Peer blames Jews for rise in anti-Semitism in UK
Story by Sapphire Hope, Daniel Martin
•
Lord Singh has made similar comments previously about the British Jewish community - AFP via Getty Images/Carl Court
A peer was booed in the House of Lords after he blamed British Jews for a rise in anti-Semitic attacks in the UK.
Lord Singh of Wimbledon provoked cries of “shame” and condemnation for his “disgraceful” remarks after he suggested attacks on British Jews had “undoubtedly” increased because they had not condemned the Israeli government’s actions in Gaza.
The crossbencher peer was also condemned by campaigners against anti-Semitism, who warned his comments risked making British Jews less safe.
Lord Singh made his remarks during a debate on Tuesday on how to protect Jewish community buildings from increased attacks.
The Government has given a record £32.4m to protect Jewish community buildings, including synagogues, schools, charities and old people’s homes. However, there has been a marked increase in arson attacks in 2026.
In the Lords debate, peers welcomed the Government’s extra security funding but warned most of it went on paying for security guards, leaving the community picking up a hefty bill for improvements to the buildings, such as reinforced doors, bomb-proof glass and alarms.
Baroness Deech said the British Jewish community faced a “perilous situation” and needed round-the-clock protection because of violent protests, arson attacks and assaults.
However, Lord Singh appeared to lay the blame at the feet of the British Jewish community. He said: “The threat to the British Jewish community has undoubtedly increased due to the Jewish community’s inexplicable silence over Israeli genocide in Gaza.”
The comments were met with booing from his fellow peers, with one shouting: “Shame.”
Lord Singh, who is Sikh, continued: “But my lord, speaking from a Sikh perspective, Palestinians in Gaza in flimsy tents destroyed by floods, and innocent care workers harassed by Israeli soldiers are also suffering through no fault of their own.
“Would the noble lord, the minister, agree that they too deserve our sympathy and practical support?”
In April, the peer also appeared to blame British Jews for the rise in anti-Jewish hatred in the UK since the Oct 7 Hamas terror attack in Israel.
He said: “My Lords, does the minister agree that it would enhance the image and security of the wonderful Jewish people if the Jewish people in this country were to issue a strong statement dissociating themselves from the policies of the Netanyahu government and the atrocities that have been committed on the people of Gaza, who are also human?”
In March, four volunteer ambulances belonging to a Jewish rescue service in Golders Green were torched. A month later, the Finchley Reform Synagogue was targeted by arsonists and, two days after, a Jewish charity in the same part of London was targeted.
In April, the Kenton United Synagogue in Harrow suffered smoke damage in an arson attack, and in May the former East London Central Synagogue building was targeted.
In June, two months after two men were stabbed in a terror attack in Golders Green, an empty pram was set alight in the communal stairwell of an apartment building which is home to mostly Jewish families.
Home Office data show Jewish people are nine times more likely than Muslims to be victims of hate crimes in the UK. In the first six months of this year, there were 1,926 anti-Semitic hate incidents in the UK.
The Community Security Trust recorded 3,700 anti-Semitic incidents in the UK in 2025. In 2024, there were 3,356 incidents and in 2023, 4,298 incidents were recorded.
The 2025 figures included a 38 per cent rise in damage and desecration of Jewish community buildings.
One of the ambulances destroyed in the Golders Green attack in March - PA Wire/Jamie Lashmar
Claudia Mendoza, the chief executive of the Jewish Leadership Council, said Lord Singh’s rhetoric risked “emboldening those who seek to intimidate, threaten and attack Jewish people in Britain”.
She said: “For a member of the House of Lords to suggest that British Jews have somehow brought attacks upon themselves is reprehensible.
“British Jews, regardless of their political opinions, are not responsible for the actions of the Israeli government, and nothing can justify targeting Jewish communities.
“At a time of rampant and rising anti-Semitism in this country, such rhetoric is deeply irresponsible and risks emboldening those who seek to intimidate, threaten and attack Jewish people in Britain.”
Lord Austin, a former Labour minister, said: “Lord Singh’s remarks are completely disgusting.
“Not only is it plain ludicrous to suggest that British Jews have brought the rise in anti-Semitism upon themselves, it’s one of the oldest anti-Semitic tropes in the book.”
Miliband imposes first Israeli settlement sanctions
The Lords debate came as Ed Miliband, the Foreign Secretary, sanctioned firms building Israeli settlements in the first penalties imposed under Labour’s shift in policy towards the Jewish state.
The sanctions, announced on Tuesday, follow Mr Miliband’s promise in September to respond to the expansion of illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank, where settler violence against Palestinians has been rising.
Mr Miliband has argued development plans in the West Bank would render a two-state solution unviable.
He said: “Protecting the two-state solution is the North Star of this Government’s approach. That is why my message on E1 is clear: do not bid, do not build, and do not profit from the destruction of the two-state solution.
“And we will not stand by while those blocking desperately needed aid deepen the intolerable suffering of civilians in Gaza. The status quo in the West Bank and Gaza is unacceptable.
“We are committed to working productively with a new Israeli government and the Palestinian Authority to advance lasting peace and security for Israelis and Palestinians alike.”
댓글 없음:
댓글 쓰기