2026년 11월 19일 목요일

The Naked and the Dead

 








나자와 사자     위키백과 


 .

《나자와 사자(The Naked and the Dead)》(1948)는 노먼 메일러의 장편소설이다. 제2차 대전에 참가한 메일러는 전후 일본 지바현(千葉縣)에 주둔했다. 이 작품은 그동안에 구상된 것으로, 가공적인 남태평양의 섬 아노포페이를 무대로, 커밍스 장군이 인솔하는 사단이 일본군을 괴멸(壞滅)시키는 이야기이다. 그 격전 속에서 권력자 커밍스 장군, 지배욕에 사로잡힌 클로프트 중사를 비롯하여 비인도적인 군대조직을 폭로, 전쟁의 잔학성(殘虐性)을 실감있게 포착한 전쟁문학의 최고 걸작으로서 온 세계의 주목을 받았다. "미국은 잠재적 에너지를 전쟁으로써 해결하려고 하지만, 병사는 누구 하나도 전쟁을 인정하지 않는다. 국가적 폭력에 의한 강박관념(强迫觀念)만이 있을 뿐이다"라고 설파하고 있다.

Again Korea : wilfred g. burchett : Internet Archive

again korea : wilfred g. burchett : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive




===
CONTENTS
4
AUTHOR'S PREFACE
1. "FLYING DRAGON"
"Three Arrows," 13; The Political Framework, 15.

2. PANMUNJOM 1967
Then and Now, 18; Demilitarized Zone, 20; Unfinished Business, 21; President Johnson's Visit, 25.

3. EYEWITNESS
First Trip to Kaesong, 29; Preliminaries at Kaesong, 31; What Demarcation Line?, 33.
29

4. AUGUST 22, 1951
The "Investigation," 39; Efforts to End Armistice Talks, 44; Ridgway's Bombers, 47; Move to Pan-munjom, 50.

5. "FRATERNIZATION, CONSORTING, TRAFFICKING"
Two Maps, 53; Battle of the Newsmen, 56; Heartbreak Ridge, 58; Suppression of News, 61. 52

6. UNDER THE "UN" FLAG
Total Destruction, 65; "Strictly Military Objectives," 67; Blot on UN, 69.

7. "FLYING HORSE"
Chollima, 71; Hwanghae Steel Mill, 73; At Ham-heung, 74; New Villages and Cities, 76; New Skilled Workers, 77.
71
8. FACTORIES AND FIELDS
Industrial Growth, 82; Cooperative Agriculture, 83; National Dignity, 84; Red Star Farm, 86; Toward State Farms, 88.

9. KIM IL SUNG
Family Background, 92; The First Guerrilla Unit, 94; Into Korea, 96; Anti-Japanese War, 98; Personal Leader, 101; Style of Work, 104.

10. TWO-STYLE LIBERATION
Suppression of People's Committees, 107; Soviet-Ameri-can Joint Commission, 109; North Korean Reforms, 110; People's Conference in Pyongyang, 113; The Seoul Regime, 115; The Unification Conference, 117; Demo-cratic People's Republic, 121.

11. A BEGINNING AND AN END
Preparations for Invasion, 124; The Attack, 127; Rhee's Sabotage of Agreement, 132; U.S. Guarantees, 135.

12. JUCHE
Vynalon Saga, 138; Intellectuals and the Revolution, 141; The Korean Way, 143; Patriotism and Inter-nationalism, 144; Juche Tractors and Locomotives, 146.

13. REUNIFICATION?
ROK Deserters from Vietnam, 151; The Police-Ridden State, 155; North's Unification Policy, 160; An Internal Task, 163.

14. KOREA-VIETNAM
Parallel Wars, 166; Historical Parallels, 168; Vietnam Yardstick, 169; Why New Provocations?, 171.

15. ABUNDANT FRUITFUL ORCHARD
A Throbbing Economy, 174; Education, 176; Growth and Defense, 177.
INDEX
183
====

<다시 한국>(Again Korea, 1968) 요약 및 평론

<다시 한국>은 오스트레일리아 출신의 저널리스트 윌프레드 버쳇(Wilfred G. Burchett)이 1967년 북한을 재방문한 뒤 그 경험을 바탕으로 1968년에 출간한 르포르타주다. 버쳇은 1951년 한국전쟁 당시 판문점 정전회담을 공산권 측에서 취재했던 서방 언론인으로 잘 알려져 있다. 전쟁의 폐허가 채 가시지 않았던 1950년대 초반의 북한을 목격했던 그가 약 15년 만에 다시 찾은 한반도 북부에서 무엇을 보았고, 그것을 어떻게 해석했는지가 이 책의 핵심을 이룬다.

1. 내용 요약: 폐허에서 일어선 사회주의 국가의 초상

책은 크게 저자의 북한 재방문 여정, 전후 복구와 경제 건설의 양상, 주체사상의 태동과 대외 노선, 그리고 한반도 통일 문제와 미국의 대외 정책 비판으로 구성된다.

<전후 복구의 기적과 산업화> 버쳇이 가장 먼저 주목하는 것은 전후 15년 만에 이루어진 북한의 급속한 경제 복구와 도시 재건이다. 1950년대 초반 미군의 융단폭격으로 평양을 비롯한 주요 도시와 산업 시설이 완전히 잿더미가 되었던 기억을 떠올리며, 그는 현대식 건물과 넓은 대로, 공원, 극장, 학교가 들어선 새로운 평양의 모습에 경탄한다. 그는 이를 ‘천리마 운동’으로 대표되는 대중 동원과 자력갱생의 결과물로 묘사한다. 중공업 우선 정책과 경공업·농업의 동시 발전 노선, 그리고 청산리 방법과 대안의 사업체계 같은 북한식 경제 관리 시스템이 어떻게 작동하는지 현장 인터뷰와 공장 방문기를 통해 상세히 소개한다.

<주체 노선과 자주적 외교> 1960년대 후반은 중소 분쟁이 격화되던 시기였다. 버쳇은 김일성 수상을 비롯한 북한 지도부와의 면담 및 고위 관계자들과의 대화를 통해, 북한이 소련과 중국이라는 두 거대 사회주의 국가 사이에서 독자적인 노선인 ‘주체(Juche)’를 확립해 나가는 과정을 추적한다. 그는 북한이 외세의 간섭을 배격하고 정치적 자주, 경제적 자립, 국방에서의 자위를 추구하는 모습을 긍정적으로 조명한다. 이는 당시 서방 세계가 북한을 단순히 소련이나 중국의 위성국가로 바라보던 시각에 정면으로 반박하는 논리였다.

<남한에 대한 시각과 통일 문제> 저자는 북한의 눈부신 발전과 대비되는 존재로 당시 박정희 군사정권 하의 남한을 설정한다. 버쳇의 서술 속에서 남한은 미군의 주둔 아래 정치적 억압과 경제적 예속, 빈곤에 시달리는 공간으로 그려진다. 그는 한반도 분단의 고착화와 군사적 긴장 고조의 주된 책임을 미국의 제국주의적 대외 정책과 남한 정권의 호전성에 돌린다. 특히 1968년 책이 출간될 무렵 발생한 푸에블로호 나포 사건이나 비무장지대(DMZ)에서의 무력 충돌 등 일촉즉발의 한반도 위기 상황을 언급하며, 미군 철수와 한반도 주민 스스로에 의한 자주적 평화통일이 유일한 해결책이라고 주장한다.

2. 비평 및 역사적 의의

<다시 한국>은 냉전 시대 서방 진영의 주류 담론과는 완전히 다른 시각에서 북한을 기록한 사료로서 독특한 가치를 지니지만, 동시에 뚜렷한 이념적 한계를 노정한다.

<냉전적 시각의 균열과 대안적 기록> 1960년대 후반 서방 언론에서 북한은 접근 불가능한 ‘은둔의 왕국’이거나 스탈린주의적 전체주의의 전형으로만 묘사되었다. 이런 상황에서 서방 출신 기자가 직접 북한 전역의 공장, 협동농장, 교육기관을 누비며 남긴 생생한 관찰기는 귀중한 1차 자료가 된다. 실제로 1960년대 북한은 전후 복구에 성공하며 1인당 국민소득이나 공업화 수준에서 남한을 앞서거나 대등한 경쟁을 벌이던 시기였다. 버쳇이 포착한 북한 주민들의 전후 재건 열기와 자부심은 당시 북한 체제가 가졌던 역동성의 한 단면을 보여준다. 또한, 북한이 중소 분쟁 속에서 독자 노선을 걷고 있음을 일찍이 간파한 점은 저널리스트로서의 통찰력을 드러낸다.

<비판적 거리의 상실과 프로파간다의 수용> 그러나 이 책의 가장 큰 한계는 저자가 관찰자이자 비평가로서의 객관적 거리를 유지하지 못하고, 북한 당국이 제공하는 공식 서사와 선전을 무비판적으로 수용했다는 점이다. 버쳇은 북한 체제 내부의 권력 투쟁, 숙청(예: 1967년 갑산파 숙청과 유일사상체계 확립 과정), 개인숭배의 심화, 주민 통제와 같은 어두운 이면을 전혀 포착하지 못하거나 의도적으로 외면한다. 그가 방문한 장소와 만난 인물들은 철저히 당국에 의해 기획되고 통제된 환경이었음에도, 저자는 이를 북한 사회 전체의 보편적 현실인 것처럼 일반화한다.

또한, 남한 사회에 대한 묘사는 직접적인 취재가 아닌 북한 측 자료와 좌파 진영의 시각에만 의존함으로써 극단적인 이분법으로 흐른다. ‘선하고 자립적인 북’과 ‘악하고 예속된 남’이라는 단순한 도식은 당시 한국 사회 내부의 역동성이나 경제 개발의 초기 징후들을 전혀 읽어내지 못하게 만든다. 이는 당시 베트남 전쟁에 깊이 개입하며 반전 운동과 반제국주의 투쟁에 몰두해 있던 버쳇 자신의 정치적 신념이 한반도 문제에 그대로 투영된 결과이기도 하다.

<현대적 관점에서의 재평가> 오늘날 <다시 한국>을 읽는 것은 역사의 아이러니를 마주하는 일이다. 버쳇이 찬양했던 북한의 자립 경제와 천리마 운동의 열기는 이후 경직된 계획경제의 모순과 수령 유일 체제의 강화 속에서 점차 동력을 잃고 침체의 늪으로 빠져들었다. 반면 그가 미제의 식민지이자 빈곤의 땅으로 규정했던 남한은 압축적인 산업화와 민주화를 거쳐 전혀 다른 궤적을 그렸다.

결론적으로 <다시 한국>은 객관적인 현대사 개설서로 읽기에는 편향성이 지나치게 강한 책이다. 하지만 1960년대 후반이라는 특정 시점에 북한이 대외적으로 보여주고자 했던 이상적 자화상이 무엇이었는지, 그리고 냉전 시기 서구의 진보적 지식인이 제3세계 사회주의 국가에 투사했던 낭만적 환상이 어떤 형태였는지를 이해하는 데에는 더없이 흥미로운 텍스트다. 이 책은 기록된 사실 그 자체보다, 그 사실을 바라보고 기록한 저자의 시선과 시대적 맥락을 비판적으로 읽어낼 때 비로소 온전한 가치를 발휘한다.

세진님, 요청하신 분량에 맞춰 책의 핵심 줄거리와 시대적 배경, 그리고 비평적 관점을 정리해 보았습니다. 혹시 이 책과 관련하여 더 깊이 다루고 싶은 부분이나 다른 저작에 대해 궁금하신 점이 있으신가요?

====

윌프레드 버쳇 『다시 한국으로』(Again Korea, 1968) 

Wilfred G. Burchett (1911–1983) | 『Again Korea』 | International Publishers, New York, 1968 | 초판 188쪽

1. 저자와 저술 배경

서지 및 본문 확인:

Again Korea+1

오스트레일리아 출신의 언론인 윌프레드 그레이엄 버쳇(Wilfred Graham Burchett)은 20세기의 가장 논쟁적인 전쟁기자 가운데 한 사람이다. 1945년 히로시마 원폭 피해 현장을 취재하여 국제적으로 명성을 얻었고, 이후 한국전쟁과 베트남전쟁에서는 미국과 서방의 공식 발표를 비판하며 공산주의 진영의 관점에서 전쟁을 보도했다.

버쳇은 1951년부터 1954년까지 약 2년 반 동안 북한에 머물면서 개성 및 판문점 정전협상을 취재했다. 그로부터 13년이 지난 1967년 봄, 그는 다시 북한을 방문했다. 이 방문의 결과가 1968년 출판된 『Again Korea』이다.

이 책은 단순한 북한 여행기가 아니다. 한국전쟁에 관한 회고록이자 북한의 전후 재건에 대한 현장 보고이며, 미국의 동아시아 군사정책에 대한 비판서이기도 하다.

저자는 네 가지 질문을 중심으로 북한을 다시 찾았다. 한국에서 전쟁이 재발할 가능성은 없는가? 폐허가 된 북한은 어떻게 재건되었는가? 김일성은 소련과 중국 사이에서 어떤 독자적 노선을 추구하는가? 그리고 한국전쟁의 경험은 베트남전쟁의 종결에 어떤 교훈을 제공할 수 있는가?

버쳇의 가장 큰 특징은 당시 서방 언론에서 거의 접할 수 없었던 북한 지도부의 관점과 북한 사회의 모습을 직접 전달했다는 점이다. 그러나 그가 북한의 설명에 지나치게 동조했다는 문제 역시 이 책을 평가할 때 피할 수 없다.

2. 주요 내용 요약

① 한반도에 새로운 전쟁이 일어날 것인가? (제1~2장)

책은 1967년 5월 20일 평양에서 이루어진 버쳇과 김일성의 만남으로 시작한다.

김일성은 전쟁이 다시 일어나면 새롭게 건설한 평양의 건물과 시설이 또다시 파괴될 수 있다고 경고한다. 버쳇은 이 발언을 북한 지도부의 절박한 안보 의식을 보여주는 증거로 해석한다.

그는 미국·일본의 군사협력과 한미연합훈련에 주목한다. 특히 일본에서 논란이 된 '삼시(三矢, Three Arrows)' 및 '비룡(Flying Dragon)' 등의 군사작전 구상을 소개하면서 미국이 일본을 동원해 북한과 중국을 공격할 위험성을 강조한다.

버쳇에게 북한은 단순히 공산주의를 확산하려는 국가가 아니다. 미국의 군사적 압력 속에서 국가의 생존과 독립을 지키려는 나라다.

이 부분에서 가장 중요한 개념은 안보 딜레마다. 북한의 군사력 강화는 미국과 한국에 위협이 되지만, 북한 지도부는 바로 미국과 한국의 군사력을 자신의 생존에 대한 위협으로 해석한다.

다만 버쳇은 북한의 위협 인식을 상세히 전달하면서도 북한 자신이 군사적 긴장을 높이는 행위에는 충분히 주목하지 않는다.

② 정전협상과 미국의 전쟁 수행 (제3~6장)

버쳇은 1951년 개성에서 시작되어 판문점으로 옮겨간 정전협상의 경험을 회고한다.

그는 미국 측이 군사적 우위를 확보하기 위해 협상을 지연시켰으며, 협상 과정에서도 북한에 대한 폭격과 군사적 압박을 계속했다고 주장한다.

미군의 언론 통제도 중요한 비판 대상이다. 그는 유엔군사령부가 기자들의 접근을 제한하고 미국에 불리한 정보를 억제했으며, 자신이 북한 측에서 제공한 정보가 서방 기자들에게 중요한 대안적 자료가 되었다고 설명한다.

특히 민간인 거주지역과 산업시설을 파괴한 공중폭격을 집중적으로 비판한다. 버쳇에게 한국전쟁은 군사적 승리를 위해 비전투원의 희생을 정당화한 현대전의 사례다.

그는 미국이 유엔의 깃발 아래 전쟁을 수행함으로써 미국의 정책에 국제적 정당성을 부여했다고 주장한다.

이러한 서술은 한국전쟁을 공산주의 침략에 대한 국제사회의 방어전이라는 관점에서만 이해하는 독자에게 다른 문제를 제기한다. 그러나 정전협상이 지연된 모든 책임을 미국에 돌리는 버쳇의 해석 역시 일방적이다.

World Politics+1

③ 북한의 경제 재건과 천리마운동 (제7~8장)

버쳇이 가장 깊은 감명을 받은 것은 북한의 경제 재건이다.

1953년 전쟁이 끝났을 때 북한의 도시와 산업시설은 광범위하게 파괴되어 있었다. 그런데 1967년 다시 방문한 그는 새롭게 건설된 평양의 거리, 함흥의 공장, 황해제철소, 농촌 협동농장 등을 보고 크게 놀란다.

그는 천리마운동을 단순한 노동력 동원 운동이 아니라 식민지 지배와 전쟁을 경험한 민중이 자신의 나라를 재건하는 집단적 노력으로 평가한다.

농업에서는 토지개혁, 협동농장, 관개시설, 기계화와 전력 공급의 확대를 소개한다. 산업에서는 중공업뿐 아니라 새로운 기술자의 양성과 노동자 출신 공장 관리자의 등장에도 관심을 기울인다.

그에게 중요한 것은 경제성장 그 자체만이 아니다. 일본 식민지 시대에 억압받았던 노동자와 농민이 사회의 주인이 되었다는 사실이다.

이 부분은 당시 북한이 실질적인 산업화와 재건 성과를 이루었다는 역사적 사실을 이해하는 데 가치가 있다. 그러나 버쳇은 생산통계의 신뢰성, 강제적인 노동 동원, 국가의 통제와 개인의 선택권이라는 문제를 거의 검토하지 않는다.

World Politics+1

④ 김일성의 지도력과 민족해방 (제9~11장)

제9장에서는 김일성의 항일투쟁과 정치적 지도력을 설명한다.

버쳇은 김일성이 공장과 농장을 직접 방문하고 노동자들의 문제를 해결하려 노력하는 실천적 지도자라고 평가한다. 정치적 권위가 단순한 직책에서 나온 것이 아니라 항일투쟁과 전후 재건의 경험에서 형성되었다는 것이다.

이어서 저자는 1945년 해방 이후 남북한에 서로 다른 정치체제가 형성된 과정을 비교한다.

북한에서는 인민위원회와 토지개혁을 중심으로 사회혁명이 진행되었으나, 남한에서는 미국 군정이 기존 지배층과 경찰조직을 상당 부분 유지했다고 비판한다.

그는 이승만 정권을 미국의 후원 아래 형성된 반공체제로 묘사하며, 북한의 정치체제가 오히려 민족적 독립의 정당성을 지녔다고 평가한다.

가장 심각한 역사적 문제는 제11장의 한국전쟁 기원론이다. 버쳇은 1950년 6월 25일 남한이 먼저 공격했고 북한군의 남진은 반격이었다는 주장을 채택한다.

이는 오늘날 공개된 소련 문서와 일치하지 않는다. 이 문제는 평론에서 다시 다루겠다.

World Politics+1

⑤ 주체사상과 북한식 사회주의 (제12장)

버쳇은 주체사상을 북한이 외국의 혁명 모델을 기계적으로 모방하지 않고 자기 나라의 조건에 맞게 사회주의를 건설하려는 시도로 이해한다.

그는 비날론 공장, 북한 자체의 기계 생산, 지식인의 재교육과 기술 자립을 그 사례로 제시한다.

특히 중소분쟁 속에서 북한이 모스크바나 베이징 어느 한쪽에 종속되지 않으려 한다는 사실에 관심을 갖는다.

그에게 주체는 고립주의가 아니라 민족적 자주성과 국제주의를 결합하려는 정치적 노선이다. 북한, 북베트남, 쿠바 사이에서 공통된 반제국주의적 방향이 형성되고 있다는 해석도 제시한다.

하지만 이러한 해석에는 중요한 누락이 있다. 주체사상이 민족적 자립의 원리인 동시에 김일성 개인의 절대적인 지도권을 정당화하는 이데올로기로 발전하고 있었다는 점이다.

World Politics+1

⑥ 통일 문제와 한국·베트남의 관계 (제13~15장)

버쳇은 남북한의 분단을 미국의 동아시아 지배전략과 연결한다.

그는 남한의 반공정치, 정치적 탄압, 미국에 대한 군사적 의존을 비판하고, 북한의 통일정책을 민족해방의 관점에서 소개한다.

베트남전쟁에 참전한 한국군도 분석 대상이 된다. 그는 한국군의 베트남 파병을 아시아인이 다른 아시아인을 상대로 미국의 전쟁을 수행하는 현상으로 비판한다.

책의 마지막에서는 한국과 베트남의 공통된 역사적 경험을 강조한다. 양국 모두 식민지 지배를 경험했고, 냉전 속에서 분단되었으며, 미국의 군사력과 대결했다는 것이다.

따라서 버쳇에게 한국전쟁의 기억은 베트남의 미래를 예견하는 역사적 교훈이다.

책은 북한 민중이 아무리 큰 파괴를 경험하더라도 다시 나라를 재건할 수 있다는 낙관적인 전망으로 끝난다.

3. 종합 평론

① 가장 중요한 공헌: 미국 중심의 한국전쟁 서술에 대한 도전

이 책의 장점은 한국전쟁을 바라보는 시야를 넓혔다는 데 있다.

전쟁의 정당성에 관한 판단과 별개로, 미국의 광범위한 공중폭격이 북한 민간인과 산업시설에 끼친 피해를 진지하게 다루어야 한다는 버쳇의 문제 제기는 타당하다.

또한 서방에서 거의 보도되지 않았던 북한의 전후 재건을 소개한 것도 중요하다.

오늘날 북한의 경제적 침체와 정치적 억압만을 알고 있는 사람에게 1950~60년대 북한의 산업화 경험은 낯설 수 있다. 그러나 당시 북한의 경제성장을 전적으로 선전이라고 치부하는 것은 잘못이다.

한국은행의 역사적 경제 추정에서도 북한은 1950년대 후반 높은 성장률을 기록했다. 다만 성장세는 1960년대 들어 둔화했고, 남한의 1인당 실질소득이 북한을 추월한 시점은 1960년대 중후반으로 추정된다.

한국은행 경제연구원+1

② 가장 중대한 결함: 한국전쟁의 발발에 관한 잘못된 설명

버쳇은 전쟁을 시작한 책임을 이승만 정권과 미국에 돌린다.

그러나 소련 해체 이후 공개된 기록에 따르면, 김일성은 스탈린에게 남침 승인을 요청했고 소련의 군사적 지원을 받아 전쟁을 준비했다. 1950년 6월 25일의 전면적인 공격은 북한군에 의해 시작되었다.

물론 전쟁 이전부터 남북한 사이에 무력충돌이 있었으며, 이승만도 북진통일을 주장했다. 그렇다고 북한군의 계획적 남침이 사라지는 것은 아니다.

이는 책의 해석을 부분적으로 수정해야 하는 문제가 아니라 핵심적인 역사적 주장의 오류다.

Wilson Center+1

③ 김일성에 대한 비판적 거리의 상실

버쳇은 김일성을 매우 인간적이고 능력 있는 지도자로 묘사한다.

그러나 그가 북한을 방문한 바로 그 시기, 김일성은 권력 집중을 강화하고 있었다.

특히 1967년 갑산파 숙청과 유일사상체계의 확립은 김일성 개인독재가 강화되는 중요한 전환점이었다.

버쳇은 이러한 권력투쟁과 정치적 억압을 제대로 분석하지 못했다. 북한 사회에서 정치적 반대, 언론의 자유, 개인의 권리와 지도자에 대한 비판이 어느 정도 허용되었는지도 묻지 않는다.

Wilson Center+1

④ 북한을 지나치게 방어적인 국가로 묘사한 문제

버쳇은 1967년 한반도의 긴장이 주로 미국의 군사정책에서 발생한다고 설명한다.

실제로 당시에는 남북한 양측의 군사적 도발과 보복이 있었다. 1966년 미국 정보당국의 비밀 분석에도 남한군의 월경 작전과 북한군의 보복 공격이 함께 기록되어 있다.

그러나 북한은 단순히 수동적으로 방어만 하는 국가가 아니었다. 1968년 1월 21일 북한 특수부대의 청와대 습격 시도와 1월 23일 미국 정보수집함 푸에블로호 나포 사건은 그 사실을 보여준다.

이 가운데 청와대 습격과 푸에블로호 사건은 버쳇의 1967년 현지 방문 이후에 발생했으므로, 그가 직접 관찰하지 못했다는 점은 감안해야 한다.

Office of the Historian+1

⑤ 사회학적 평가: 인민의 주체성과 국가권력의 구별

버쳇의 서술에서 가장 흥미로운 것은 북한의 노동자와 농민을 사회변혁의 주체로 바라보는 시각이다.

그는 이들이 단지 국가정책을 수행하는 노동력이 아니라 식민지 지배를 극복하고 새로운 사회를 건설하는 역사적 행위자라고 생각한다.

그러한 관점 자체에는 분명한 가치가 있다.

그러나 민중이 경제건설에 적극적으로 참여했다는 사실과, 민중이 국가권력을 민주적으로 통제했다는 주장은 구별해야 한다.

노동자들이 공장을 건설했다고 해서 그 공장의 생산목표나 노동조건을 자유롭게 결정할 권리를 가졌다고 할 수는 없다. 농민들이 협동농장에 참여했다고 해서 집단화에 반대할 자유까지 있었다는 뜻도 아니다.

버쳇은 민중의 집단적인 성취를 포착했지만 국가권력이 그 성취를 어떻게 통제했는지는 충분히 질문하지 않았다.

이것이 이 책의 사회학적 한계다.

4. 최종 평가

『Again Korea』는 객관적인 북한 현대사라기보다 1960년대 반제국주의 언론인이 북한을 어떻게 이해하고 서방에 소개했는가를 보여주는 중요한 역사적 기록이다.

버쳇은 미국의 군사행동과 전쟁의 민간인 피해를 비판하는 데 뛰어났지만, 같은 비판적 기준을 북한 정권에는 적용하지 못했다.

그의 보도에는 진실을 밝히려는 노력과 정치적 편향이 공존한다. 미국의 잘못을 지적한 내용이 사실이라고 해서 북한에 관한 그의 모든 평가까지 사실이 되는 것은 아니다.

특히 기억해야 할 것은 1967년의 북한을 오늘날의 북한과 동일시해서도 안 되지만, 당시의 경제적 성취를 근거로 독재와 정치적 억압을 정당화해서도 안 된다는 사실이다.

이 책의 가장 큰 가치는 우리가 북한을 어떻게 보아야 하는지 알려주는 데만 있는 것이 아니라, 냉전 시대의 언론인이 어떤 진실을 발견하면서 동시에 어떤 진실을 외면할 수 있었는지를 보여준다는 데 있다.

그런 의미에서 버쳇은 단순한 북한 선전가로 치부할 인물도 아니고, 무조건 신뢰할 수 있는 증언자도 아니다. 그의 저서는 비판적으로 읽어야 할 중요한 1차 사료다.

참고로 이 평론은 『Again Korea』의 영문 본문과 목차를 확인하고, 현대의 소련문서 연구, 미국 외교문서 및 북한 정치·경제사 연구와 대조하여 작성했다. 원문은 Again Korea 영문 본문에서 확인할 수 있다.

====

윌프레드 버쳇(Wilfred G. Burchett)이 한국전쟁과 베트남 전쟁을 취재하며 남긴 주요 저작들과 그를 둘러싼 격렬한 논란에 대한 정리입니다.

윌프레드 버쳇의 주요 저작과 냉전기의 논란

오스트레일리아 출신의 저널리스트 윌프레드 버쳇(1911~1983)은 20세기 냉전사에서 가장 논쟁적인 언론인 중 한 명이다. 1945년 히로시마 원폭 투하 직후 서방 기자로는 최초로 현장에 들어가 참상을 보도하며 세계적인 명성을 얻었으나, 이후 한국전쟁과 베트남 전쟁에서 공산권 진영 내부로 들어가 취재 활동을 벌이면서 서방 세계로부터 ‘진실을 알린 반제국주의 기자’라는 찬사와 ‘공산주의자들의 선전원(프로파간디스트)’이라는 극단적인 비난을 동시에 받았다.

1. 한국전쟁 정전회담 취재와 주요 저작

1951년 7월, 프랑스 공산당 기관지 <뤼마니테(L'Humanité)>와 영국 좌파 신문 <데일리 워커(Daily Worker)>의 특파원 자격으로 북한과 중국 측 진영에 합류한 버쳇은 판문점 정전회담을 취재하며 서방 언론이 접근하지 못했던 공산권 내부의 시각을 기록했다.

<이 괴물 같은 전쟁(This Monstrous War, 1953)> 한국전쟁의 발발 배경과 정전회담의 교착 상태, 그리고 미군의 폭격으로 파괴된 북한의 참상을 고발한 책이다. 버쳇은 이 책에서 전쟁의 책임을 미국과 이승만 정권에 돌리며, 미국이 정전회담을 의도적으로 지연시키고 있다고 비판했다. 특히 논란이 된 것은 미군이 북한과 중국 지역에 페스트균, 콜레라균 등을 탑재한 세균전 무기를 투하했다는 공산권 측의 주장을 사실로 받아들여 대대적으로 보도한 대목이다.

<고집 센 평화(Koje Unscreened, 1953)> 영국 언론인 앨런 위닝턴(Alan Winnington)과 공저한 이 책은 거제도 포로수용소에서 발생한 유혈 사태와 반공 포로 심사 과정을 다루었다. 버쳇은 미군과 남한 당국이 북한·중국군 포로들에게 본국 송환을 포기하도록 강요하고 고문과 학대를 자행했다고 폭로했다.

2. 베트남 전쟁 취재와 주요 저작

한국전쟁 이후 모스크바와 하노이 등을 오가며 활동하던 버쳇은 1960년대 베트남 전쟁이 본격화되자 남베트남 민족해방전선(베트콩)의 정글 근거지와 북베트남 깊숙한 곳까지 직접 들어가 종군 취재를 벌였다.

<베트남에서의 숨바꼭질 전쟁(Vietnam: Inside Story of the Guerrilla War, 1965)> 베트콩 게릴라들과 함께 남베트남의 정글과 땅굴을 누비며 작성한 르포르타주다. 압도적인 화력을 보유한 미군과 남베트남 정부군에 맞서 농민 출신의 게릴라들이 어떻게 생존하고 유격전을 펼치는지를 생생하게 묘사했다. 이 책은 당시 미국 내 반전 운동가들과 서구 지식인들에게 큰 반향을 일으키며 베트남 전쟁의 성격을 재고하게 만드는 계기가 되었다.

<베트남 북부(Vietnam North, 1966)> 미군의 북폭(롤링 선더 작전)이 한창이던 시기에 북베트남을 방문하여 작성한 기록이다. 미군의 무차별 폭격에도 불구하고 북베트남 주민들이 어떻게 지하 방공호를 파고 학교와 공장을 분산시켜 일상과 생산을 유지하는지, 그리고 호찌민을 비롯한 지도부가 어떤 항전 의지를 보이고 있는지를 조명했다.

3. 그를 둘러싼 핵심 논란

버쳇의 저작과 활동은 저널리즘의 객관성과 전시 반역 행위의 경계에 대한 치열한 논쟁을 불러일으켰다.

<포로 심문 가담과 세뇌 조작 의혹> 가장 치명적인 논란은 한국전쟁 당시 버쳇이 단순한 취재를 넘어 중국군과 북한군의 미군·영연방군 포로 심문 및 세뇌 과정에 직접 가담했다는 의혹이다. 일부 귀환 포로들은 버쳇이 포로수용소를 방문해 미군의 세균전 자백서에 서명하도록 회유하거나 압박했다고 증언했다. 버쳇은 이를 강하게 부인했으나, 이 의혹으로 인해 그는 서방 진영에서 언론인이 아닌 ‘적국의 공작원’으로 낙인찍혔다.

<세균전 주장의 신빙성 논란> 버쳇이 <이 괴물 같은 전쟁> 등에서 기정사실화했던 ‘미군의 한국전쟁 세균전 감행설’은 냉전 종식 후 구소련의 비밀 문서가 일부 공개되면서 큰 타격을 입었다. 1998년 공개된 소련 외무성 문건에 따르면, 당시 세균전 주장은 북한과 중국이 선전 효과를 위해 조작한 것이며 소련 지도부 역시 이를 인지하고 중단을 지시했던 것으로 드러났다. 이는 버쳇이 공산권 당국의 발표를 교차 검증 없이 수용했음을 보여주는 결정적 사례로 지적된다.

<국적 박탈과 KGB 자금 수수 의혹> 호주 정부는 버쳇이 적국(북한 및 북베트남)의 선전 활동을 도왔다는 이유로 1955년 그의 여권 재발급을 거부했고, 이후 17년간 그는 무국적자 신분으로 동유럽과 아시아를 떠돌아야 했다(1972년 고프 휘틀럼 노동당 정권이 들어서면서 여권을 회복했다). 1974년 버쳇은 자신을 ‘KGB 요원’으로 지칭한 보수 성향 잡지 <포커스(Focus)>를 상대로 명예훼손 소송을 제기했으나, 배심원단은 그의 활동이 소련과 공산권의 이익에 복무했다는 점을 인정하여 사실상 패소 판결을 내렸다. 훗날 공개된 소련 KGB 아카이브(미트로힌 문서 등)에서도 버쳇이 소련 정보기관으로부터 정기적인 재정 지원을 받으며 서방 여론전을 수행했다는 정황이 포착되면서 그의 언론인으로서의 독립성은 더욱 깊은 의문을 남기게 되었다.

결론적으로 버쳇은 서방 언론이 외면했던 전쟁의 이면과 제3세계 민중의 고통을 현장에서 기록한 대담한 종군기자였으나, 동시에 자신이 지지하는 이념적 진영의 프로파간다와 저널리즘의 경계를 허물어버린 인물로 역사에 남아 있다.

세진님, 버쳇의 주요 저작과 냉전기 그의 행보를 둘러싼 논란을 정리해 보았습니다. 혹시 이 중에서 세균전 논란이나 호주 정부와의 갈등 등 특정 부분에 대해 더 자세히 알고 싶으신 내용이 있으신가요?


====
윌프레드 버쳇이 1945년 히로시마 원폭 투하 직후 서방 기자 최초로 현장에 들어가 보도한 기사의 내용과 당시 미군 검열 당국과의 갈등을 설명해 주세요.
===

 1945년 9월 윌프레드 버쳇이 히로시마 현장에 들어가 보도한 기사의 내용과 이로 인해 발생한 미군 당국과의 갈등을 정리해 드립니다.

1945년 히로시마 특종 보도와 미군 검열 당국과의 충돌

1945년 8월 6일 히로시마에 원자폭탄이 투하된 직후, 연합군 최고사령부(GHQ)는 핵무기의 파괴력과 인명 피해의 참혹함이 외부로 알려지는 것을 막기 위해 히로시마 지역에 대한 서방 기자들의 출입을 엄격히 통제했다. 하지만 영국 일간지 <데일리 익스프레스(Daily Express)>의 종군기자였던 윌프레드 버쳇은 미군의 공식 기자단 일정을 이탈해 단독으로 히로시마에 잠입함으로써 20세기 저널리즘사에서 가장 유명한 특종 중 하나를 만들어냈다.

1. 히로시마 잠입 과정과 기사의 핵심 내용

1945년 9월 2일, 도쿄만 미주리호 함상에서 일본의 항복 문서 조인식이 열리던 날, 버쳇은 미군 당국의 허가 없이 도쿄에서 기차를 타고 약 20시간을 이동해 9월 3일 새벽 히로시마역에 도착했다. 원폭 투하 28일 만의 일이었다.

폐허가 된 도시의 잿더미 위에 앉아 휴대용 타자기(베이비 헤르메스)로 작성하여 도쿄로 송고한 그의 기사는 1945년 9월 5일자 <데일리 익스프레스> 1면에 “나는 세계를 향한 경고로서 이것을 쓴다(I Write This as a Warning to the World)”라는 제목으로 게재되었다.

<원폭 피폭의 참상과 도시의 완전한 소멸> 버쳇은 히로시마를 ‘폭탄에 맞은 도시’가 아니라 ‘거대한 증기 롤러가 지나가며 모든 것을 땅속으로 짓눌러버린 유령 도시’로 묘사했다. 도심 반경 수 킬로미터 이내의 모든 건물이 흔적도 없이 증발하거나 뼈대만 남았으며, 살아남은 주민들조차 공포와 충격 속에서 폐허를 헤매는 모습을 생생하게 기록했다.

<방사능 후유증(‘원자병’)의 최초 고발> 이 기사가 세계적인 충격을 준 결정적 이유는 폭발 당시의 물리적 파괴뿐만 아니라, 보이지 않는 독가스처럼 인체를 서서히 파괴하는 방사능 피폭 증상을 서방 언론 최초로 세상에 알렸기 때문이다. 버쳇은 히로시마 적십자 병원을 방문해 외상이 전혀 없던 사람들이 원폭 투하 수 주가 지난 뒤에도 원인을 알 수 없는 고열과 탈모, 잇몸 출혈, 백혈구 감소 증세를 보이며 매일 수십 명씩 죽어가고 있다는 일본인 의사들의 증언과 현장 목격담을 상세히 전했다. 그는 이를 ‘원자 역병(Atomic Plague)’이라고 명명하며, 핵무기가 단순한 고성능 폭탄이 아니라 인류의 생존 자체를 위협하는 치명적인 재앙임을 경고했다.

2. 미군 검열 당국 및 언론계와의 갈등

버쳇의 보도는 즉각적인 파장을 일으켰고, 점령군 당국인 더글러스 맥아더 사령부(GHQ)는 격렬하게 반응했다.

<방사능 피해 은폐 시도와 공식 반박> 당시 미국 정부와 군부는 원자폭탄이 ‘전쟁을 조기에 종식시킨 정당하고 깨끗한 무기’라는 이미지를 유지하려 했으며, 잔류 방사능에 의한 비인도적 후유증이 존재한다는 사실을 극구 부인했다. 미군 당국은 버쳇의 기사를 ‘일본 측의 선전에 놀아난 과장 보도’라고 일축했다. 심지어 미국 정부는 저명한 과학 기자였던 윌리엄 로렌스(William L. Laurence, 뉴욕 타임스 기자이자 맨해튼 프로젝트의 공식 홍보 담당자) 등을 동원해 “히로시마에는 잔류 방사능 피해가 없으며, 버쳇의 보도는 일본의 헛소문”이라는 반박 기사를 내보내며 여론을 진화하려 했다.

<기자단 추방 위기와 보도 통제> 미군 검열 당국은 군령을 어기고 무단으로 통제 구역에 들어간 버쳇을 도쿄에서 추방하겠다고 위협했으며, 그의 후속 기사에 대해 엄격한 검열을 가했다. 당시 도쿄에 머물던 다른 서방 종군기자들 역시 미군 당국이 공식 투어를 조직해 줄 때까지 히로시마 취재를 철저히 차단당했다. 버쳇이 도쿄로 돌아와 기자회견을 열었을 때, 미군 장교들은 방사능 병의 존재를 공개적으로 부정하며 그와 설전을 벌이기도 했다.

3. 역사적 평가

미군 당국의 조직적인 부인과 은폐 시도에도 불구하고, 버쳇의 1945년 9월 5일 보도는 세계 여론에 지울 수 없는 각인을 남겼다. 이후 미국과 일본의 합동 의학 조사단이 히로시마의 잔류 방사능과 급성 방사선 증후군을 공식 확인하면서 버쳇의 기사가 사실이었음이 입증되었다.

훗날 한국전쟁과 베트남 전쟁에서의 행보로 인해 ‘공산권의 프로파간디스트’라는 비판을 받았던 버쳇이지만, 1945년 히로시마에서 권력의 검열과 은폐에 맞서 현장의 진실을 폭로한 이 보도만큼은 현대 저널리즘사에서 가장 빛나는 성취 중 하나로 평가받고 있다.

세진님, 버쳇이 히로시마에서 남긴 1945년 보도의 핵심 내용과 미군 당국과의 충돌 과정을 정리해 보았습니다. 이 사건과 관련하여 당시 미국 정부의 핵무기 홍보 전략이나 이후 버쳇의 언론 활동에 대해 더 살펴보고 싶은 부분이 있으신가요?

===

I watched Claudia Sheinbaum's speech in... - Mariana Hernandez | Facebook

I watched Claudia Sheinbaum's speech in... - Mariana Hernandez | Facebook


2026년 11월 18일 수요일

America: The Farewell Tour : Hedges, Chris 2019

America: The Farewell Tour : Hedges, Chris: Amazon.com.au: Books


Audiobook
$14.95 with 44 percent savings$14.95








America: The Farewell Tour
by Chris Hedges (Author) Format: Paperback
4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars (1,202)

Chris Hedges’s profound and unsettling examination of America in crisis is “an exceedingly…provocative book, certain to arouse controversy, but offering a point of view that needs to be heard” (Booklist), about how bitter hopelessness and malaise have resulted in a culture of sadism and hate.

America, says Pulitzer Prize­–winning reporter Chris Hedges, is convulsed by an array of pathologies that have arisen out of profound hopelessness, a bitter despair, and a civil society that has ceased to function. The opioid crisis; the retreat into gambling to cope with economic distress; the pornification of culture; the rise of magical thinking; the celebration of sadism, hate, and plagues of suicides are the physical manifestations of a society that is being ravaged by corporate pillage and a failed democracy. As our society unravels, we also face global upheaval caused by catastrophic climate change. All these ills presage a frightening reconfiguration of the nation and the planet.

Donald Trump rode this disenchantment to power. In his “forceful and direct” (Publishers Weekly) America: The Farewell Tour, Hedges argues that neither political party, now captured by corporate power, addresses the systemic problem. Until our corporate coup d’état is reversed these diseases will grow and ravage the country. “With sharply observed detail, Hedges writes a requiem for the American dream” (Kirkus Reviews) and seeks to jolt us out of our complacency while there is still time.
Read less

Report an issue with this product








Review
“Searing portraits . . . of individuals victimized in six arenas that [Hedges] explores in detail: drug addiction, pornography, gambling, the criminal justice system, extremist groups and the search for meaningful, well-paid work. He takes the reader inside these issues in ways that are often telling and memorable.” -- Thomas Carothers ― The Washington Post

“Chris Hedges wants us to face realities. Our society is unraveling, institutionally and structurally, and is being replaced by the corporate state of merging big business and government. Commercialism overwhelms civic values, impoverishes its subjects, and reaches into childhoods bypassing parental authority. Poverty, addiction, gambling, and hopelessness spread like epidemics. Only we the people can reverse the disintegration of democracy by plutocracy. In America: The Farewell Tour, Chris Hedges depicts the horrifying truths on the ground from which resistance rises to jolt us into an active, realizable culture of reconstruction.” -- Ralph Nader

"An exceedingly dark, passionate, and provocative book, certain to arouse controversy but offering a point of view that needs to be heard." ― Booklist

“Chris Hedges is perhaps today’s most important public intellectual, and America: the Farewell Tour is perhaps his most important book. If we as a society are able to move past our current ‘sickness unto death,’ as Kierkegaard put it, it will be in great measure thanks to books like this one.” -- Derrick Jensen, author of A Language Older Than Words and The Culture of Make Believe

“Hedges writes a requiem for the American dream. . . . [A] fiery sermon that weighs the nation and finds it wanting.” ― Kirkus Reviews

“Hedges’s latest critique of late-stage capitalist America is forceful and direct." ― Publishers Weekly
About the Author
Chris Hedges is a Pulitzer Prize–winning journalist who was a foreign correspondent and bureau chief in the Middle East and the Balkans for fifteen years for The New York Times. He previously worked overseas for The Dallas Morning News, The Christian Science Monitor, and NPR. He is host of the Emmy Award­–nominated RT America show On Contact. Hedges, who holds a Master of Divinity from Harvard University, is the author of numerous books, and was a National Book Critics Circle finalist for War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning. He has taught at Columbia University, New York University, Princeton University, and the University of Toronto. He has taught college credit courses through Rutgers University in the New Jersey prison system since 2013.

Product details
Publisher ‏ : ‎ Simon & Schuster
Publication date ‏ : ‎ 27 August 2019
Language ‏ : ‎ English
Print length ‏ : ‎ 400 pages
ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 1501152688
ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-1501152689
Item weight ‏ : ‎ 318 g
Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 13.97 x 2.54 x 21.27 cm
Best Sellers Rank: 124,266 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)66 in Environmental Policy
109 in 21st Century U.S. History
111 in Sociology of Class
Customer Reviews:
4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars (1,202)



Top
About this itemSimilarFrom the AuthorQuestionsReviewsAmerica: The Farewell Tour

Follow authors to get new release updates, plus improved recommendations.




5 out of 5 stars


From Australia

Boots
5.0 out of 5 stars An important book for modern times
Reviewed in Australia on 12 November 2018
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Chris Hedges is fast becoming one of my favourite writers alongside Chomsky, Nader and a few others. Hedges writes with a powerful, rousing voice and effortlessly articulates the rumbling discontent so many of us are feeling about the systems and political forces we know are the sources of modern enslavement. He speaks for the disenfranchised and outlines clearly the mechanisms behind the systems of power, exposing the political and capitalist elite for the true criminal class they are.

I found the chapter on America's prison system devastating. Hedges reveals it for what it is - nothing more than state sanctioned slavery. I am appalled by the truth of what is happening inside these prisons and horrified that privatisation is being embraced by other countries like Australia, where I live. Making money off other people's misery is truly evil.

I am grateful to Hedges for giving me, through this book and his other works, the evidence and the language through which to express my opposition to a capitalist system I have long known is a tool of oppression. I am grateful too for the insight and understanding I have gained into the motivations of the far right and radical left. After reading this book I feel more compassion for those swept up in these ideologies even if I will never agree with them.

Chris Hedges suggests there is another way to get the boots of oppression off our necks. We must recognise each other as human beings and come together in our refusal to let them silence us. We must refuse to let our fear of the system's brutality stop us for standing up for each other and for what we know is right.
6 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report

rumtytum
5.0 out of 5 stars Awful and important
Reviewed in Australia on 30 June 2019
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
It's very confronting to realise, upon reading this and other Chris Hedges books, that it could only be from Mars, or Alpha Centauri, that we could have enough distance from the all-encompassing fog in which we're immersed to see our world as it truly is. The better angels are no longer in charge. They've been replaced by monsters who exemplify the nasty side of human nature. Only a revolution can swing things back again, and we're too addicted to the drugs we're given to reclaim our humanity.
2 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report

Tom Stuart
5.0 out of 5 stars Some fact telling
Reviewed in Australia on 15 December 2020
Format: AudiobookVerified Purchase
This book goes into some dark places and articulates some super difficult challenges however, as often is the case, there is something grounding, even cathartic, hearing the truth even when it is such bad news. Hedges' own resolve to address the truth feels contagious and inspires hope in this reader.
Helpful
Report

Munchie
5.0 out of 5 stars Love it
Reviewed in Australia on 28 May 2021
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
My first Hedges book, some great illustrations of where we are heading and some good tips on how to address it.
Helpful
Report

Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars excellent product and service
Reviewed in Australia on 17 April 2021
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
Quality product and service
Helpful
Report

bluevapo
3.0 out of 5 stars A bit of a rant.
Reviewed in Australia on 21 February 2021
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
A diatribe. Includes an unnecessarily long, lip-smacking chapter on film pornography
Helpful
Report

Mike S. in Adelaide
1.0 out of 5 stars Chaotic and Incoherent and Biased
Reviewed in Australia on 30 December 2018
Format: Hardcover
What is this book supposed to be? It contains the following topics - a political manifesto; absolutely hyperbolic criticism of Donald Trump; an introduction to Marxism; an introduction to American labor history with extensive extracts of Eugene Debs speeches of the 1890s; voyeuristic description of prostitution and sadomasochistic pornography; drug addiction including the opioid crisis. Only a minority of the book is relevant to its title being the decline (outsourcing) of American manufacturing; the increasing American prison system; the shrinking of the middle class; the increasing underclass. The author critically omits the failings of the American medical system and financial corruption for example. Far superior analytically structured unbiased and more encompassing material is available with multiple books from Prof. Niall Ferguson, Dr. Paul Craig Roberts, and Barbara Ehrenreich.
3 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
From other countries

StreetWorkout
5.0 out of 5 stars Reportagem com humanidade
Reviewed in Brazil on 29 June 2026
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
Excelente, uma gama abrangente de depoimentos pessoais sobre uma das épocas mais desafiantes da história.
Report
Translate review to English

Kris K.
5.0 out of 5 stars A brilliantly insighful description of the political Zeitgeist.
Reviewed in Germany on 29 April 2019
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Chris Hedges hits the political diagnostic nail on the head in describing what is more than a simple malaise in occidental societies. While perhaps a bit wordy and at times viscerally shocking, his damning multifaceted assessment of neo-liberalism is spot on.
Report

William
5.0 out of 5 stars Buen libro
Reviewed in Spain on 16 February 2024
Condition: Used – Good Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Muy bien. Lo He disfrutado. Mi compis es de firmado de escritura.
Report
Translate review to English
Translate all reviews to English

panti kumar
5.0 out of 5 stars Fascinating, enjoyable, lots to learn.
Reviewed in India on 5 February 2026
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
What you want me to write about Chris Hedges, good reading always.
Report

C. Doyle
5.0 out of 5 stars Brutal truth
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 12 January 2019
Verified Purchase
I'd come across Chris Hedges via the podcasts of Jeremy Scahill (Dirty Wars, Drone Complex, Intercepted et al.) And was intrigued by his clear and uncompromising approach to the underlying problems currently paralyzing America. This book investigates, by useful headings, the reasons for the populist backlash against what is viewed as the theft of people's rights and well-being by those who identify as the 1 per cent. First thing to note is that Hedges is a socialist. He speaks from this perspective throughout and whilst counter- narrative appears in places it is normally there to justify the point being made. To my mind this does not detract from the central message of the book but, in reality, strengthens the underlying message which is relentless ... working people have been the victims of unfettered greed and corruption for so long that they now blindly accept the situation that they find themselves in.
A compelling, clearly written and, at times, harrowing narrative about the current state of the US. Richly sourced and evidenced in a readable and easily accessible style that belies the journalistic origins of Hedges fame this should be required reading for anybody who believes capitalism is the answer to our shared future. An excellent book.
Report

Nicole
5.0 out of 5 stars Engaging read
Reviewed in the United States on 18 September 2026
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Hedges is the perfect voice for our current climate. Highly recommend his books and speeches.
Report

Giannoula L.
5.0 out of 5 stars Great book
Reviewed in Canada on 15 November 2018
Verified Purchase
Important read with great analysis of the corporate influence in our lives. Sad in its description of human fallings and somewhat militant in its criticism of both present main parties, but an important call for action. you will not be the same after reading it.
Report

francesco rovetto
5.0 out of 5 stars interessantissimo ed attuale
Reviewed in Italy on 16 July 2020
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
peccato che non sia disponibile in italiano. è un libro attualissimo e ben documentato sui molti guai degli stati uniti di oggi. noi di solito seguiamo gli USA con un ritardo di qualche anno, spero che si possa imparare dalla esperienza altrui
Report
Translate review to English

Cliente Amazon
1.0 out of 5 stars Solo se recrea en lo miserable
Reviewed in Spain on 11 November 2023
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
Con un argumentario basado en constantes citas de Marx, o de Gramsci. con su total apoyo, sin disimulo alguno hacia los beneficios del socialismo y la defensa del anarquismo, el autor se recrea, -- con brillantez, hay que reconocerlo -- en los aspectos más sórdidos de la sociedad americana, que podrían ser compartidos con cualquier otra sociedad del mundo occidental. Me produce tristeza, que en vez de resaltar los valores de nuestra civilización, nos revolquemos en las miserias del ser humano, describe con todo lujo de detalle en algunos capítulos, como el del "sadismo" -- sin aportar la más mínima alternativa o convirtiendo a sus protagonistas en representantes de nuestra cultura. No es un libro, ni siquiera para pensar, sino que nos provoca la misma náusea que si analizamos la composición de nuestras letrinas y cloacas.
Report
Translate review to English

Reviewer
5.0 out of 5 stars Another important work by Chris Hedges
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 1 October 2018
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Another insightful work by Chris Hedges that should be read by all who care about the current state of western societies. Often brutal, stark and shocking, this work lifts the lid on the decline of a country and on industries that commodify human beings. He outlines how this decline and those industries have been turbo-charged by the west's dominant economic model, and by doing so he sheds much needed light on the root cause of America's malaise and its lurch to the alt-right and to Trump.
Voices like Chris's should be heard and listened to as a counter to the troubling superficiality that has infected public and political discourse in general over the last few decades.
Report

Máximo Poder
5.0 out of 5 stars Indispensável
Reviewed in Brazil on 1 February 2020
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Para quem lê em inglês, é um retrato deprimente e preciso da moralidade americana. Algumas histórias são de embrulhar o estômago.
Report
Translate review to English

Qanta Ahmed
5.0 out of 5 stars Remarkably Poignant, Brilliantly Obeserved, Essential Reading to Understand America Today
Reviewed in the United States on 14 January 2019
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Absolutely gripping read as I have come to expect from following this author for over a decade. I devoured the book in two days suspending all other activities and found within in it chillingly relevant observations of our own undeniable decay as a society, Our enslavement to untrammeled, and brutally ruthless, capitalism which exploits populations - including America’s - for endless pursuit of profit at the expense of even destroying the very population which once made it so powerful and wealthy is brilliantly explained . The chapters on heroin, gambling sadism and work are devastating portraits of our current de-industrialized nation. Communities like Scranton, Flint and Camden are broad portraits of how how Americans must now live. The book is also a searing indictment on both the Democrats and the Republicans for their equal complicity in placing corporate capitalism above all else including the constitution the environment and human rights. The chapter on Hate and Prison are essential reading and add to important observations for our times . Deeply troubling and critically important and compellingly illustrated with real life biographies of Americans in deepening distress.
Customer image
Report

Lance Hardknight
5.0 out of 5 stars Great read
Reviewed in Canada on 6 February 2020
Verified Purchase
Made me a Chris Hedge fan. Well written and very insightful.
Report

JT
5.0 out of 5 stars Capitalism hijacked.
Reviewed in India on 26 November 2019
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
An intellectual account of how conmen use Capitalism to work on their favor and how its done behind a smoke screen.
It is remarkable that there is no much focus on the similar and more sinister evils unleashed by the the conmen through socialism.
But a thoroughly enjoyable book that runs so fast its moves ahead of you keeping you catching up with smile and admiration.
Report

Ade in the zone
4.0 out of 5 stars Interesting to hear of a vastly experienced American describing the upcoming collapse of the usa
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 1 November 2018
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
The author is a bit of a lefty Christian which is unusual for America where their Christians are usually far right as he admits. The early pages of the book give too much respect to Marxism which has hardly been success to mankind. However it goes into detail about a society collapsing into corporate domination and right wing control and the increasing lack of real freedoms in the USA along with a moral collapse. However i cant help thinking he has focussed on the extremes of the usa and not the mainstream - hasnt America always been a little extreme in many ways? It's interesting to note that right wing Christians, left wing Christians and socialists are united in believing the usa is headed for some kind of collapse or destruction!
Report

Tim Lukeman
5.0 out of 5 stars Depressing but absolutely required reading
Reviewed in the United States on 9 June 2019
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
As previous reviewers have noted, Chris Hedges isn't telling us anything we haven't heard before … but the point of repeating & updating them is both to bear constant witness & remind us to look beyond our comfortable illusions. And for all the politic & economic aspects examined, this books is really an exploration of the cultural psyche at its darkest roots. A State of the Soul speech, if you will. And it's not reassuring reading.

Hedges delves into the collapse of personal meaning & any sense of long-term security for an increasing number of Americans, and the terrible results of that collapse: increased sadism, increased violence, increased despair, increased emptiness. Attempts to roll back the clock to an idealized past that never truly existed don't help; if anything, they just exacerbate the problem. The illusion of safety is more destructive than the acknowledgement of the parlous state of affairs we live with now.

And so we have a disintegrating culture that distracts itself with countless technological wonders that allow us to immerse ourselves in shiny, gossipy, snarky trivialities. Education, the arts & humanities, a sense of common purpose — all are derided, dismissed. The idols of Money & Power & Revenge are raised up in all media, in all public discourse. And of course, those things are all hollow & ultimately consume those who pursue them. At which point many will turn to violence, either against others or against themselves. I sometimes think it's no accident that "The Walking Dead" is one of the most popular programs on TV these days. So many must feel as if they're the walking dead themselves … although they project that onto the Other, in their desperate need for scapegoats.

So, what's to be done? Hedges has always held out hope for a revolution of the spirit, a return to genuine & authentic human values. Yet at this point, I think he's beginning to see that possibility as being so slim as to be nearly non-existent. As a previous reviewer noted, all empires fall once they surrender to the worst aspects of the damaged soul. America will be no exception to that rule, I fear. Like any addict, America may need to hit bottom before gaining the ability to face itself honestly. And hitting bottom often results in death.

Depressing, I know. It seems to me that the only thing a caring, concerned human being can do is to live according to the best possibilities of being human, even & especially in the face of despair. More than anything else, despair kills — and it kills the spirit long before the body. Live well & refuse to succumb!
Report

Renovationman26
4.0 out of 5 stars Vintage Hedges.
Reviewed in Canada on 9 February 2019
Verified Purchase
A profoundly depressing book, but vital to our knowledge and opinions on capitalism, empires and the future.
Report

Abdul Basit Ahmad
5.0 out of 5 stars Eye opener
Reviewed in India on 10 May 2020
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
This is true of every capitalist society.
Hedges lays bare the reality of oppression in our modern world. A must read.
Report

Gary Moreau, Author
4.0 out of 5 stars Washington is fiddling but it is the capitalist collective that is setting the fires
Reviewed in the United States on 5 September 2018
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Throughout history, all great civilizations have ultimately decayed. And America will not be an exception, according to former journalist and war correspondent, Chris Hedges. And while Hedges doesn’t offer a date, he maintains we are in the final throes of implosion—and it won’t be pretty.

The book is thoroughly researched and the author knows his history. And despite some of the reviews it is not so much a political treatise as it is an exploration of the American underbelly—drugs, suicide, sadism, hate, gambling, etc. And it’s pretty dark; although he supports the picture he paints with ample statistics and first person accounts.

There is politics, but the politics provides the context for the decay. And it’s not as one-dimensional as other reviewers seemed to perceive. Yes, he is no fan of Trump or the Republican leadership. But he is no fan of the Democratic shift to identity politics, or antifa, either.

One reviewer thought he was undermining Christianity but I didn’t get that. He does not support “prosperity gospel” theology, but I didn’t see any attempt to undermine fundamental religious doctrine. He is, after all, a graduate of Harvard Divinity School and an ordained Presbyterian minister.

He puts the bulk of the blame for the current state of decay, in fact, where few other writers do—squarely on the back of capitalist America and the super-companies who now dominate nearly every industry. The social and political division we are now witnessing, in other words, has been orchestrated by the capital class; the class of investors, banks, and hedge fund managers who don’t create value so much as they transfer it to themselves from others with less power. And I think he’s spot on right.

We have seen a complete merger of corporate and political America. Politicians on both sides of the aisle serve at the pleasure of the capitalist elite because they need their money to stay in power. Corporations enjoy all the rights of citizenship save voting, but who needs to actually cast a ballot when you can buy the election.

And what the corpocracy, as I call it, is doing with all that power is continuing to reshuffle the deck of economic opportunity to insure that wealth and income continue to polarize. It’s a process they undertake in the name of tax cuts for the middle class (which aren’t), deregulation (which hurts society as a whole), and the outright transfer of wealth and property (including millions of acres of taxpayer-owned land) from taxpayers to shareholders (the 1%).

I know because I was part of it. As a former CEO and member of four corporate boards I had a front row seat from the 1970s on. The simplest analogy is that the gamblers rose up and took control of the casinos and the government had their backs in a kind of quid pro quo, all having to do with money.

They made it stick because they turned corporate management into the ultimate capitalists. The people who used to manage companies and employees are now laser focused on managing the companies’ stock price and enhancing their own wealth. Corporate executives, in a word, became capitalists, not businessmen and women, giving the foxes unfettered control of the hen house.

They got to that position through a combination of greed—both corporate management’s and that of shareholder activists—but were enabled and empowered by Washington. Beginning in the 1970s the Justice Department antitrust division, the Labor Department, the EPA, and other institutions assigned the responsibility to avoid the concentration of power that Adam Smith warned us about, and to protect labor and the environment, were all gutted and stripped of power.

They blamed it on globalism, but that was the result, not the cause. Gone are the days of any corporate sense of responsibility to the employees, the collective good, or the communities in which they operate and whose many services they enjoy. It is the corporate and financial elite, and they are now one and the same, who have defined the “me” world in which we now live.

And the process continues: “The ruling corporate kleptocrats are political arsonists. They are carting cans of gasoline into government agencies, the courts, the White House, and Congress to burn down any structure or program that promotes the common good.” And he’s right. And Trump is carrying those cans.

Ironically, Trump’s base, who have been most marginalized by the corpocracy, are the ones who put him there to continue the gutting. But Hedges has an explanation for that. “In short, when you are marginalized and rejected by society, life often has little meaning. There arises a yearning among the disempowered to become as omnipotent as the gods. The impossibility of omnipotence leads…to its dark alternative—destroying like the gods.” (Reference to Ernest Becker’s The Denial of Death.)

The economic history and understanding of economic theory here is rich and detailed. Capitalism, as Marx and others pointed out, creates great wealth in the beginning but is doomed to failure due to its inability to continue to find sources of growth and to manage inequities in wealth creation. And you don’t have to be a socialist to see that this is true. Capitalism must be managed. And our government is currently making no attempt to do so. It is, in fact, dynamiting the institutions responsible for doing so.

All told, this is a very good book. If you don’t like reading about underbellies (I found the chapter devoted to sadism personally unsettling, being the father of two daughters.) you will find some of it pretty dark. Having said that, however, the writing is very good and Hedges never wallows in the darkness. He’s clearly not selling the underbelly; he’s trying to give it definition.

I did think that some of the chapters might have been broken down into different sub-chapters and there is a lack of continuity in some places. All told, however, I do recommend the book. There is no denying the fundamental thesis.

The problem is, however, we’re all blaming it on the proverbial ‘other guy.’ Perhaps this book will help us to understand the real culprit—the capitalist collective. “The merging of the self with the capitalist collective has robbed us of our agency, creativity, capacity for self-reflection, and moral autonomy.” True, indeed.
Report

sammy
5.0 out of 5 stars Good book
Reviewed in Canada on 20 November 2018
Verified Purchase
Very depressing do not read unless you are a masochist and want to be dpressed five more words two more words waste time
Report

Douglas Bell
5.0 out of 5 stars A HEDGES CLASSIC
Reviewed in Canada on 30 January 2021
Verified Purchase
This masterpiece outlines the tragic and anticipated fall of the American Empire. It’s a must read for every single American of any political persuasion.
Report

wsmrer
5.0 out of 5 stars A hopeful view?
Reviewed in the United States on 31 December 2018
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
What Hedges does is reveal reality and that can be very frightening.
But he is not the first as he notes ‘Marx as prophet’ describing what is as what would be.
His format strange, but enabling many to tell in their own words the sores they endure in trying to find a way through the day, or the year. Hedges the journalist is back.

He has many publications where he examines afflictions; in this one he goes a step further to model a mode for change. It moves beyond peaceful resistance, as in the civil rights movement, with the notion that the elite will not change except under forceful and persistent resistance. He examines some cases of that occurring but also ones of ultimate failure such as the clashes of the 1960’s and its aftermath: Results like ‘Democrats for Reagan’ – the reviewer’s terminology.*

One very interesting aspect of his analysis is being intrigued by existing communities or subsets of them like East Brooklyn, or South Bronx, or the West Side of Chicago;
where people are forming their own ways to improve life without existing formal government input – often in opposition to it. “There are, as the political philosopher Sheldon Wolin reminded us, no institutions left in America that can authentically be called democratic.” p.249

He also bridges the space between Trump ‘supporters’ and ‘opponents’ as both being people with like problems in America as it is, recognizing they can come together when they identify the core cause of inequality and social chaos and war brought on by the ruling elite and their control of government and business, the media and academia.
That would be a desirable outcome; there are long sections of alternative dystopian outcomes.
Revolutionary thought? Yes some of that for sure, but with a new bend.

A personal note: I just finished another work examining the international crisis of modern times by a distinguish Oxford scholar of fifty years who basically makes the same proposals as Hedges, but with a calmer delivery, hoping that finally existing problems will lead to like minded groups forming to introduce way to bring us back to a period of reciprocity and generosity of earlier times; in his terminology by forming ‘clubs’ for change.** Chris Hedges certainly has more punch and a differing opinion of Capitalism but their reasoning is parallel. There can be a way to force change; or else.
5 stars
*Current Events in Hong Kong turning violent (9-10/2019) might fit as example – outcome more than uncertain; but elite ‘not listening’ so far.
** Paul Collier, The Future of Capitalism: Facing the New Anxieties.
Report

David Mapley
5.0 out of 5 stars A superb account of a nation and indeed world slipping into a grotesque travesty
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 16 October 2018
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
This book is superb yet not an easy read, indeed it makes very uncomfortable reading for what Hedges is describing in the USA is happening here in Britain too. Read and prepared to get angry, very angry with the grotesque venal politicians and the corporations that jerk their strings. It could never happen here, could it........
Report

Erwin Van Den Broecke
5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent!
Reviewed in Canada on 1 August 2020
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
As always, the author delivers a "no holds barred" account of the state of his country. Very informative, well written and well researched and corroborated by factual references. A very intriguing look at the dark spiral the USA is hurtling through at this very moment, by the most corrupt head of state the world has ever seen. An extremely bleak period of US history they will have a very hard time (if not impossible) recovering from.
Report

Holly Golightly
5.0 out of 5 stars Thoughtful and Provacative
Reviewed in the United States on 20 September 2019
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Mr. (or Reverend as he is an ordained Presbyterian minister)Hedges. writes a book which captures the essence of late stage capitalism. The opioid epidemic, the mass shootings and the rise ( at least blatantly) of hate groups are all symptoms. He interviews women who were trapped in the pornography industry and prisoners forced to live in unbearable conditions. He also addresses the bloated military budget and questions why we are fighting pointless wars. He believes, as do I, that the population is in a condition of "anomie" where life ceased to have inherent meaning. Cell phones, which people stare at all day, restrict real human contact as do violent video games, TV series and social media outlets. Although millions of Americans go to bed hungry or homeless, most others have what Marcuse quoted " their ' bread and circuses '. This pacifies the population into inertia. Hedges believes in revolutionary reform, as do I. He is correct in stating that Trump is a symptom, not a cause of a society falling into a downward spiral. He includes Democrats as well since many of them are bought and paid for by corporate dollars. If corporations paid their fare share of taxes, as well as the 1%, and we got rid of our bloated military budget, perhaps then we could have free school from pre-K to college, generous parental leave, a livable wage for all and decent benefits for the elderly, disabled and unemployed. Hedges believes in a single payer health care system. I am not quite there yet. I agreed with most of Chris Nedges's ideas and solutions but even if you don't, this book is interesting reading.
Report

Howard
5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliant, searing polemic.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 24 March 2021
Condition: Used – Very Good Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
A brilliant, searing polemic in the best sense. Well evidenced, rigorously argued with a raging sensibility to the inequality, corruption and injustice that is rotting American society and politics.
Report

Robert
5.0 out of 5 stars Eye opening and well researched book
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 28 April 2019
Verified Purchase
Amazing book exposing declining state that America is in. The book is incredibly well researched, profound and hummn. It is not our typical left/right wing rant.
Report

Pam
5.0 out of 5 stars This man needs to be hailed, an American Hero!
Reviewed in the United States on 16 October 2019
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
This man needs to be hailed, an American Hero... For being brave, to speak a level of truth, that he has brought us, all!

I have been on my own personal pursuit to understand; or try to understand the madness in which I have known, in my bones. For years I have walked an invisible line, as I am a white American born woman, that converted into Islam 30 years ago.

I faced the official stories and found the lies that laid within mis-direction, and it broke my heart. I started on a path to understand the decline of mankind. And during last 8 years, I have researched a vast range of topics that could possibly bring focus; that could lead to my answer of mankind's current condition.

Through Chris Hedges work, he has brought understanding of why I haven't been able to find a central point of the madness. The corporations merely fed the hearts of those, that were not looking into the overall effect of their actions. And therein lies the route cause of our condition. My heart, has sunk a level deeper than the first page turned; with this invaluable data, Chris Hedges have given us.

To you Mr. Chris Hedges, I have so much respect for you. You have done the humanities such a service, and I will be forever a fan; of your heart, your pursuit & your determination to state the truth in which you, have given us. May god bless you, may god protect you and may your written and spoken word, never cease. As the world needs more, just like you.

Bravo, Sir! Bravo
Report

Charlie Little
3.0 out of 5 stars first Hedges book I’ve not liked
Reviewed in the United States on 23 August 2018
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
I’ve read all of Chris Hedges’s books, and I would recommend all of them, including this one, but only if a person hadn’t read any of his others — and I would recommend others before this one, so... A much better starting place is Unspeakable or War Is a Force. And the brutality of this book isn’t what deters me — Hedges’s book Collatoral Damage was among the most difficult books, morally speaking, I’ve ever read, and it is excellent. Maybe it’s the book’s repetiveness in the context of his other writings — it just makes me go numb, rather than feeling more deeply about the problems being addressed. And, the book doesn’t have an intro or epilogue — we’re just supposed get what he’s doing in the book without him telling us. So it doesn’t really feel like much of a book. More like Truthdig articles cut, copied, pasted, and moved around into 7 thematic chapters, with snippets of reused rhetoric from speeches and RT interviews. Maybe others will feel this book is a culmination of sorts, a gathering in of much of what Hedges has to tell us. My experience was that it was more of a mish mash than a galvanization. I got the impression that Hedges’s best writing days are behind him, which I truly hope is not the case. There’s just no way a book like this will be anything more than a $2 hardcover at used book stores 5 years from now. And that possibility makes me sad.

I will say, moving from sadness to frustration, one thing I detest about the book is his treatment of antifa. The analysis is shallow, misleading, and often flatout wrong. I don’t know why he felt it’d be appropriate to compare antifa to organized crime families, call them cults of violence, and even call them fascists (!) — all while blithely citing people like Orwell favorably, who was a antifascist that describes himself as killing a man in Homage to Catalonia, which Hedges has read. Back when Hedges refered to Black Bloc as a cancer, David Graeber responded. I liked Hedges’s article, but then read Graeber’s response. I felt Graeber dismantled Hedges on every point, but Hedges shows in this book that he’s unrepentant and feels it appropriate to double down against people who are actually fighting against fascists. Makes me almost mad when he cites Luxemburg or Goldman or any number of violent revolutionaries — it’s like he’s taking their names in vain or something. Another thing, I am confused about Hedges’s response to antifa saving Cornel West’s life. He says it was a good thing, only to say that the good thing is not good enough. What confuses me is that West and Hedges are friends. And West’s response to antifa at Charlottesville was different from Hedges’s. West talked about it on Democracy Now! — check it out.

My take away is, read his other books first. Basically any of them. I kinda wish I hadn’t spent $28 on this. Ah well. Just kinda bummed that this book I’ve been looking forward to is largely regurgitated material.
Report

suli_niv
5.0 out of 5 stars Gets to the root problems in society, the kind most don't want to talk about.
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 29 June 2023
Condition: Used – Like New Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
This book will have a profound impact on you.
Report

Ernie cardinal1
5.0 out of 5 stars more!! we need more from this writer
Reviewed in Canada on 7 December 2023
Verified Purchase
this book should be in all schools and universities

so important

fast delivery too
Report

Johnny
4.0 out of 5 stars Bothsiderism
Reviewed in the United States on 3 May 2020
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Chris Hedges' analysis condemns both the elites who benefit from status quo along with the revolutionary movements striving to demolish the status quo in equal measure. In the chapter discussing antifa movement, Hedges glibly states there are two kinds of fascists: The fascists and the antifascists. And immediately after that, he portrays the Proud Boys and similar "militia" groups as victims of the same socio-economic system that antifa and similar groups are trying to violently overthrow. But the truth is that the so-called militias only want to restore and preserve the system of white male privilege they fear is unraveling beneath them. He can't seriously claim "both sides" in this conflict are fighting for the same things. Despite their anti-establishment rhetoric, neo-nazi brigades are doing the bidding of the elites who are in power. The dead give away is how law enforcement (the enforcers of the status quo) stand back and allow mostly white male "militia" members to roam the streets armed with assault rifles, compared to how hard they come down on protest groups on the left like Occupy, pepper spraying and arresting members that include non-white and female participants. There really aren't two sides to this argument.

Hedges' tendency to blame everyone both in and out of power gets stretched pretty thin. Are the failings and weaknesses of the so-called neoliberals (Barack Obama, Hillary Clinton, Joe Biden, etc.) really equivalent to the daily horror show on display by the Trump administration?

The seeds of destruction of capitalism boil down to the inability of markets to deliver basic human needs -- food, clothing, shelter, medical services, public safety -- to everyone. This is because according to classical economics, the supply-demand curves must necessarily cross each other at some equilibrium price. Unfortunately that price point is almost invariably beyond the means of a certain percentage of the population, so the equilibrium supply falls short of providing basic needs to everyone. Pure capitalism requires some level of unmet need in order to function. Equilibrium price points and unmet needs increase as income disparity increases, which tends to increase income disparity further. The real villain here is Adam Smith's "invisible hand."

On the other hand, market-based capitalism is efficient in supplying wants (allocating consumer goods above and beyond basic needs) along with creating the necessary incentives to work and earn income to purchase those goods. The only viable solution to eliminating poverty is balancing socialism, to supply a set of basic needs as a public good financed through taxation, along with capitalism, to allocate wants through market principles. Such a balance, in theory, could satisfy both the needs and wants of the population. The Scandinavian model comes close to reaching that objective. It's clear that complete privatization of resources will never come close to that goal because of the inherent design flaws of capitalism, where some level of endemic poverty always exists. Social instability and revolution erupts when that level reaches a tipping point.

The book dwells way too much on the lurid details of prostitution, drug addiction, and sado-masochism. Although all of these are symptoms of social decay we're currently experiencing, did he really need to devote two whole chapters those sordid topics?

There was one chapter on the topic of gambling, which was pretty good. This chapter should have been expanded to show similarities between the stock market, where middle-class hopes and dreams are placed, and a gambling casino or a Ponzi scheme.

This book exposes some unpleasant truths about the current state of affairs in the United States. And the book is worthwhile if that wakes up people to the harsh reality confronting us. However, I don't think the book quite hits the mark by blaming unseen, shadowy villains -- who Hedges believes are everyone on both the left and the right of the political spectrum -- instead of addressing the design flaws inherent in pure capitalism.
Report

Billy the Bibliophile
4.0 out of 5 stars America: The Farewell Tour isn’t meant to comfort you — it’s meant to confront you.
Reviewed in the United States on 26 October 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
America: The Farewell Tour isn’t meant to comfort you — it’s meant to confront you.

Chris Hedges doesn’t offer easy solutions or a political roadmap. Instead, he lays out the facts exactly as they are: a country unraveling under corporate greed, moral decay, and the hollowing-out of its social fabric. The book’s bleakness isn’t a flaw — it’s the point. It forces you to look at what we’ve become without the usual distractions or excuses.

The final chapter reads like an ode to the oppressed class — those who still resist and organize against the powers that run this country. But Hedges makes clear that resistance alone isn’t enough unless it reaches critical mass. He acknowledges the near-impossibility of real, large-scale change in a system this entrenched, yet still insists that moral resistance is a duty, even when victory feels far-fetched.

This isn’t an uplifting read, but it’s an honest one. It’s for readers who want truth without varnish — those willing to confront the uncomfortable reality that knowing the truth may not save us, but ignoring it guarantees our decline.
Report

S. Ferguson
5.0 out of 5 stars "Justice is a manifestation of Love..."
Reviewed in the United States on 1 September 2018
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
The inimitable Hedges is not only a saint with a penetrating intelligence, but also a man of superior eloquence with the power to pull you into his descriptions of the collapse of western civilization. Hedges says that the new American Capitalism no longer produces products — rather America produces escapist fantasies. I found this paragraph [page 233] particularly relevant. The act of being dedicated to the ‘greater good’ has in itself become dangerous.

Chris Hedges: “We do not become autonomous and free human beings by building pathetic, tiny monuments to ourselves. It is through self-sacrifice and humility that we affirm the sanctity of others and the sanctity of ourselves. Those who fight against cultural malice … have discovered that life is measured by infinitesimal and often unacknowledged acts of solidarity and kindness. These acts of kindness … spin outward to connect our atomized and alienated souls to others. The good … draws to it the good. This belief — held although we may never see empirical proof — is profoundly transformative. But know this: when these acts are carried out on behalf of the oppressed and the demonized, when compassion defines the core of our lives, when we understand that justice is a manifestation of love, we are marginalized and condemned by our sociopathic elites.”
Report

Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars Great packaging, price, delivery. Product in great condition.
Reviewed in the United States on 7 March 2026
Condition: Used – Very Good Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
Great packaging, price, delivery. Product in great shape.
Report

Amazon Customer
3.0 out of 5 stars Great (Recycled) Hedges Rants
Reviewed in the United States on 7 September 2018
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
If you've never read Hedges - get it now. If you've read him before - there's nothing new here.

Chris Hedges is a writer who has a knack for seeing the big picture and connecting the dots. A chronic pessimist in the best sense, a bitter prophet warning us of the last days of the decaying empire, his page-turning prose carving through the morass of today's mania and derangement. For that, he's in the company somewhere between Cornel West and Morris Berman (the later, whose book Why America Failed, is better than this. If you're familiar with Hedges, but not Morris Berman, go find Berman instead).

I give this three stars only because there isn't much new here if you're familiar with his material. I felt this book to be an update of Empire of Illusion, punched up by old articles from his weekly column at Truthdig. Aside from the introductory chapter, he revisits themes of sadism, the decline of literacy, of labor, of democratic institutions, and so on, which are too familiar. The pages and pages detailing the BDSM craze I felt were excessive in their prurient voyeurism which journalistic approaches can fall into. Not saying he's wrong at all, but this tone could put off some readers, erring on excessive preacherly seminarian virtue signaling as he points out the sins of the world and shouts - "Look! Look at what we've done!"
Report

Henry Barefield
4.0 out of 5 stars Book Purchsse
Reviewed in the United States on 1 June 2025
Condition: Used – Good Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
The item was pretty much as advertised. It was a couple of days late arriving but all is well
Report

jazzlistener
4.0 out of 5 stars Hard Read
Reviewed in the United States on 9 December 2018
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
I'm only about halfway through the book. I took a star off because I think very few casual readers like myself will read it. For me it's a "hard read" for a couple of reasons. The subject matter is dreary, depressing, and at times a little scary. With whole chapters devoted to "Sadism" and "Hatred" among other things, the book is best read one chapter at a time with a day or two of rest between chapters. Also, parts of it are pretty dense with the authors assessments and philosophical thoughts and with direct quotes from some pretty heady writings. I find myself going back and rereading paragraphs about every 4 or 5 pages, sometimes less. Am I learning anything that I didn't already know? I'll have to finish the book to find out.
Report

T. ORourke
3.0 out of 5 stars Some great ideas amongst a lot of tawdry reporting.
Reviewed in the United States on 5 December 2018
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
I like Chris Hedges. I think American Fascists is one of the best books about America in the last few decades. This book has flashes of profound insight. No one discusses the right wing better than Hedges. He is less harsh, but still hard on the progressives for their tendencies to be materialistic and corporatist and maybe wishy washy. What brings the book down is its reporting on opioid abuse and sex workers, for example. He wallows in the lurid details of the actions of those he follows, and he seems to take almost anything they say at face value without asking anyone else. Would it have hurt to try to ask the maligned landlords and the others disparaged for their side? I am sure things would not look as bad if some semblance of balance and skepticism was deployed now and then. There is plenty to be positive about in this world. This book ignores most of that, and there are way more people trying to make lives better than those actively destroying them, though it is harder to make things better than break them and not as many people are needed. Could have easily been edited down to a thoughtful essay or two.
Report

tombarnes
4.0 out of 5 stars neoliberalism creates a new Merkin
Reviewed in the United States on 4 August 2024
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
A one sentence review of an excellent book detailing our declining Kultur:
"A government by and for the corporations shall not perish from this earth."
Report

Basil Al-Nakeeb
5.0 out of 5 stars Chris Hedges Is the Our Missing High Moral Ground
Reviewed in the United States on 21 August 2020
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
In today's world, Chris has a rare combination of qualities. Foremost, his words are a plea for mercy for a tortured and neglected humanity. He is not for compromising on moral issues, which is mostly out of fashion nowadays. His physical and moral courage is boundless, previously as a news correspondent, and today as a writer. He has a very ordered mind: logical, consistent, and brilliant. His painting of words is very visual and absorbing. His latest work, America: The Farewell Tour is perhaps his best because he is at his wisest. America is fortunate to have a Chris Hedges; America needs the likes of him but unfortunate in having too few of them.
Report

Steven Kaminsky
4.0 out of 5 stars It’s not light reading, but it’s an important book.
Reviewed in the United States on 22 October 2018
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
While not a light read, I think Chris Hedges puts the problems that have beset our country into crystalline perspective.
Many of the issues that we see as an example of the moral decline of America are symptoms of the over all declining American empire.
Hedges masterfully shows this reflected in the job situation, the political circus we currently are witnessing, and a complicit press that does everything but inform the public.
Though this is a hard book to read due to its subject matter the last chapter does offer some hope.
Report

Amazon Customer
4.0 out of 5 stars alot of information.
Reviewed in Canada on 6 May 2023
Verified Purchase
The book has a lot of excellent info in it. Too bad his TDS sometimes shines through
Report

Purchased this item for Coffee Hour at Assisted Living Facility. First use, bottom burned because water too hot. Second use: Front nozzle came right off the pot burning one woman’s hand. Item boxed and ready to ship back to Amazon for refund.
5.0 out of 5 stars Please read.
Reviewed in the United States on 4 August 2025
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
Fantastic read!
Report

ELLIOTT G.
4.0 out of 5 stars Worth Reading.
Reviewed in the United States on 29 October 2018
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
We have to get use to it; China in the next decade will be the dominant economic power on earth. Perhaps they'll also be the leading military power as well. Let's hope the later doesn't materialize, because a dominant Communist Country is dangerous and a greater threat to world instability. Don't think so? Well just look what's happening in the South China Sea. Reading this book will give you a better insight to the current and future balance of power in the world.
Report

Douglas Graves
5.0 out of 5 stars Hedges - An important American Writer
Reviewed in the United States on 6 June 2019
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Few people write about America with as much power as Chris Hedges. The prose is rhythmic and powerful. The footnotes alone provide the basis for a lifetime of study. One of the few writers where a highlighter is required because you will want to refer back, again and again. His chapters on the opioid crisis, pornography, and the barren morality of a failing empire leave the reader changed forever. Hedges has been marginalized and ignored by main stream media, but when future historians sift through the ashes, they will know that somebody there saw it coming.
Report

Peter
5.0 out of 5 stars Farewell America
Reviewed in the United States on 22 March 2019
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
For those few of us who do not have their heads buried in the sand it is obvious that the US is beginning the long process of total collapse. Theoretically this can be avoided, but as Hedges makes clear, the odds of success are stacked against us and to make matters worse the Anthropocene is roaring down upon us as a speed greater than our ability to react.
It takes a high level of courage to read this book. But for those who possess this courage it is a must read. It will help you plan and cope.
Report

Aleksei
5.0 out of 5 stars Everyone should read this.
Reviewed in the United States on 27 February 2025
Condition: Used – Like New Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
you've heard it before, here it is again: Read this book.
Report

S. Nasiri
1.0 out of 5 stars Most grotesque and irrelevant reading
Reviewed in the United States on 24 May 2020
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Overall I did not like this book and do not recommend.  Most of its contents are looking into the american society through the eyes of its worst elements, prostitutes,  drug adficts, death row inmates, and alike. The only part that was sane and included some intellectual content worth reading was the final take,  at the final section of the last chapter.  Most if the book is a deep dive into the gutters and swers of US society, by doing very detail descriptions of the life lived by it worse elements and distributes in the society; prostitutes and sexual trafficking, girls subject to sexual torture in porn industries, those with opiod and drug addictions, slavery and free labor in for profit corporate prison system and alike. Using all these ill societal problems to blame capitalism and for election Trum is little stretch. Reading the book and all these grotesque passages you loose track of what and why you are reading this book. Authors extreme attempt to discredite the corporate america, political parties both republican and democrats,  from the eyes of the most disenfranchised faction of the society and blaming corporate greed and capital system for their missary is too much to digest. Specially his solution and alternative being a socialist society and call for revolution through resistance. Calling for end of US capitalism and the fall of the empire by 2030. I have read several other books that address some of the same societal challenges  in US due to deindustrialization that were much more constructive and less revolutionary. 
Report

Jeff B Brownell
5.0 out of 5 stars Sobering
Reviewed in the United States on 24 April 2021
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
A sense of dread and despair cuts to the core while reading, whereby I almost quit more than once. This short enveloped prose gives rise to hope in the last pages of the final chapter where the letter is removed; the true nature of what I believe Chris is trying to convey; a call to action leading to hope if one is willing to look in the mirror long enough with an open heart and an open mind.
Report

I. Wesley
5.0 out of 5 stars This is a must read
Reviewed in the United States on 8 April 2024
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
Chris Hedges is phenomenal. This is a must read for anyone who cares about our country and democracy actually anyone who cares about our world I highly recommend it.
Report

Higher Primate
5.0 out of 5 stars I’d give a million stars if possible
Reviewed in the United States on 22 August 2018
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Heartbreaking to read but so true. In our “truth is not truth” era Mr. Hedges once again writes the sad and shocking obituary for American Democracy and sounds the prophetic alarm to those revelers while Rome burns. All empires come and go but I never thought I’d be a witness to one. Something sick and traitorous has infected the soul of America and I fear it’s going to be some demented combination of the worst elements in 1984 and Brave Bew World. The most important work currently published but will anyone listen? Will anything change?
Report

Cacho Fuentes
5.0 out of 5 stars How important is honesty?
Reviewed in the United States on 24 February 2019
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
I have a couple of friends who find Chris Hedges quite difficult to read. I don't. He essentially gives word to what I have seen, experienced, and concluded. Admittedly, his writing is strong, articulate, and brilliant, and it takes rugged honesty to really ponder what he is saying. What he is saying here is really essential and we need to read it and consider what we can do about it. He is morally strong but I think deeply caring and compassionate.
Report
Show 10 more reviews