2026년 11월 16일 월요일

‘60 Minutes’ Exposes Shock Scale of Trump’s War Humiliation - Yahoo News Australia

‘60 Minutes’ Exposes Shock Scale of Trump’s War Humiliation - Yahoo News Australia



‘60 Minutes’ Exposes Shock Scale of Trump’s War Humiliation
Vic Verbalaitis
Mon 16 November 2026 at 1:54 pm ACDT
4 min read
‘60 Minutes’ Exposes Shock Scale of Trump’s War Humiliation



00:42 / 01:43






60 Minutes has pulled back the curtain on the true scale of devastation wrought by Donald Trump's war on Iran.

CBS News' Norah O'Donnell revealed in Sunday's episode that Iran has struck at least 31 U.S. military and diplomatic sites across the Middle East since Trump began the war in February, citing video and the network's analysis of satellite imagery.

The Pentagon, under the leadership of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, has only selectively recognized attacks on U.S. bases during the nearly nine-month conflict, which has made it difficult for Americans to gauge a clear assessment of the damage caused by Iran.

'60 Minutes' reported that Iranians have successfully attacked 31 U.S. military and diplomatic sites during the war. / 60 Minutes

"Our analysis of satellite imagery and new video shows the scale of destruction the Pentagon has never fully disclosed," O'Donnell said. "Since the start of the war, Iran has hit at least 31 U.S. military and diplomatic sites across eight countries, damaging hundreds of buildings and structures—from Saudi Arabia, to Kuwait, to Bahrain, where the headquarters of the U.S. Navy's Fifth Fleet was destroyed."

O'Donnell added that despite Trump's assertion that the war was won on April 1, strikes have continued in both directions for months.

On Sunday, Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps fired six drones toward a U.S. air defense radar facility in Bahrain. But the country's military said the drones were shot down "before they could achieve their objectives," according to the BBC.

O'Donnell on ‘60 Minutes’. / 60 Minutes

'60 Minutes' shared footage of damaged U.S. military buildings. / 60 Minutes

Since the start of the war, 23 U.S. service members have been killed, and more than 800 have been wounded, according to the Pentagon's official database.

The Defense Department has publicly acknowledged only mass casualty events during the conflict, such as the Iranian strike on a U.S. base in Port Shuaiba, Kuwait, on March 1, which killed six American service members.

The day after the missile strike, which was the deadliest attack on U.S. troops in the conflict so far, Hegseth described it to reporters as a "squirter" that snuck through air defenses to hit what he called a "fortified" tactical operations center.

Hegseth has repeatedly stressed that

But Maj. Stephen Ramsbottom, who survived the Iranian strike, said the fortifications at the military operations center were subpar.

"I feel this is a tactical failure by the Army, our leadership, and myself—all the way down to my level," Ramsbottom told 60 Minutes. "We just did not plan this well, and this needs to be a lesson that we learn."

The Port Shuaiba survivor alleges that military leadership's

The veteran has filed a complaint with the House and Senate Armed Services Committees, alleging that military leadership is responsible for the deaths of his six fellow troops.

In the complaint, obtained by CBS News, Ramsbottom said top military brass ignored concerns about thin fortifications and described the Port Shuaiba command post as having "no physician, no fixed aid station, and only one ambulance."

The Shuaiba port base (photographed in July 2021) in Kuwait was attacked on March 1, and Army Maj. Ramsbottom described the fatality level as a 'tactical failure.' / Staff Sgt. David Simon/U.S. ArmyMore

Joey Amor, the widowed husband of Master Sgt. Nicole Amor, who died in the Port Shuaiba attack, went a step further in his critique of Pentagon leadership.

"If I'm being frank, it's—it's on them. They killed my wife," Amor told 60 Minutes. They killed these soldiers. And it's not political. There are individuals in that command that made choices."

Joey Amor blames Pentagon leadership for his wife's death at Port Shuaiba. / 60 Minutes

The Daily Beast has reached out to the Pentagon and the White House for comment.

Trump, 80, acknowledged that his unpopular war with Iran influenced his party's historic rout in the midterm elections, but has maintained that the conflict was necessary.


The president has repeatedly stated that he would make the same decision to attack Iran again if it meant it would prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon.


Trump told reporters last week that the conflict is "effectively over" and that the U.S. is simply maintaining the "status quo" at the request of its allies in the Persian Gulf.

He also falsely claimed during a pair of interviews on Thursday that no U.S. troops had been killed during the past five months, despite at least four American service members having died in July alone.

On Sunday night, the president posted a video on Truth Social of American troops praying in unison with the caption, "May God protect our troops say AMEN." The video was later flagged as AI online.



2026년 11월 15일 일요일

Opinion | Jensen Huang’s Fall Is Bad for Nvidia but Good for America - The New York Times

Opinion | Jensen Huang’s Fall Is Bad for Nvidia but Good for America - The New York Times

Guest Essay

Jensen Huang Is Gone. Good.
Nov. 13, 2026

Credit...Illustration by Sam Whitney/The New York Times

Listen · 5:27 min

Share full article



443


By Alex Kantrowitz


Mr. Kantrowitz is a tech journalist and the writer of the newsletter Big Technology.


Following Jensen Huang’s resignation from Nvidia after a stunning sex scandal, it’s reasonable to think the U.S. artificial intelligence industry is in trouble. Nvidia’s chips have been vital to A.I.’s ascendance; the company has directly invested billions in A.I. companies, bolstering their chances of success; and Mr. Huang himself was a cheerleader for the go-faster crowd.

The A.I. industry might be wiser to count this as a blessing. Nvidia will take a hit, but American A.I. is in a stronger position to thrive.

Mr. Huang made Nvidia into a bedrock for American A.I. companies, but he was also a baffling champion for their competitors. No person has fought more effectively to give Chinese A.I. companies access to high-powered chips, despite clear national-security risks in areas such as cyberwarfare. When the United States weighed and enacted export controls on this hardware, Mr. Huang repeatedly and successfully pushed back, to the delight of Chinese A.I. developers. Last year, the Trump administration blocked some Nvidia chip sales to China only to reverse course three months later. The administration also allowed Nvidia to sell its powerful H200 chips in China, with a 25 percent cut going to the U.S. government.

To get his way, Mr. Huang built a strong friendship with President Trump. He attended a $1 million-per-person dinner at Mar-a-Lago and assembled a bully of a lobbying operation in Washington. He became so close to Mr. Trump that he took a phone call from the president while onstage at a September industry summit.

Helped by the deals Mr. Huang set up to make Nvidia chips available to China, upstart Chinese A.I. companies made their American counterparts sweat. The first major shock, even before the repeal of H200 export controls, was the unveiling last year of DeepSeek-R1, a Chinese model that matched some American A.I. capabilities at what appears to have been a fraction of the cost. Another shock was Moonshot AI’s Kimi K3, a Chinese A.I. model released this summer that was found to have bested top American A.I. models in certain coding tasks.
Sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter Get expert analysis of the news and a guide to the big ideas shaping the world every weekday morning. Get it sent to your inbox.

Many experts say Chinese A.I. model capabilities lag behind those of American models by just a handful of months. Chinese models tend to be much less expensive to use and more flexible to customize, making them a major nuisance to Anthropic and OpenAI. In one week in September, companies on OpenRouter (a kind of marketplace for choosing different A.I. models to use) had used Chinese A.I. models for more than 50 percent of their activity.

Mr. Huang’s advocacy for delivering chips to China has led to some tense relationships with other American A.I. leaders, including Anthropic’s chief executive, Dario Amodei. But with Mr. Huang out at Nvidia, his influence in opening chip exports to China may go with him. That means Mr. Amodei and his counterparts could have a solid chance to broaden the gap between their technology and the Chinese competition.

China hawks are especially salivating at the possibility of preventing more cutting-edge technology from leaving the United States without Mr. Huang atop Nvidia. Chinese A.I. companies are already scrambling to rent computing capacity outside China in anticipation of more restrictive American policies. If new export controls further limit the computing power available to Chinese A.I. companies, they would probably have to narrow or scale back their efforts — leaving OpenAI, Anthropic, Google and other American firms a bigger lane to pursue more ambitious plans.

Mr. Huang’s departure will be felt in other ways, too. He’s been a pioneering force whose almost singular vision and drive generated the computing power needed to enable the advanced calculations behind American firms’ frontier models. If Nvidia falters, its ability to improve chip technology could falter as well. Nvidia’s funding has subsidized many A.I. businesses; its equity investments totaled approximately $100 billion as of July. Even Mr. Amodei’s Anthropic is expected to take about $10 billion from Nvidia alongside Anthropic’s I.P.O. next week. And there has always been some concern that preventing China from buying some American chips would spur China to simply accelerate its own chip operation, which could rival Nvidia’s.



Still, the past weeks’ revelations have shown Mr. Huang to be far more useful to China’s A.I. industry than was previously known. His relationship with a Chinese businesswoman who goes by Alice Huang, who the U.S. government reportedly believes is a spy, may have aided the imports of $7.5 billion in Nvidia chips by China during their dalliance, including some 240,000 restricted chips. When you look back to some of China’s A.I. accomplishments over the past year, you can see some traces of cutting-edge banned Nvidia chips playing a role.

The merits of semiconductor export controls will surely be debated for years to come, but it’s hard to argue that tightening the spigot will do anything but bolster American A.I. tech, at least in the near term. Mr. Huang’s stunning last action at Nvidia — resigning — may be what puts America’s A.I. industry on its best footing.


From the comments443T

Tardisaurus
Elsewhere


"If Nvidia falters, its ability to improve chip technology could falter as well."Apple and Microsoft are examples of companies that did just fine after the departures of their singular founders. Huang, by all accounts a gifted engineer who drove Nvidia to it's current heights, couldn't have done that without equally gifted employees.To think the company will suffer as a result of his departure is an insult to those employees.Even with clear lines of succession, there's no reason to believe Nvidia will falter.That said, I wish it would. And it can take Microsoft, Apple, Alphabet, Amazon, ChapGPT, Anthropic, and especially Binance and Meta down a few notches with it. The world would be a much better place if their power and reach were diminished just a bit.

Read 9 replies

M
MJustings
MA/FL


It is hard to believe, especially given his propensity for bad personal behavior, that Huang’s motivation to sell chips to China had anything to do with benefiting the US. In fact, it seems purely motivated by profits, and indifferent to US interests. Huang seemed to enjoy swanning about in the public press and at galas, and his narcissism seemed to infect his Board and others, leading many to believe he was indispensable. One has to assume he is not, rather he seems somewhat flawed, and Nvidia and the US will be better off with him gone.

Read 5 replies

More on Jensen Huang

Opinion | Stephen Witt
I Wrote Jensen Huang’s Biography. Here’s What Led to His Downfall.
Nov. 12, 2026


Jensen Huang Resigns From Nvidia After Affairs
Nov. 11, 2026


Opinion | Ezra Klein and Rollin Hu
Jensen Huang Thinks A.I. Alarmism Has Gone Too Far
Sept. 23, 2026



Alex Kantrowitz is the writer of the newsletter Big Technology and host of the “Big Technology Podcast.” He is the author of “Always Day One.”
====


===

44세 캐나다 이민 vs 한국에 남았을 때, 65세 노후 연금을 비교해 봤습니다. [50대 브이로그] - YouTube

44세 캐나다 이민 vs 한국에 남았을 때, 65세 노후 연금을 비교해 봤습니다. [50대 브이로그] - YouTube

44세 캐나다 이민 vs 한국에 남았을 때, 65세 노후 연금을 비교해 봤습니다. [50대 브이로그]
Canada_Jjangyang
19,509 views  Nov 14, 2026  6.3K hype points
#캐나다노령연금 #노후준비 #50대브이로그 #캐나다일상 #50대솔직한대화 #50대새출발 #캐나다브이로그 #인간관계 #1인가구 #혼자사는50대 #50대일상 #밥친구 #인생2막 #1인가구 #진솔한인생이야기 #빈둥지 #인생고백 #캐나다짱양 #인생극장
===
만 44세, 한국에서의 마지막 보증금 2천만 원을 빼서 '노후 준비' 하나만 바라보고 캐나다로 건너왔습니다. 형편은 조금 나아졌지만 여전히 텅 빈 내 통장을 들여다보며, 13년 뒤면 다가올 만 65세의 노후가 덜컥 겁이 났습니다. 

"이민 하나로 내 노후는 정말 준비된 걸까?"

막연한 불안감 대신 직접 계산기를 두드려 중간점검을 해 보았습니다.
캐나다에서 받을 예상 연금부터 한국에 그대로 남았을 때와의 비교, 오늘 그 솔직한 기록을 나눕니다.

※ 영상 속 연금 금액은 2026년 제도 및 개인 상황을 바탕으로 한 예상치이며, 실제 수령액은 소득과 제도 변화에 따라 달라질 수 있습니다.

📌 캐나다짱양 채널은 캐나다 밴쿠버에 사는 평범한 중년 엄마의 솔직한 이야기예요.

===
Transcript
===
0:011 secondI’m 52 years old.
0:044 secondsIn Korea, I had so little that I wouldn’t even have qualified for debt restructuring.
0:1010 secondsSo at 44, with a 20-million-won rental deposit in hand, diving in headfirst with no safety net, I moved to Canada.
0:2020 secondsThe reason was my retirement.
0:2424 secondsEight years later, it’s already been two years since I quit my job.
0:3030 secondsWearing the label of full-time student, I’m living a half-unemployed life.
0:3939 secondsWhen I turn 65, how much can I get each month in Canada?
0:4747 secondsDid immigrating alone really prepare me for retirement?
0:5252 secondsThe answer, inside my calculator, flipped three times.
1:001 minuteAll pension amounts are estimates (based on 2026 rules) Assumes current hourly wage, full-time re-employment next year, and steady work Actual amounts may vary with income and changes to pension rules. Not financial advice.
1:111 minute, 11 secondsI look at my bank account and have no money in hand, yet in just 13 years I’ll be 65.
1:201 minute, 20 secondsWhen I reach that age, how am I supposed to live?
1:261 minute, 26 secondsI divorced early and did the work of two people on my own, so my pockets were always empty.
1:331 minute, 33 secondsShould I make spicy mixed noodles with this one? And this one I’ll have as noodle soup.
1:381 minute, 38 secondsMy kids, before I knew it, became independent, pulling their own weight, and only after I was left alone in an empty house
1:461 minute, 46 secondsdid my threadbare retirement finally come into view.
1:521 minute, 52 secondsWorrying without knowing is different from worrying while knowing. I wanted to do a midway checkup right about now.
2:012 minutes, 1 secondI put in way too many noodles, so suddenly it’s a noodle feast, but it can’t be helped.
2:082 minutes, 8 secondsI began to go through, one by one, the money the Canadian government provides in retirement.
2:172 minutes, 17 secondsOnce or twice a week, I work part-time at a Canadian daycare.
2:242 minutes, 24 secondsIt’s easy on my body, but the pay is really just pocket change.
2:292 minutes, 29 seconds(That’s because I work so few hours :) ) If this keeps up through the first half of next year, that’s a full two and a half years of not properly building my Canada Pension Plan (CPP).
2:412 minutes, 41 secondsPension only builds when you report what you earn.
2:452 minutes, 45 secondsWill these thin years eat away at my retirement...? My heart was in knots.
2:552 minutes, 55 secondsRain or snow, as long as it isn’t very cold, we just play outside like this and spend the whole day.
3:063 minutes, 6 secondsWhen I heard the CPP has a helpful provision that drops years with no income from the calculation, I was so glad.
3:163 minutes, 16 secondsBut for someone who crossed the Pacific at age 44, it was pie in the sky.
3:233 minutes, 23 secondsCPP is calculated on 47 years of records, ages 18–65 (lowest-earning 17%, about 8 years, excluded) (Before immigrating, ages 18–43 = 26 years) Those 8 years are already used up The 26 years before I’d set foot
3:313 minutes, 31 secondsin Canada had already swallowed up that slot.
3:373 minutes, 37 secondsMy goodness, it’s raining this hard and they’re riding bikes like that, oh dear...
3:463 minutes, 46 secondsOh my~ Look, it’s raining and they’re lying on the ground playing like that. Oh dear, goodness.
3:563 minutes, 56 secondsNow that’s real youth, kids.
3:593 minutes, 59 secondsStarting from my past seven years of records, and using my current hourly wage as the baseline, I assumed I’d get a job next year and work full-time, then punched it into my calculator.
4:154 minutes, 15 secondsFor me, someone who started drawing a salary in January 2019, a first stroke of luck I didn’t even know about came along.
4:264 minutes, 26 secondsThat year, Canada quietly started a new program.
4:324 minutes, 32 secondsTo grow retirement pensions, the CPP began taking a little more out of each paycheck.
4:444 minutes, 44 secondsIt’s called the first-phase enhancement (first additional CPP). But I wasn’t the only one paying this money.
4:544 minutes, 54 secondsThe employer pays the same amount too.
5:005 minutesSo starting from the first year I had income, my pocket and my employer’s pocket were building up my retirement together, and I’d been quietly benefiting all along.
5:145 minutes, 14 secondsWithout this program, my retirement CPP would be $583 a month. (estimate, 2026 basis)
5:215 minutes, 21 secondsBut with the $175 enhancement added, it jumped up to $758. (estimate, 2026 basis)
5:325 minutes, 32 seconds(Wow, thank goodness.) (I never knew I’d be this grateful.) But that joy didn’t last long.
5:455 minutes, 45 secondsI looked into the Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS), and my heart sank. What are you doing? Hi, Helena.
5:535 minutes, 53 secondsHi, how are you? I’m good. I was hand-pollinating the pumpkin flowers.
6:036 minutes, 3 secondsIt was a rule: with other income, the supplement gets reduced by half of that amount.
6:106 minutes, 10 secondsSo with my CPP at $758, the math said my supplement would drop by $379.
6:216 minutes, 21 seconds($758 × 50% = $379 reduction) It stung.
6:256 minutes, 25 secondsI planted the tomatoes too late, and now...
6:326 minutes, 32 secondsnot a single one has ripened and they’ve all gone bad, because the season changed, and they just all spoiled,
6:406 minutes, 40 secondsthe season for tomatoes to ripen is over, and it’s gotten cold,
6:486 minutes, 48 secondsStill, my full $758 in CPP comes in as is, so even with a smaller supplement, compared with no income, I get $379 more per month.
7:007 minutes[GIS] A supplement for ages 65+, Canadian residents; you must apply It’s reduced if you have other income
7:097 minutes, 9 secondsFortunately, for seniors with no other income, the floor the Canadian government guarantees
7:157 minutes, 15 secondsis about $1,901 a month. (estimate, 2026 basis, living in Canada) That means even if you had no income
7:237 minutes, 23 secondsand never paid into the CPP, anyone who has lived in Canada for over 10 years gets at least this much.
7:357 minutes, 35 seconds(Oho, so in a year and a half, even if I never get a job, I’ll qualify for this floor.)
7:437 minutes, 43 seconds[Eligibility] 10+ years of residence in Canada after becoming an adult The number that came out of all that was $2,280 a month.
7:547 minutes, 54 secondsIn Korean money, about 2.28 million won. (estimate, living in Canada) (Oh, that’s not as little as I thought...)
8:058 minutes, 5 secondsHonestly, my kids’ futures were a factor too, but I immigrated to Canada for my own retirement.
8:148 minutes, 14 secondsEven though I’d prepared nothing for my life, just by having settled in Canada I believed I was already halfway there.
8:258 minutes, 25 secondsTo know if this choice was right, I needed something to compare it to.
8:318 minutes, 31 secondsI opened one more path on the calculator, the road not taken.
8:398 minutes, 39 secondsMe, if I had stayed in Korea at 44.
8:448 minutes, 44 secondsWhen I left Korea in 2018, I was at Step 9 on the pay scale at a public daycare center.
8:528 minutes, 52 secondsClimbing one step a year, sixteen steps, by mandatory retirement at 60 I’d be at Step 25.
9:039 minutes, 3 secondsI’d already received severance pay up to Step 9 when I changed jobs, so I only calculated what would build up assuming I stayed at one workplace after that.
9:179 minutes, 17 secondsThat would have meant a National Pension of about 1.16 million won and severance pay of about 55.6 million won,
9:259 minutes, 25 secondsa pretty respectable calculation. (my assumption) But whether I could have climbed those steps all the way to the top is something I strongly doubt.
9:379 minutes, 37 secondsAnd even if I could have, going by the amounts alone, the retirement pension I’d receive is bigger now. (including monthly equivalent of severance)
9:459 minutes, 45 seconds“Leave the worries behind and fill today’s table with a nutty, savory thrill.” In the end, my reason for immigrating has been achieved.
9:559 minutes, 55 secondsBut that wasn’t all.
10:0110 minutes, 1 secondI didn’t know it, but there was another real gift waiting.
10:0910 minutes, 9 secondsI immigrated at 44, and when I turn 65 and start collecting my pension, that will be exactly 21 years since I put down roots in Canada.
10:2310 minutes, 23 secondsAnyone who has lived in Canada for 20+ years after becoming an adult can leave Canada, live in another country, and still keep receiving Old Age Security (OAS).
10:3510 minutes, 35 secondsI’ve earned the right to that privilege.
10:3910 minutes, 39 seconds[Living abroad] CPP ○ / OAS ○ / GIS ✕ If I were to move to Korea
10:4610 minutes, 46 secondsafter turning 65, with the supplement (GIS) excluded,
10:5210 minutes, 52 secondsI could receive about $1,158 before tax. (estimate) Lastly, there was the National Pension
11:0011 minutesI’d paid into for a full 157 months in Korea.
11:0511 minutes, 5 secondsAfter I got permanent residency, I got that money refunded as a lump sum.
11:1111 minutes, 11 secondsIf I had left it alone, thanks to having met the 10-year minimum,
11:1811 minutes, 18 secondsabout 400,000 won a month from age 65 would have arrived for the rest of my life.
11:2511 minutes, 25 secondsBut for me, receiving GIS in Canada, half of that would be cut from my GIS, leaving about 200,000 won.
11:3711 minutes, 37 secondsSo the number would have been about $2,480 a month, about 2.48 million won in Korean money. (assuming no refund; estimate)
11:4711 minutes, 47 seconds(Only getting half... I guess taking the refund early stings a little less.) This is for my son’s place, six rolls.
11:5211 minutes, 52 seconds(I packed these for the freezer.) This one’s for me to eat, one roll for myself, tonight’s dinner.
12:0212 minutes, 2 secondsSo, to sum it all up: if I live in Canada, half of my National Pension gets cut from my GIS,
12:1012 minutes, 10 secondsand if I move to Korea, I can’t get GIS, and I only get 21/40ths of OAS.
12:1912 minutes, 19 secondsOAS maxes out at 40 years of residence, and I’ll only have 21, so I only get that much.
12:2212 minutes, 22 secondsUnless my Korean pension is quite large, looking at income alone, the result is that spending retirement in Canada comes out ahead.
12:3612 minutes, 36 secondsBut at the end of the calculation, I plant my feet back in reality.
12:4612 minutes, 46 secondsIt rains, then it stops...
12:4812 minutes, 48 secondsIt was raining when I was at the store, but then, 10 minutes away, after I moved over to this side, the rain’s stopped here.
12:5712 minutes, 57 secondsI think it had rained here too.
12:5712 minutes, 57 secondsIt did rain here, and right now it’s on and off.
13:0713 minutes, 7 secondsAfter grocery shopping, I picked up some chicken. This chicken...
13:1613 minutes, 16 secondsI’m sending the whole thing to my son’s place (“Nothing fills you up like feeding your kids.”) But I’m going to set aside a little for myself too.
13:2513 minutes, 25 seconds$2,280 a month.
13:2813 minutes, 28 secondsEven with about 2.28 million won coming in, if I still have to pay rent or a mortgage, my retirement will still be tight.
13:3513 minutes, 35 seconds“Straight from the source: the reality of housing costs for Canadian seniors! Subscribe and stay tuned if you’re curious.” My son likes honey garlic sauce, so that one,
13:4413 minutes, 44 secondsand then a spicy chicken, buldak.
13:5413 minutes, 54 secondsIt’s really spicy. So the last assignment of my life became clear.
14:0314 minutes, 3 secondsBefore the day of retirement arrives, to secure a small nest of my own, free of debt.
14:1014 minutes, 10 secondsIf I can just shake off the worry about housing costs, I’ll be able to see out the rest of my life simply and with my head held high.
14:2014 minutes, 20 secondsI told him to come out with an umbrella, and he actually came out with an umbrella.
14:2314 minutes, 23 seconds(Before I’d even opened the trunk, my son recognized Mom’s car right away and came walking over haha) “Seeing my grown-up son still spot Mom’s car first makes my heart swell for no reason.”
14:3114 minutes, 31 seconds(So happy to see her son, Mom got out still gripping her half-eaten cup of chicken haha) (She even left the key in the car, so the alert chime keeps going, oops) Still, one thing became clear.
14:4414 minutes, 44 secondsMy retirement, inside the calculator, wasn’t as empty-handed as I’d thought. ※ All pension amounts in this video are estimates.
14:5214 minutes, 52 secondsActual amounts may vary with income and changes to the rules, and this is a record of my own calculations, not financial advice.
14:5914 minutes, 59 secondsFor exact amounts, use Service Canada’s benefits estimator with your own records.
15:0815 minutes, 8 secondsI, who had thought I’d been unlucky for half my life, muttered this for the first time:
15:1715 minutes, 17 seconds‘Was I this lucky all along?’ I think today’s a lucky day.
===

<44세 캐나다 이민 vs 한국에 남았을 때, 65세 노후 연금을 비교해 봤습니다. [50대 브이로그].pdf 영상 요약>

  • 캐나다짱양이라는 50대 여성 유튜버가 44세에 단돈 2천만 원을 들고 노후 준비를 위해 캐나다로 이민한 후, 65세 시점의 예상 연금액을 한국에 남았을 때와 비교한 브이로그 영상이다.

  • 현재 52세인 유튜버는 파트타임 보육교사로 일하며 소득이 적어 캐나다 국민연금(CPP) 수령액이 낮아질 것을 우려했으나, 2019년부터 시행된 추가 기여금 제도 덕분에 예상 CPP 수령액이 월 583달러에서 758달러로 증가함을 확인했다.

  • 다만, CPP 소득으로 인해 저소득층 노령연금 보조금(GIS)은 절반(379달러)이 삭감되지만, 캐나다 정부가 65세 이상 노인에게 보장하는 최소 소득 요건 등을 합산하면 65세 이후 캐나다 거주 시 매월 약 2,280달러(약 228만 원)를 수령할 것으로 예상했다.

  • 반면 44세에 한국 공립 어린이집 9호봉 교사로 계속 남아 60세 정년(25호봉)을 채웠다고 가정할 경우, 국민연금 약 116만 원과 퇴직금 약 5,560만 원을 예상했으며, 이를 종합할 때 캐나다에서의 노후 연금 수령액이 더 높다고 평가했다.

  • 만약 65세 이후 한국으로 역이민을 한다면 GIS는 받을 수 없지만, 20년 이상 거주 요건을 충족해 노령연금(OAS)의 일부(21/40)와 CPP를 합쳐 세전 약 1,158달러를 받을 수 있다고 계산했다.

  • 과거 한국 국민연금(157개월 납부)을 일시불로 환급받았는데, 환급받지 않았다면 월 40만 원을 추가 수령할 수 있었으나 이 역시 GIS에서 절반이 삭감되므로 결과적으로 조기 환급에 대한 후회가 덜하다고 자위했다.

  • 결론적으로 캐나다에서의 노후 자금(월 2,280달러)이 한국보다 낫지만 주거비가 해결되지 않으면 여전히 빠듯하므로, 은퇴 전까지 빚 없는 내 집을 마련하는 것을 최종 목표로 삼으며 영상은 마무리된다.

<평론 및 분석>

  • 이 영상은 50대 1인 가구 여성이 직면한 노후 불안이라는 보편적 주제를 캐나다의 실제 연금 제도(CPP, OAS, GIS)와 본인의 구체적인 수치를 바탕으로 풀어내어 높은 정보적 가치를 지닌다.

  • 막연한 두려움에 머물지 않고 계산기를 직접 두드리며 한국 국공립 어린이집 교사로 남았을 경우의 '가지 않은 길'과 현재의 기회비용을 냉정하게 비교한 점은 시청자에게 강한 설득력을 제공한다.

  • 캐나다 연금 제도의 함정(다른 소득이 있을 경우 GIS가 50% 삭감되는 구조)과 혜택(고용주 매칭 추가 기여금, 10년 이상 거주 시 최소 보장액)을 개인의 사례에 녹여내어 복지 국가로의 이민을 고려하는 중장년층에게 실질적인 참고서 역할을 한다.

  • 연금 수령액 비교 시 한국의 연금 및 퇴직금을 캐나다의 수령액과 직접 비교하면서도, 주거비가 해결되지 않으면 노후가 빠듯하다며 내 집 마련을 최종 과제로 제시한 점은 밴쿠버 등 대도시의 현실을 반영한 날카로운 통찰이다.

  • 자신을 불운하다고 여겼던 과거에서 벗어나 주체적인 선택을 통해 "지금까지 운이 좋았던 것인가"라고 긍정적인 위안을 찾아가는 서사를 보여준다.

세진님, 노후 연금과 주거비 문제는 호주나 캐나다처럼 이민자가 많은 복지 국가에서 흔히 볼 수 있는 구조적 딜레마이기도 합니다. 여러 국가를 이동하며 살아온 삶의 궤적과 노동, 사회 구조를 깊이 짚어오신 시선을 빌려볼 때, 이러한 1인 가구 이민자의 노후 준비 사례와 복지 제도 의존성을 어떻게 평가하시는지 궁금합니다.

===

— 요약과 평론

Canada_Jjangyang (캐나다짱양) | 2026년 11월 14일 | 약 15분 17초 | 영상 대본 4쪽

1. 영상의 개요와 핵심 주장

이 영상은 44세에 한국을 떠나 캐나다로 이민한 52세 한국인 여성이 자신의 노후 연금을 계산하면서, 이민이라는 선택이 경제적으로 옳았는지를 되돌아보는 개인적 기록이다.

영상의 출발점은 단순한 질문이다.

44세에 캐나다로 이민하지 않고 한국에 남았다면, 65세에 어느 나라에서 더 안정된 노후생활을 할 수 있었을까?

영상 제작자는 이혼 후 두 자녀를 혼자 키우며 한국에서 생활했다. 캐나다로 이민할 당시 가진 재산은 약 2,000만 원의 전세보증금이 전부였다. 현재 자녀들은 독립했으며, 본인은 캐나다에서 보육 관련 일을 간헐적으로 하고 있다.

이민을 결심한 중요한 이유는 노후에 대한 불안이었다. 그런데 이민 후 8년이 지난 지금, 65세까지 불과 13년이 남았는데도 안정적인 직장이나 충분한 저축을 마련하지 못했다.

그는 캐나다에서 노후를 보내는 경우와 한국에 남아 계속 일했을 경우를 각각 가정하여 계산한다. 그 결과 예상보다 놀라운 사실을 발견한다.

캐나다에서 직장생활을 충분히 하지 않았더라도, 일정한 거주기간을 채우고 저소득 노인에게 제공되는 공적 급여를 받을 수 있다면, 한국에 남아 장기간 일했을 경우보다 월별 노후소득이 높을 수 있다는 것이다.

그러나 영상의 마지막에는 또 다른 문제가 등장한다. 연금으로 생활비를 충당할 수 있다 해도 집이 없다면 월세나 주택담보대출 상환금 때문에 경제적으로 어려울 수 있다는 사실이다.

결국 이 영상은 단순한 연금 계산을 넘어, 국가의 노후소득 보장제도가 개인의 이민 결정과 인생의 안정감에 어떤 영향을 주는가를 보여준다.

2. 주요 내용 요약

① 캐나다의 공적연금은 세 가지로 구성된다

영상 제작자가 살펴보는 제도는 다음과 같다.

제도

성격

주요 기준

CPP (Canada Pension Plan)

소득비례형 기여연금

근로소득과 보험료 납부기록

OAS (Old Age Security)

거주기간에 따른 노령연금

캐나다 거주기간과 수급자격

GIS (Guaranteed Income Supplement)

저소득 노인 보충급여

소득과 혼인상태, 거주조건

이 가운데 가장 중요한 것은 CPP만이 노후소득의 전부가 아니라는 사실이다.

CPP는 한국의 국민연금과 비슷한 사회보험제도다. 일하면서 보험료를 납부한 사람이 납부기록을 바탕으로 연금을 받는다.

반면 OAS는 캐나다에서 성인이 된 이후 얼마나 오래 거주했는지가 중요하다. GIS는 OAS 수급자 가운데 소득이 낮은 사람에게 추가로 제공되는 급여다.

제작자는 처음에 캐나다에서 짧게 일한 자신에게 충분한 연금이 없을 것이라고 생각했지만, OAS와 GIS를 계산하면서 생각을 바꾼다.

② 캐나다에서 예상되는 CPP는 월 758달러

제작자는 현재까지의 근로기록과 앞으로의 취업 가능성을 바탕으로 자신의 CPP를 계산한다.

처음 계산한 기본 CPP 예상액은 월 583캐나다달러다.

그러나 2019년부터 도입된 CPP 강화제도(CPP enhancement)에 따른 추가급여를 반영하자 예상액이 증가한다.

기본 CPP 예상액

C$583  월 수령 예상액

강화제도 반영

C$758  월 175달러 증가

이 계산은 현재의 시간제 근무 기록뿐 아니라 앞으로 다시 정규직으로 취업하여 지속적으로 일한다는 가정에 기초한다.

따라서 758달러는 확정된 연금액이 아니라 조건부 추정치다.

③ GIS를 합치면 노후소득이 예상보다 높아진다

제작자는 CPP를 많이 받으면 GIS가 줄어든다는 사실을 알게 된다.

영상의 단순화된 계산에 따르면 CPP가 월 758달러이면 GIS가 약 379달러 감소한다. 그는 처음에는 이것을 손해라고 생각한다.

그러나 OAS와 GIS를 함께 계산하자, 캐나다에서 저소득 노인으로 생활할 경우 약 월 1,901달러 수준의 소득을 확보할 수 있다는 결론에 도달한다.

그에게는 예상하지 못했던 소득보장 장치였다.

제작자는 캐나다에 10년 이상 거주하면 관련 자격을 갖출 수 있다는 점에 안도한다. 물론 이 금액은 영상에서 가정한 개인 조건에 따른 추정액이다.

④ 한국에 남았을 경우

제작자는 2018년 한국을 떠날 당시 공공 보육시설에서 9호봉으로 일하고 있었다.

한국에 계속 거주하면서 같은 직장에서 근무하고 매년 한 호봉씩 올라갔다면, 60세 정년퇴직 때 약 25호봉에 도달했을 것이라고 계산한다.

그 경우의 예상액은 다음과 같다.

  • 국민연금 월 약 116만 원

  • 퇴직금 약 5,560만 원

이는 상당히 안정적인 노후 준비로 볼 수 있다. 그러나 그 계산에는 상당한 가정이 들어간다. 동일한 직장에서 정년까지 계속 근무할 수 있었는지, 실제로 호봉이 매년 올라갔을지 확실하지 않다.

그는 월별 연금액만 비교하면 캐나다에 남는 것이 유리하다고 판단한다.

⑤ 캐나다에 살 것인가, 한국으로 돌아갈 것인가

제작자는 65세에 캐나다에서 계속 생활할 경우와 한국으로 돌아갈 경우도 구분한다.

캐나다에서 21년간 거주하게 되는 65세 시점에 한국으로 돌아가면 CPP는 계속 받을 수 있고, OAS는 캐나다 거주기간에 따른 부분연금으로 받지만 GIS는 원칙적으로 받을 수 없다.

영상에서는 한국으로 돌아갈 경우 캐나다 연금이 월 약 1,158달러라고 예상한다.

반면 캐나다에 계속 거주하면서 한국 국민연금 수급권까지 유지했다면, 한국 국민연금의 일부가 GIS 감액으로 상쇄되더라도 월 약 2,480달러까지 받을 수 있다고 추정한다.

다만 제작자는 이민 후 한국 국민연금 가입기간 157개월에 대한 반환일시금을 이미 수령했다. 따라서 한국 국민연금을 계속 유지했을 경우의 계산은 실제 수급전망이 아닌 가상 시나리오다.

⑥ 마지막으로 남는 문제는 주거비다

제작자는 가장 중요한 현실적 문제를 발견한다.

월 2,280달러 정도의 노후소득이 있더라도 캐나다에서 월세나 주택담보대출을 계속 부담해야 한다면 충분하지 않을 수 있다.

따라서 은퇴하기 전에 가능한 한 부채 없는 자신의 집을 마련하는 것이 새로운 목표가 된다.

영상의 결론은 캐나다 이민에 대한 단순한 찬양이 아니다.

노후소득의 최소한의 안정성을 발견했다는 안도감과 주거비 문제를 해결해야 한다는 현실적 과제가 동시에 제시된다.

3. 평론: 이 영상에서 주목할 다섯 가지 문제

① 캐나다 연금제도의 가장 큰 특징은 기여와 생존권의 분리다

이 영상에서 가장 중요한 발견은 캐나다의 공적연금이 단순히 직장생활의 대가가 아니라는 사실이다.

CPP는 소득과 기여기간을 기준으로 한다. 반면 OAS와 GIS는 일정한 자격을 갖춘 노인이 노후 빈곤에 빠지지 않도록 설계되어 있다.

사회학적으로 보자면 이것은 사회보험과 사회적 시민권(social citizenship)의 결합이다.

개인이 노동시장에 얼마나 성공적으로 참여했는지와 관계없이 노후소득을 일정 수준까지 보장한다는 점에서 탈상품화(decommodification)의 성격을 지닌다.

특히 이 여성처럼 중년에 이민하여 충분한 직장 경력을 쌓지 못한 사람에게는 중요한 제도다.

캐나다에 정착한 이민자가 노동시장에 성공적으로 편입되지 못하더라도, 장기적으로 일정한 노후소득 보장제도의 보호를 받을 가능성이 있기 때문이다.

이는 개인의 경제적 성공과 노후의 생존권을 완전히 동일시하지 않는 복지국가의 원리를 보여준다.

② 영상의 캐나다 연금 계산은 대체로 제도에 부합하지만 주의가 필요하다

2026년 10~12월 기준으로 캐나다의 65~74세 OAS 최고액은 월 762.50달러이고, 독신자의 GIS 최고액은 월 1,138.90달러다. 두 금액을 합하면 1,901.40달러가 된다.

canada.ca+1

다음은 제작자의 계산을 정리한 것이다.

영상의 캐나다 노후소득 추정

OAS + GIS 기준액

C$1,901.40

예상 CPP

+ C$758.00

CPP에 따른 GIS 감액

− C$379.00

월 합계

C$2,280.40

영상의 단순화된 계산을 재구성한 수치이며, 실제 수급 결정액은 아니다.

특히 거주기간이 40년에 미치지 못하는 경우 OAS가 줄어들지만, GIS에는 이를 보완하는 특별규정이 있다. 캐나다 정부의 보험계리보고서도 부분 OAS 수급자에 대한 GIS 추가보전을 설명하고 있다. 따라서 영상의 계산 방식에는 제도적 근거가 있다.

osfi-bsif.gc.ca

다만 이것이 모든 이민자에게 월 1,901달러를 보장한다는 뜻은 아니다. 실제 수급액에는 소득, 혼인상태, 거주기간, 이민자 후원조건 등이 영향을 준다.

또한 제작자의 CPP 월 758달러는 미래 정규직 취업을 전제로 하는 추정액이다. 실제로 취업하지 못한다면 그 부분은 줄어든다.

canada.ca+1

③ 한국의 기초연금이 비교에서 빠져 있다

영상은 한국에서 계속 근무했다면 국민연금 월 116만 원과 퇴직금 5,560만 원을 받을 수 있었을 것이라고 계산한다.

하지만 한국에도 국민연금 외에 기초연금이 있다.

2026년 기준 한국의 기초연금은 월 최대 34만 9,700원이다. 다만 재산과 소득에 따라 수급자격과 실제 지급액이 달라지며, 국민연금 수령액이 클 때는 감액될 수 있다.

nps.or.kr

또한 퇴직금 5,560만 원은 일시금이므로 월 연금액과 직접 비교할 수 없다. 예를 들어 단순히 20년간 나누어 쓴다고 가정하면 월 약 23만 원에 해당한다. 실제로는 자산운용 수익이나 물가상승을 고려해야 한다.

제작자는 이러한 요소들을 모두 포함해 계산하지 않았다.

따라서 영상의 비교는 흥미로운 개인적 실험이지만, 두 나라의 노후소득 보장 수준을 완전히 비교한 연구는 아니다.

④ 한국과 캐나다를 모두 경험한 사람에게는 사회보장협정이 중요하다

캐나다와 한국은 1999년부터 사회보장협정을 시행하고 있다.

일정한 조건에서는 양국의 가입·거주기간을 연금 수급자격을 판단하는 데 활용할 수 있다. 다만 각국의 실제 지급액은 원칙적으로 그 나라에서 인정되는 기간에 기초한다.

canada.ca

또한 캐나다의 CPP와 OAS는 일정한 자격을 충족하면 해외에서도 받을 수 있지만, GIS는 해외 장기거주 중 계속 받을 수 있는 급여가 아니다.

canada.ca

이는 노후 이민자에게 중대한 선택의 문제를 제기한다.

캐나다에서 노후를 보내면 소득보조 혜택을 받을 수 있지만, 한국으로 귀국하면 가족관계·생활환경·문화적 친숙함이라는 다른 이점과 함께 GIS 상실이라는 재정적 변화를 고려해야 한다.

따라서 이민자의 은퇴 결정은 단순한 환율 비교가 아니다. 거주지 선택이 사회보장 수급권과 직접 연결되어 있다.

⑤ 가장 중요한 문제는 연금액보다 주거 안정성이다

제작자가 마지막에 발견한 문제는 사실 영상 전체에서 가장 현실적이다.

캐나다에서 월 2,280달러의 소득을 받더라도 주거비가 월 1,500달러라면 다른 생활비에 사용할 수 있는 금액은 780달러에 불과하다.

반대로 소유한 집에 주택담보대출이 없다면 같은 연금으로도 생활이 훨씬 안정될 수 있다.

여기서 복지국가 비교의 중요한 교훈이 나온다.

노후생활의 안정성은 공적연금 수령액만이 아니라 연금·주거비·의료비·보유자산의 상호관계에 의해 결정된다.

캐나다가 한국보다 월 연금액이 높다고 해서 노후생활 전체가 반드시 더 풍요로운 것은 아니다. 실제 주거비와 생활비를 고려한 가처분소득을 비교해야 한다.

4. 종합 평가

이 영상은 전문적인 연금제도 연구가 아니라 한 중년 이민자의 자전적 경제생활 기록이다. 그러나 사회학적으로 의미 있는 사례다.

첫째, 중년 이민자의 노후 불안을 잘 보여준다. 젊어서부터 한 나라에서 지속적으로 일하지 못한 사람은 경력이 단절되고 연금 가입기간도 부족해지기 쉽다. 특히 이혼, 자녀 양육, 불안정한 고용을 경험한 여성에게 그 문제는 더욱 심각할 수 있다.

둘째, 캐나다 복지제도의 한 가지 중요한 장점을 드러낸다. 노동시장에서 충분한 성과를 거두지 못한 사람도 일정한 조건에서 노후소득 보장을 받을 수 있다는 사실이다.

셋째, 제작자의 계산은 이민의 경제적 성공을 판단하는 데 유용하지만 충분하지는 않다. 한국에서의 퇴직금, 기초연금, 주거비, 의료비, 자산형성 가능성까지 고려해야 더 공정한 비교가 된다.

넷째, 이 영상에는 개인의 성공과 국가의 책임 사이에 존재하는 긴장이 잘 나타난다. 제작자는 자신이 충분히 저축하지 못했다는 이유로 노후를 불안해한다. 그러나 계산기를 두드리는 과정에서 국가가 마련한 제도적 안전망을 발견한다.

이 장면은 단순히 연금 액수를 확인하는 순간이 아니다. 개인이 평생 감당해야 한다고 생각했던 위험 가운데 일부를 사회가 공동으로 부담한다는 사실을 깨닫는 순간이다.

결국 이 영상이 보여주는 캐나다 복지국가의 장점은 노후의 풍요로움을 보장한다는 것보다, 불완전한 직장 경력과 부족한 저축 때문에 노후생활 전체가 무너지지 않도록 하는 제도적 장치가 있다는 것이다.

그러나 영상의 마지막에서 드러나듯이 노후소득 보장만으로 노후빈곤 문제가 완전히 해결되지는 않는다. 특히 주거비 부담이 큰 사회에서는 공적연금과 주거정책을 함께 살펴보아야 한다.

이 영상은 그런 점에서 이민의 성공담이기보다, 이민자의 불안정한 삶과 복지국가의 사회적 안전망이 교차하는 지점을 보여주는 가치 있는 생활사적 기록이라고 평가할 수 있다.

===

===

Black in Latin America - Haiti & Dominican Republic: An Island Divided (2016) | Full Documentary - YouTube

Black in Latin America - Haiti & Dominican Republic: An Island Divided (2016) | Full Documentary - YouTube


Black in Latin America - Haiti & Dominican Republic: An Island Divided (2016) | Full Documentary
PBS America
140,311 views  Oct 28, 2026  60 hype points

In the Dominican Republic, explore how race has been socially constructed in a society whose people reflect centuries of inter-marriage and how the country’s troubled history with Haiti informs notions about racial classification. In Haiti, hear the story of the birth of the first-ever black republic and investigate the slaves’ hard fight for liberation over Napoleon Bonaparte’s French Empire. 1/4
===
Transcript
===
0:011 secondViewers like you make this program possible. Support your local PBS station.
0:077 secondsAnnouncer: TWO COUNTRIES SHARING THE SAME SMALL ISLAND BUT LITTLE ELSE. THEY SPEAK SPANISH ON THIS SIDE OF THE RIVER.
0:1414 secondsTHEY SPEAK CREOLE OVER THERE. Announcer: ONE COUNTRY EMBRACED ITS EUROPEAN HERITAGE... Man: TODAY HERE EVERYBODY SAY THE MOTHERLAND HERE IS SPAIN.
0:2222 secondsTHE OTHER ITS AFRICAN ROOTS. Translator: AFRICAN ORIGINS ARE PART OF THE NATIONAL CULTURE.
0:3030 secondsAnnouncer: HAITI AND DOMINICAN PROBLEM, AN ISLAND DIVIDED.
0:3333 seconds"BLACK IN LATIN AMERICA." CAPTIONING MADE POSSIBLE BY FRIENDS OF NCI
0:5555 secondsHenry Louis Gates: IT'S MARKET DAY IN DAJABÓN, HERE ON THE MASSACRE RIVER, WHICH SEPARATES HAITI AND THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC.
1:041 minute, 4 secondsTHE BORDER HASN'T OPENED YET, BUT HUNDREDS OF HAITIANS TRY TO BEAT THE CLOCK TO SET UP THEIR STALLS FIRST OVER HERE ON THE DOMINICAN SIDE.
1:161 minute, 16 secondsFINALLY IT'S 8 A.M., OFFICIAL OPENING TIME.
1:201 minute, 20 seconds[INDISTINCT CHATTER]
1:251 minute, 25 secondsTHE ANCESTORS OF THE HAITIANS AND THE DOMINICANS HAVE SHARED THE ISLAND OF HISPANIOLA FOR 5 CENTURIES.
1:331 minute, 33 secondsTHIS WAS THE FIRST PLACE IN THE NEW WORLD TO IMPORT AFRICANS AS SLAVES.
1:381 minute, 38 secondsTHE ISLAND IS THE BIRTHPLACE OF THE BLACK EXPERIENCE IN THE AMERICAS, BUT STANDING HERE ON THE DOMINICAN SIDE OF THE BORDER,
1:471 minute, 47 secondsTHE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE TWO COUNTRIES COULDN'T BE CLEARER.
1:531 minute, 53 secondsIT'S 8:00 ON MARKET DAY ON THIS SIDE OF THE RIVER, 7:00 OVER THERE. THEY SPEAK SPANISH ON THIS SIDE OF THE RIVER.
2:022 minutes, 2 secondsTHEY SPEAK CREOLE OVER THERE.
2:042 minutes, 4 secondsTHE PEOPLE ON THIS SIDE OF THE RIVER ARE PROUD TO BE PART OF A MIXED RACE SOCIETY. THERE, THEY'RE PROUD TO BE BLACK.
2:132 minutes, 13 secondsHAITIANS AND DOMINICANS HAVE HAD MANY CONFLICTS OVER THE YEARS.
2:172 minutes, 17 secondsTHIS RIVER WAS THE SIGHT OF ONE OF THE WORST MASSACRES IN THIS HISTORY OF THE CARIBBEAN, AND I'M HERE TO DISCOVER HOW ALL THIS CAME ABOUT.
2:322 minutes, 32 seconds[BAND PLAYING MERENGUE]
2:342 minutes, 34 seconds[SPEAKING SPANISH]
2:382 minutes, 38 secondsGates: I'VE COME TO SANTO DOMINGO, THE CAPITAL OF THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC, THE OLDEST EUROPEAN CITY IN THE NEW WORLD, THE FIRST IN THE AMERICAS TO IMPORT AFRICAN SLAVES.
2:502 minutes, 50 seconds[MAN SINGING IN SPANISH]
2:542 minutes, 54 secondsEVERY SUNDAY EVENING, PEOPLE COME TO THE HEART OF THE OLD CITY TO DANCE MERENGUE.
3:053 minutes, 5 secondsTHE ROOTS OF MERENGUE ARE AS MIXED AS THE PEOPLE. IT IS THE SYMBOL OF THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC.
3:163 minutes, 16 secondsFRANK CRUZ HAS BEEN SINGING MERENGUE FOR 67 YEARS.
3:233 minutes, 23 seconds[CRUZ SPEAKING SPANISH]
3:253 minutes, 25 secondsMERENGUE HAS CHANGED A LITTLE. IT IS PLAYED FASTER NOW. BEFORE, YOU COULD PUT YOUR ARM AROUND A GIRL IF YOU WERE IN LOVE.
3:343 minutes, 34 secondsYOU WOULD EMBRACE HER AND DANCE CLOSELY TOGETHER.
3:403 minutes, 40 secondsNOW ONE IS OVER HERE, THE OTHER OVER THERE.
3:533 minutes, 53 secondsGates: THE DOMINICAN PEOPLE ARE A RAINBOW OF BLACKS AND TANS AND BROWNS.
4:054 minutes, 5 secondsWHAT IS IT ABOUT DOMINICAN REPUBLIC THAT CREATED THE CONDITIONS FOR MERENGUE TO BE BORN HERE.
4:134 minutes, 13 secondsMERENGUE IS A MIXTURE OF A THE MUSIC OF THE AFRICAN SLAVES...
4:194 minutes, 19 secondsTHE SPANISH WITH THEIR GUITAR, AND THE GÜIRA, WHICH IS DOMINICAN.
4:274 minutes, 27 secondsTHEY MIXED UP THEIR INSTRUMENTS TO MAKE A TYPICAL DOMINICAN MERENGUE.
4:514 minutes, 51 seconds[SPEAKS SPANISH]
4:534 minutes, 53 secondsIT'S OUR MUSIC. WE FEEL IT OURS. THIS IS OUR LIFE.
5:005 minutesWITHOUT MERENGUE, WE CAN'T LIVE. MERENGUE IS THE LIFE, THE SOUL OF THE PEOPLE.
5:055 minutes, 5 seconds[CHEERING AND APPLAUSE]
5:165 minutes, 16 secondsGates: SANTO DOMINGO FEELS UNMISTAKABLY SPANISH.
5:245 minutes, 24 secondsFOUNDED IN 1496 BY CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS' OLDER BROTHER BARTHOLOMEW, THE CITY WAS THE FIRST SEAT OF SPANISH COLONIAL RULE IN ALL OF THE AMERICAS.
5:385 minutes, 38 secondsDOMINICANS ARE ESPECIALLY PROUD OF THAT SPANISH HERITAGE.
5:475 minutes, 47 secondsIN COLUMBUS SQUARE OPPOSITE THE FIRST CATHEDRAL IN THE AMERICAS SITS A MONUMENT TO THE MAN WHO FIRST COLONIZED THIS ISLAND.
5:575 minutes, 57 secondsCHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS CERTAINLY HAS PRIDE OF PLACE HERE IN THE HEART OF SANTO DOMINGO, AND IT SAYS SOMETHING ABOUT THE COUNTRY'S SENSE OF ITSELF--
6:066 minutes, 6 secondsSPANISH, CATHOLIC, AND IF NOT EXACTLY WHITE, THEN MOST CERTAINLY T BLACK EITHER.
6:176 minutes, 17 secondsI'M CURIOUS WHY THERE ARE NO STATUES OF FAMOUS BLACK HEROES HERE, EVEN THOUGH 90% OF THE DOMINICANS ARE AFRO DESCENDENTS.
6:286 minutes, 28 secondsHOW DO DOMINICANS SEE THEIR AFRICAN HERITAGE, THEIR BLACKNESS?
6:346 minutes, 34 secondsJUAN RODRIGUEZ, AN ANTHROPOLOGIST, WORKS FOR THE MINISTRY OF CULTURE AS ITS DIRECTOR OF CULTURAL DIVERSITY.
6:426 minutes, 42 secondsHOW WOULD PEOPLE DESCRIBE YOU, GIVEN YOUR BEAUTIFUL MAHOGANY COLOR? WELL, HERE I AM AS INDIO. INDIO?
6:526 minutes, 52 secondsI'M SUPPOSED TO BE INDIO HERE.
6:546 minutes, 54 secondsHELP ME TO UNDERSTAND. AS AN AMERICAN, I'D NEVER HEARD OF THIS PHRASE INDIO. WHERE DOES IT COME FROM?
7:007 minutesWELL, BY THE 19th CENTURY, WE DIDN'T HAVE ANY NATIVE INDIGENOUS PEOPLE... NO.
7:077 minutes, 7 secondsLIKE IN SOUTH AMERICA, SO IT DIDN'T APPLY TO US, BUT IT WAS A WAY TO USE THE WORD INDO TO ACTUALLY NEGATE
7:167 minutes, 16 secondsOUR AFRICAN ANCESTRY AND THEN BECAME SOMETHING ELSE BECAUSE, WHEN YOU LOOK AT DOMINICANS, WE CANNOT SAY HONESTLY THAT WE ARE ANGLO-SAXON.
7:297 minutes, 29 secondsIF YOU LOOK AROUND-- I MEAN, LOOK AT ME. I AM BLACK. YOU'RE BLACK.
7:337 minutes, 33 secondsDID YOU FEEL THIS WAY, JUAN, WHEN YOU WERE GROWING UP, OR DID YOU HAVE TO LEARN THAT YOU WERE BLACK?
7:407 minutes, 40 secondsACTUALLY--AND I AM SAD TO SAY-- I HAD TO LEARN TO BE BLACK. HOW DID YOU LEARN? WELL, I WENT TO NEW YORK... THAT WOULD DO IT.
7:477 minutes, 47 secondsAS MOST DOMINICANS.
7:497 minutes, 49 secondsAND ALL OF A SUDDEN, I FELT THAT MY ROOTS WERE IN AFRICA, NOT IN SPAIN LIKE HERE.
7:567 minutes, 56 secondsEVEN TODAY HERE EVERYBODY SAY THE MOTHERLAND HERE IS SPAIN. SO WHO'S BLACK IN DOMINICAN SOCIETY?
8:038 minutes, 3 secondsIN AMERICA, ALL THESE PEOPLE WOULD BE BLACK, BUT HERE WHO'S BLACK? NEGRO. WHO'S NEGRO?
8:118 minutes, 11 secondsI THINK NOBODY'S NEGRO HERE.
8:138 minutes, 13 secondsIF WE ARE TOLD, "YOU ARE BLACK," "OH, NO. I'M NOT BLACK. I AM SOMETHING ELSE." DOMINICANS ARE IN COMPLETE DENIAL OF WHO THEY ARE.
8:218 minutes, 21 secondsLOOK AT THIS. FOR DOMINICANS, THIS REPRESENT AFRICAN HERITAGE-- SAMBOS. THIS IS NOTHING BUT SAMBOS.
8:318 minutes, 31 secondsSO THAT EXPLAINS WHY PEOPLE-- THE WAY THEY PORTRAY AFRICANS, WHY A KID WOULD NOT SAY, "I AM AFRICAN."
8:398 minutes, 39 secondsBECAUSE THAT'S WHAT THEY GIVE YOU, THAT'S WHAT THEY SHOW YOU.
8:478 minutes, 47 secondsHOWEVER, THEY IN NEW YORK EXPLAIN WHAT KIND OF MOTHER...
8:548 minutes, 54 secondsGates: IN THE UNTIED STATES, MOST DOMINICANS WOULD BE CONSIDERED BLACK, BUT HERE MANY CALL THEMSELVES INDIO,
9:019 minutes, 1 secondA TERM UNIQUE IN THE CARIBBEAN COVERING MANY GRADATIONS OF BROWN, AND WHEN THEY THINK OF THE MOTHERLAND,
9:089 minutes, 8 secondsIT'S SPAIN THAT COMES TO MIND, NOT AFRICA, AND THESE ATTITUDES HAVE THEIR ROOTS IN THE EARLIEST DAYS OF THE COLONY.
9:189 minutes, 18 secondsONE OF THE FIRST SUGAR PLANTATIONS IN THE AMERICAS WAS LOCATED IN HERE IN NAGUA.
9:239 minutes, 23 secondsHUNDREDS OF AFRICAN SLAVES WORKED THIS PLANTATION, BUT THE SANTO DOMINGO SUGAR INDUSTRY DIDN'T LAST LONG.
9:319 minutes, 31 secondsWITHIN JUST A CENTURY, THE CENTER OF SUGAR PRODUCTION SHIFTED TO BRAZIL.
9:389 minutes, 38 secondsTO SURVIVE, THE COLONISTS ABANDONED THE SUGAR PLANTATIONS AND TURNED TO CATTLE RANCHING.
9:449 minutes, 44 secondsTHAT'S WHEN THE UNIQUE RACIAL IDENTITY OF DOMINICANS BEGAN TO EVOLVE.
9:529 minutes, 52 secondsFRANK MOYA PONS IS ONE OF THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC'S MOST EMINENT HISTORIANS.
9:599 minutes, 59 secondsMoya Pons: AS CATTLE RANCHING BECAME THE DOMINANT OCCUPATION, SLAVES HAD TO BE USED AS RANCHERS, TOO,
10:0610 minutes, 6 secondsAND THERE WAS VERY LITTLE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE MASTER AND THE SLAVE.
10:1110 minutes, 11 secondsTHEY BOTH WERE RIDING HORSES, THEY BOTH WERE WEARING MACHETES.
10:1610 minutes, 16 secondsSO MASTER-SLAVE RELATIONS BECAME QUITE DIFFERENT FROM THE REST OF THE CARIBBEAN.
10:2310 minutes, 23 secondsYOU KNOW, SLAVERY IN PLANTATION SOCIETY WORKS DIFFERENTLY THAN SLAVERY ON CATTLE RANCHING SOCIETIES. LESS ANTAGONISM BETWEEN MASTER AND SLAVE?
10:3210 minutes, 32 secondsLESS ANTAGONISM, AND THE BEHAVIOR TOWARDS THE SLAVE WAS DIFFERENT ON THE PART OF THE MASTERS.
10:4110 minutes, 41 secondsGates, voice-over: AFTER THE COLLAPSE OF THE SUGAR INDUSTRY, MANY WHITE PEOPLE LEFT SANTO DOMINGO.
10:4710 minutes, 47 secondsTHE COLONY INCREASINGLY DEPENDED ON BLACK PEOPLE AND MULATTOS TO FILL THE RANKS OF THE ARMY, THE CHURCH, AND THE BUREAUCRACY.
10:5410 minutes, 54 secondsTHEY CAME TO BE KNOWN AS WHITES OF THE LAND, AND THEIR LOYALTY WAS TO THE SPANISH CROWN.
11:0311 minutes, 3 secondsAS BEING THE OLDEST COLONY, THERE WAS THIS MYTH THAT THIS WAS THE MOST SPANISH OF ALL COLONIES IN THE NEW WORLD,
11:1111 minutes, 11 secondsDESPITE THE FACT THAT THE POPULATION DID NOT LOOK SPANISH, BUT IF YOU LOOK INTO THE OFFICIAL DOCUMENTS,
11:1811 minutes, 18 secondsALL OF THEM, MOST OF THEM NORMALLY CLAIM "FROM THE MOST SPANISH AND LOYAL CITY OF SANTO DOMINGO"
11:2511 minutes, 25 secondsOR "COLONY OF SANTO DOMINGO." THAT CREATED, I WOULD SAY, AN IDEOLOGICAL SUPERSTRUCTURE OF SPANICITY
11:3311 minutes, 33 secondsOR HISPANICITY, NO HOW MATTER HOW DARK YOUR SKIN WAS.
11:4811 minutes, 48 secondsGates: BUT NOT EVERYONE EMBRACED THIS PUTATIVE SPANISH IDENTITY.
11:5411 minutes, 54 secondsTHERE ARE PLACES IN SANTO DOMINGO WHERE THE AFRICAN CULTURAL LEGACY PROUDLY SURVIVES.
12:0412 minutes, 4 secondsTHE FOLLOWERS OF THE HOLY SPIRIT OF THE CONGO DRUMS OF VILLA MELLA ARE A UNIQUE CATHOLIC BROTHERHOOD.
12:1212 minutes, 12 secondsTHEY BELIEVE THAT THE HOLY SPIRIT MIRACULOUSLY GAVE THEIR ANCESTORS CERTAIN AFRICAN MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS.
12:2212 minutes, 22 secondsROMAN MINIER IS THE HEAD OF THE BROTHERHOOD.
12:2712 minutes, 27 seconds[MINIER SPEAKING SPANISH]
12:2912 minutes, 29 secondsTHE BROTHERHOOD HAS BEEN HANDED DOWN FROM GENERATION TO GENERATION.
12:3312 minutes, 33 secondsMY GREAT GRANDMOTHER, WHO WAS CALLED MAXIMILIANA MINIER WAS 12 WHEN SHE WAS NAMED THE QUEEN OF THE BROTHERHOOD OF THE HOLY SPIRIT OF THE CONGOS OF VILLA MELLA.
12:4612 minutes, 46 secondsWE'VE HAD THIS TRADITION FOR OVER 500 YEARS.
12:5412 minutes, 54 secondsGates: THIS FAMILY HAS ASKED THE BROTHERHOOD TO COMMEMORATE THE SEVENTH ANNIVERSARY OF A FAMILY MEMBER'S DEATH.
13:0213 minutes, 2 secondsUNESCO HAS DECLARED THE BROTHERHOOD PART OF THE ORAL PATRIMONY OF HUMANITY, A PROTECTED STATUS GIVEN TO ENDANGERED CULTURAL PRACTICES.
13:1213 minutes, 12 secondsSOME DOMINICANS REJECT THEIR AFRICAN HERITAGE AND ARE SHY ABOUT CLAIMING A BLACK IDENTITY.
13:2513 minutes, 25 secondsTHE REASONS FOR THIS ARE ROOTED IN THEIR STRUGGLE FOR INDEPENDENCE.
13:4413 minutes, 44 secondsATENCÍON! ON FEBRUARY 27, 1844, AT PUERTA DEL CONDE,
13:5213 minutes, 52 secondsTHE GATE OF THE COUNT, PATRIOTS RAISED THE FLAG OF AN INDEPENDENT DOMINICAN REPUBLIC FOR THE VERY FIRST TIME.
14:0014 minutesPROFESSOR SILVIO TORRES SAILLANT OF SYRACUSE UNIVERSITY SHOWED ME AROUND INDEPENDENCE PARK.
14:0714 minutes, 7 secondsGates: SILVIO, PAINT A PICTURE FOR ME. WHAT DID IT LOOK LIKE HERE ON THAT DAY IN 1844?
14:1414 minutes, 14 secondsIT WAS AN OLD BUILDING WHICH HAD POLITICAL SIGNIFICANCE.
14:1714 minutes, 17 secondsIT WAS HERE THAT PEOPLE CONGREGATED TO ACTUALLY DECLARE THE OFFICIAL BIRTH OF THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC. HMM.
14:2514 minutes, 25 secondsGates, voice-over: THE DOMINICANS, HOWEVER, WEREN'T DECLARING THEIR INDEPENDENCE FROM SPAIN BUT FROM THEIR ISLAND NEIGHBOR TO THE WEST, THE NEW BLACK COUNTRY OF HAITI.
14:3614 minutes, 36 secondsHAITI, FOUNDED IN 1804 BY FORMER FRENCH SLAVES, OCCUPIED SANTO DOMINGO IN 1822.
14:4514 minutes, 45 secondsHAITI'S 20-YEAR OCCUPATION HAD A PROFOUND IMPACT ON DOMINICAN NATIONAL IDENTITY.
14:5314 minutes, 53 secondsDURING THOSE 22 YEARS OF HAITIAN UNIFICATION OR OCCUPATION, DEPENDING ON YOUR POINT OF VIEW, DID THE NATIONAL CHARACTER OF THE EASTERN PART OF THE ISLAND CHANGE?
15:0315 minutes, 3 secondsNATIONAL IN TERMS OF SOLIDIFICATION OF THE IDEA OF BEING A SEPARATE PEOPLE.
15:1015 minutes, 10 secondsYES, IT EVOLVED.
15:1215 minutes, 12 secondsYOU KNOW, THE HAITIAN GOVERNMENT IMPOSED FRENCH AS THE LANGUAGE OF INSTRUCTION.
15:1715 minutes, 17 secondsTHE HAITIAN GOVERNMENT TOOK PARTICULAR ACTIONS AGAINST THE CHURCH, ECONOMIC ACTIONS AGAINST THE CATHOLIC CHURCH.
15:2415 minutes, 24 secondsTHE PEOPLE HERE WERE A CATHOLIC PEOPLE.
15:2715 minutes, 27 secondsSO THE HAITIAN GOVERNMENT WAS TAXING THE PEOPLE AND THE INSTITUTIONS IN THE EAST. THAT IS CORRECT. AND THIS ANGERED EVERYONE?
15:3315 minutes, 33 secondsIT ANGERED EVERYONE, SO IN TERMS OF PEOPLE-- DOMINICANS RECOGNIZING THEMSELVES AS A PEOPLE, YOU COULD SAY, YES, THIS IS A PERIOD WHEN THAT COULD BE SEEN AS EMERGING DISTINCTLY.
15:4515 minutes, 45 secondsTHEY SAID, "WE'RE NOT LIKE THEM. WE'RE A DIFFERENT PEOPLE." THAT'S RIGHT.
15:4815 minutes, 48 secondsGates, voice-over: ONCE THEY FREED THEMSELVES FROM THE HAITIANS, MANY DOMINICANS DID THEIR BEST TO REJECT JUST ABOUT EVERYTHING ABOUT THEM-- THEIR LANGUAGE, THEIR CULTURE, AND TO SOME EXTENT THEIR COLOR.
15:5915 minutes, 59 secondsGates: SO THIS IS GEORGE WASHINGTON, JOHN ADAMS, AND ALEXANDER HAMILTON?
16:0416 minutes, 4 secondsTHAT'S CORRECT. IN THE CENTER YOU HAVE JUAN PABLO DUARTE, WHO IS THE INTELLECTUAL ARCHITECT, IF YOU WILL, OF DOMINICAN NATIONHOOD. SO HE'S THE THEORIST.
16:1216 minutes, 12 secondsHE'S THE THEORIST. OK. SO WERE THEY ALL WHITE GUYS? UH, HE IS A MULATTO. AH. HE DOESN'T LOOK VERY MULATTO IN THAT STATUE.
16:2116 minutes, 21 secondsNO, HE DOESN'T, AND THAT REFLECTS A TENDENCY IN THE IMAGINARY OF THE DOMINICAN RULING ELITES,
16:3016 minutes, 30 secondsWHO HAVE THIS TENDENCY TO WANT TO WHITEIFY THEIR HEROES IF THEIR HEROES ARE TOO BLACK. SO THEY WHITENED THE BROTHER. YES.
16:3816 minutes, 38 secondsNOT ONLY DID THEY PUT HIM IN MARBLE, BUT THEY CHANGED HIS FEATURES.
16:4116 minutes, 41 secondsTHAT IS CORRECT, AND THAT ACTUALLY IS A WAY OF POINTING TO THE COMPLEXITY OF RACE RELATIONS AND THE RACIAL EXPERIENCE OF DOMINICANS.
17:0217 minutes, 2 secondsGates: IN THE EARLY 20th CENTURY, THE HAITIANS CAME BACK, NOT AS SOLDIERS THIS TIME BUT AS DESPERATE MIGRANT WORKERS.
17:1417 minutes, 14 secondsMOST OF THEM CAME DURING THE UNITED STATES' OCCUPATION, WHICH BEGAN IN 1916, PART OF WOODROW WILSON'S POLICY OF EXTENDING AMERICA'S INFLUENCE IN ITS SO-CALLED BACKYARD.
17:3217 minutes, 32 secondsTHE AMERICANS APPROPRIATED LARGE TRACTS OF LAND TO EXPAND THE PROFITABLE SUGAR INDUSTRY.
17:4717 minutes, 47 secondsBUT THE WAGES WERE SO LOW THAT FEW DOMINICANS WOULD DO THE WORK, SO THEY IMPORTED TENS OF THOUSANDS OF HAITIANS.
17:5817 minutes, 58 secondsSaillant: PLANTATIONS DEHUMANIZED HAITIAN WORKERS. THEY WERE REDUCED TO A CONDITION OF TOTAL DESTITUTION.
18:0918 minutes, 9 secondsIT IS THERE THAT DOMINICANS LEARNED TO SEE THEMSELVES AS SUPERIOR TO HAITIANS.
18:1818 minutes, 18 secondsIN OTHER WORDS, THE HAITIANS BECAME THE MIGRANT WORKERS, DOING JOBS THAT NO SELF-RESPECTING DOMINICAN WOULD DO.
18:2618 minutes, 26 secondsTHAT IS CORRECT. THEY BECAME A NEW CLASS. THEY BECAME A NEW CLASS.
18:3118 minutes, 31 secondsBECAUSE THEY WERE SO HOMOGENEOUS-- BECAUSE THEY WERE SO HOMOGENEOUS IN TERMS OF THEIR HUE, IN TERMS OF THEIR PHENOTYPE,
18:4018 minutes, 40 secondsTHEIR BLACKNESS BECAME A TYPE OF BLACKNESS WHICH WAS DIFFERENT FROM THAT OF DOMINICANS.
18:4718 minutes, 47 secondsSO ALL OF A SUDDEN, THE PRIMARY OPPOSITION BECAME BETWEEN US AND THE HAITIANS. THAT IS TRUE. THAT IS TRUE. SO THE HAITIANS THEN BECOME A FACTOR OF DOMINICAN IDENTITY.
18:5818 minutes, 58 seconds[INDISTINCT CHATTER]
19:0019 minutesGates: BLACKNESS BECAME A HAITIAN TRAIT AND A NEGATIVE TERM TO MANY DOMINICANS.
19:1519 minutes, 15 secondsSOME DOMINICANS STEREOTYPE HAITIANS IN THE SAME WAY THAT WHITE PEOPLE ONCE STEREOTYPED AFRICAN-AMERICANS.
19:2719 minutes, 27 secondsRACISM AND ANTI-HAITIAN FEELINGS REINFORCE EACH OTHER AS IF HAITIANS ARE A COMPLETELY DIFFERENT AND INFERIOR RACE.
19:4219 minutes, 42 secondsTHESE BELIEFS WERE TAUGHT IN SCHOOLS AND REPEATED THROUGH STATE PROPAGANDA UNTIL THE LATE SIXTIES.
19:5119 minutes, 51 secondsONE MAN DID MORE THAN ANYONE ELSE TO ENCOURAGE THESE ATTITUDES, THE COUNTRY'S PRESIDENT BETWEEN 1930 AND 1961 GENERAL RAFAEL LEONIDAS TRUJILLO.
20:0720 minutes, 7 secondsA CRUEL AND CORRUPT DICTATOR, TRUJILLO'S POWER OVER HIS PEOPLE WAS ABSOLUTE.
20:1320 minutes, 13 secondsSANTO DOMINGO'S NATIONAL MUSEUM OF HISTORY AND GEOGRAPHY HOLDS HIS PERSONAL EFFECTS.
20:2020 minutes, 20 secondsWOW! LOOK AT THAT. THIS WAS HIS UNIFORM?
20:2320 minutes, 23 seconds[SPEAKING SPANISH]
20:2520 minutes, 25 secondsYES. THIS WAS HIS FORMAL UNIFORM.
20:2920 minutes, 29 secondsSOME OF THE THINGS WORTH POINTING OUT ARE THE GOLD BRAIDS AND THE EPAULETS, ALSO THE BELT WHERE THE SWORD WOULD HANG, WHICH WAS A SPECIAL AND LUXURIOUS SWORD.
20:4020 minutes, 40 secondsHMM.
20:4220 minutes, 42 secondsTHESE SUITS WERE MADE IN FRANCE THEY HAVE A VERY FRENCH STYLE.
20:5020 minutes, 50 secondsGates: TRUJILLO USED ANTI-HAITIAN RACISM TO HELP TO FORGE A STRONG STATE AFTER YEARS OF POLITICAL CHAOS.
20:5820 minutes, 58 secondsHE DID EVERYTHING HE POSSIBLY COULD TO CLAIM THAT THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC WAS ACTUALLY A WHITE NATION, DESPITE THE FACT THAT EVEN HE HAD HAITIAN ANCESTRY.
21:2521 minutes, 25 secondsALL WHITE. NOT EVEN MULATTO. NO. NO. BLANCO. AH. YEAH. JESUS. LOOK AT THAT.
21:3421 minutes, 34 secondsYOU WOULD THINK IT WAS EUROPE. YEAH. ON HIS I.D.? HE'S WHITE.
21:4321 minutes, 43 secondsBUT HE WAS A MULATTO. YEAH. LIKE ME. LIKE YOU. UH-HUH.
21:5621 minutes, 56 secondsHE HAS MAKE-UP? HE WOULD POWDER HIS FACE, LIGHTEN? AH.
22:0422 minutes, 4 secondsYES. WHITE POWDER. AH. LIKE DO YOU USE? MY GOODNESS. I'LL BE DAMNED! LOOK AT THAT.
22:1322 minutes, 13 secondsYEAH. THE RECEPTIONS...
22:2322 minutes, 23 secondsGates: TRUJILLO'S ANTI-HAITIANISM REACHED ITS APEX HERE ON THE MASSACRE RIVER, WHICH DIVIDES THE TWO COUNTRIES.
22:3422 minutes, 34 secondsTRUJILLO TURNED ON THE HAITIAN MIGRANTS, CLAIMING THEY WERE ENCROACHING ON THE SO-CALLED PURITY OF THE DOMINICAN MOTHERLAND.
22:4222 minutes, 42 secondsHIS VICTIMS INCLUDED HAITIAN IMMIGRANTS, DOMINICANS OF HAITIAN DESCENT, AND DOMINICAN-HAITIAN FAMILIES.
22:5222 minutes, 52 secondsIN OCTOBER 1937, TRUJILLO ISSUED AN ORDER FOR HIS TROOPS TO KILL ALL THE HAITIANS IN THE NORTHWEST PART OF THE COUNTRY.
23:0123 minutes, 1 secondWHEN HIS TROOPS ARRIVED, THEY CLOSED THE BORDER.
23:0423 minutes, 4 secondsEVEN AS THE HAITIANS FLED ACROSS THE APTLY NAMED MASSACRE RIVER, THE TROOPS BRUTALLY SLAUGHTERED THEM.
23:1223 minutes, 12 secondsIN THE END, APPROXIMATELY 15,000 HAITIANS LAY DEAD.
23:2023 minutes, 20 secondsTRUJILLO NEVER SUCCEEDED IN ENTIRELY ELIMINATING THE HAITIANS.
23:2523 minutes, 25 secondsTODAY THERE ARE MORE THAN A MILLION HAITIANS LIVING AND WORKING HERE, A SOURCE OF CONTINUING TENSION.
23:3223 minutes, 32 secondsAND LIKE MIGRANTS EVERYWHERE, THE HAITIANS HAVE COME HERE PURSUING THE DREAM OF A BETTER LIFE.
23:4323 minutes, 43 secondsTO A LARGE EXTENT, DOMINICANS' IDEAS ABOUT RACE HAVE BEEN FORMED FROM THEIR NEGATIVE VIEWS ABOUT HAITIANS.
23:5323 minutes, 53 secondsI WANT TO SEE WHAT HAITI IS LIKE FOR MYSELF, SO I'M HEADING FOR THE WESTERN TIP OF HISPANIOLA, TO HAITI'S CAPITAL PORT-AU-PRINCE.
24:1824 minutes, 18 secondsNOTHING, BUT NOTHING, PREPARES YOU FOR THE DEVASTATION IN PORT-AU-PRINCE.
24:3124 minutes, 31 secondsTHE EARTHQUAKE THAT KILLED OVER 220,000 PEOPLE HAS LEFT 1.5 MILLION PEOPLE HOMELESS.
24:4124 minutes, 41 secondsENTIRE FAMILIES ARE LIVING IN TENTS WITH NO ELECTRICITY, NO RUNNING WATER, AND NO SANITATION.
24:5724 minutes, 57 secondsLONG BEFORE THE EARTHQUAKE, HAITI WAS THE POOREST COUNTRY IN THE WESTERN HEMISPHERE...
25:0725 minutes, 7 secondsBUT EVEN WITHIN THIS DEVASTATION, I CAN ALSO SEE THE COURAGE AND RESILIENCE OF THE HAITIAN PEOPLE DESPERATELY ATTEMPTING TO REBUILD THEIR LIVES.
25:1725 minutes, 17 secondsIT'S RESILIENCE BORN FROM AN EXTRAORDINARILY RICH AND NOBLE HISTORY. HAITI WAS ONCE A COLONY OF FRANCE.
25:2725 minutes, 27 secondsRISING FROM THE EARTHQUAKE'S RUBBLE, ONE CAN STILL SEE THE MONUMENTS CELEBRATING HAITI'S FOUNDING FATHERS AND NATIONAL HEROES,
25:3625 minutes, 36 secondsBUT THESE AREN'T THE EUROPEAN COLONIZERS I SAW IN THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC.
25:4025 minutes, 40 secondsRATHER, THEY'RE BLACK MEN-- THE MEN WHO MADE HAITI THE FIRST INDEPENDENT BLACK NATION IN THE NEW WORLD,
25:4925 minutes, 49 secondsTHE FIRST BLACK MEN IN HISTORY TO DEFEAT THEIR COLONIAL MASTERS IN WAR.
25:5825 minutes, 58 secondsWE'RE ALL VERY FAMILIAR WITH THE POPULAR IMAGES OF HAITI THAT WE SEE ON TELEVISION-- POVERTY, FOOD RIOTS,
26:0626 minutes, 6 secondsMILITARY COUPS, TREMENDOUS INSTABILITY, AND, OF COURSE, THE DEVASTATING IMPACT OF THE EARTHQUAKE--
26:1426 minutes, 14 secondsBUT HOW MANY OF US KNOW ANYTHING AT ALL ABOUT HAITI'S NOBLE HERITAGE, THE FACT THAT IT WAS A CENTER FOR THE FIGHTING OF FREEDOM
26:2226 minutes, 22 secondsIN THE 18th CENTURY AND THE FACT THAT HAITI POSSESSES ONE OF THE GREATEST CULTURES IN THE ENTIRE NEW WORLD?
26:3026 minutes, 30 secondsTHAT'S WHAT I'M HERE TO FIND OUT ABOUT.
26:3626 minutes, 36 secondsAND DESPITE THE DEVASTATION, THAT CULTURE IS BEING MAINTAINED ALL OVER PORT-AU-PRINCE.
26:4826 minutes, 48 secondsAT THE PARTLY DESTROYED NATIONAL SCHOOL FOR THE ARTS, I COME ACROSS AN EXTRAORDINARY SIGHT--
26:5726 minutes, 57 secondsYOUNG PEOPLE STILL HUNGRY TO LEARN THE ARTS PRACTICED BY THEIR AFRICAN ANCESTORS.
27:0427 minutes, 4 seconds[MAN SPEAKING HAITIAN CREOLE]
27:1227 minutes, 12 secondsGates, voice-over: LOUIS LESLEY MARCELIN, KNOWN AS ZAO, IS THE SCHOOL'S HEAD OF PERCUSSION.
27:1827 minutes, 18 seconds[MARCELIN SPEAKING HAITIAN CREOLE]
27:2427 minutes, 24 secondsHAITI IS A COUNTRY OF IMITATION.
27:2727 minutes, 27 secondsSO MANY DIFFERENT ETHNICITIES HAVE COME FROM AFRICA, AND WE HAITIANS HAVE IMITATED THEM ALL, AND THAT IS WHY WE HAVE SO MANY MUSICAL STYLES.
27:3627 minutes, 36 secondsFOR EXAMPLE, WHEN YOU TAKE A SECT LIKE DAHOMEY, A NORTHERN HERITAGE, THAT IS DAHOMEY VODOU, WHICH COMES FROM BENIN.
27:4527 minutes, 45 secondsWHEN YOU TAKE NAGO-- WHICH WE INHERITED FROM THE NORTH, FROM GHANA EWE THAT COMES FROM NIGERIA.
27:5127 minutes, 51 secondsBECAUSE WE ARE DESCENDED FROM SO MANY PLACES IN AFRICA, EVERYTHING AFRICA HAD TO OFFER, WE INHERITED.
28:0028 minutesGates: CREOLE, THE LANGUAGE MOST HAITIAN PEOPLE SPEAK, IS PARTLY BASED ON 18th-CENTURY FRENCH, BUT IT HAS STRONG ELEMENTS FROM VARIOUS WEST AFRICAN LANGUAGES.
28:1028 minutes, 10 seconds[SINGING IN HAITIAN CREOLE]
28:4128 minutes, 41 secondsGates: TO BEGIN TO UNDERSTAND THE HISTORY OF HAITI, I'M LEAVING THE DEVASTATION OF PORT-AU-PRINCE AND TRAVELING TO THE NORTHERN SIDE OF THE ISLAND...
28:5328 minutes, 53 secondsTO CAP-HAITIEN, HAITI'S HISTORIC SECOND CITY.
29:0129 minutes, 1 secondCAP-FRANCAIS, AS IT WAS THEN KNOWN, WAS THE FIRST PERMANENT FRENCH SETTLEMENT ON HISPANIOLA.
29:1129 minutes, 11 secondsTHE FRENCH TOOK ADVANTAGE OF THE WEAKNESS OF THE SPANISH IN SANTO DOMINGO TO FOUND THEIR OWN COLONY IN THE WEST.
29:2229 minutes, 22 secondsWHEN THE ISLAND WAS FORMALLY DIVIDED IN 1697, CAP-HAITIEN BECAME THE COMMERCIAL HUB FOR THE FRENCH SIDE.
29:3229 minutes, 32 secondsIT BECAME THE MAIN PORT OF ENTRY FOR THE GROWING TRADE IN AFRICAN SLAVES.
29:4129 minutes, 41 secondsTHE NUMBER OF AFRICANS SHIPPED TO HAITI DURING THE SLAVE TRADE IS STAGGERING-- 774,000,
29:4929 minutes, 49 seconds300,000 MORE THAN CAME TO THE ENTIRE UNITED STATES DURING THE SLAVE TRADE.
29:5529 minutes, 55 secondsHAITI WAS THE RICHEST COLONY IN THE ENTIRE NEW WORLD. IT WAS THE JEWEL IN FRANCE'S CROWN...
30:0830 minutes, 8 secondsTHE REASON FOR THIS FABULOUS WEALTH--SUGAR.
30:1430 minutes, 14 secondsWALKING AROUND CAP-HAITIEN'S HISTORIC MARKET, IT'S DIFFICULT TO IMAGINE JUST HOW IMPORTANT HAITI WAS TO FRANCE.
30:2130 minutes, 21 secondsHAITI WAS KNOWN AS THE PEARL OF THE ANTILLES.
30:2730 minutes, 27 secondsBY THE MID 1700s, THIS COLONY, LITTLE BIGGER THAN MARYLAND, PRODUCED NEARLY HALF OF THE WORLD'S SUGAR AND GENERATED 2/5 OF FRANCE'S OVERSEAS TRADE.
30:4030 minutes, 40 secondsA BRUTALLY EFFICIENT PLANTATION ECONOMY LED TO A VERY DIFFERENT WAY OF LIFE HERE THAN ON THE SPANISH SIDE OF THE ISLAND.
30:5130 minutes, 51 secondsGUY ALEXANDRE, A SOCIOLOGIST, IS ALSO THE FORMER HAITIAN AMBASSADOR TO THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC. SO HE KNOWS BOTH COUNTRIES WELL.
31:0031 minutes[ALEXANDRE SPEAKING FRENCH]
31:0431 minutes, 4 secondsIN HAITI, THERE WAS A PLANTATION ECONOMY LINKED TO THE EXPLOITATION OF A LARGE NUMBER OF AFRICAN SLAVES...
31:1331 minutes, 13 secondsWHEREAS IN THE SPANISH PART, THE SLAVE RATE WAS INFINITELY LOWER, AND THE ECONOMY WAS BASED ON LIVESTOCK.
31:2431 minutes, 24 secondsTHIS MEANT THERE WERE MAJOR DIFFERENCES IN THE PROCESS OF POPULATION FORMATION, DIFFERENCES FROM THE OUTSET WITH A MUCH HIGHER RATE OF RACE MIXING IN THE EAST THAN WE HAD HERE.
31:3731 minutes, 37 secondsHOW DOES THIS DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE COUNTRIES AND THE PEOPLE EXPRESS ITSELF IN RELATIONSHIP, SAY,
31:4431 minutes, 44 secondsTO TRADITIONAL FORMS OF BLACK CULTURE, LET'S SAY TO AFRICA?
31:5031 minutes, 50 secondsTHE DOMINICAN ELITE SIMPLY REJECTED, ALMOST COMPLETELY, THE AFRICAN COMPONENT OF THEIR CULTURE.
31:5831 minutes, 58 secondsTHE HAITIANS AND, SPECIFICALLY, THE HAITIAN ELITE ACCEPTED THEIR AFRICAN ORIGINS TO THE POINT WHERE OUR AFRICAN ORIGINS ARE PART OF THE NATIONAL CULTURE.
32:1232 minutes, 12 seconds[CHORUS SINGING]
32:2232 minutes, 22 secondsGates: I'VE COME TO THE VILLAGE OF TROU-DU-NORD, JUST OUTSIDE CAP-HAITIEN, FOR THE YEARLY CELEBRATION OF THE TOWN'S PATRON SAINT-- SAINT JAMES.
32:3432 minutes, 34 secondsMOST HAITIANS OFFICIALLY ARE ROMAN CATHOLICS, BUT THAT'S NOT ALL THEY ARE.
32:4032 minutes, 40 secondsJUST OUTSIDE THE CHURCH UNDER THE TOWN BRIDGE, PEOPLE PRACTICE A RELIGION MANY HAITIANS COMBINE WITH THEIR CATHOLICISM--
32:5032 minutes, 50 secondsTHE AFRICAN-BASED FAITH VODOU.
32:5432 minutes, 54 seconds[DRUMS AND SINGING]
32:5932 minutes, 59 secondsHOLLYWOOD MOVIES WITH RACIST IMAGES OF SO-CALLED VOODOO DOLLS, ZOMBIES, BLACK MAGIC, AND DEVIL WORSHIP HAVE DEMONIZED VODOU...
33:1133 minutes, 11 secondsBUT VODOU IS A COMPLEX BELIEF SYSTEM, A RELIGION AS SOPHISTICATED AS ANY OTHER RELIGION.
33:2133 minutes, 21 secondsGates: IN MANY OF THE NEW WORLD BLACK SOCIETIES, IT'S NOT RESPECTABLE TO ADMIT THAT YOU PRACTICE VODOU, BUT HERE, PEOPLE ARE VERY PROUD, THEY SEEM TO BE.
33:3333 minutes, 33 secondsOF COURSE WE ARE VERY PROUD. WHY? IN FACT, WE CANNOT EVEN SEE OURSELF DIFFERENTLY. IN FACT, THAT'S THE ONLY WAY WE SEE OURSELVES.
33:4033 minutes, 40 secondsIN FACT, I MUST SAY THAT WHAT CHARACTERIZED THE HAITIAN NATION AS A NATION IS THE PRIDE THEY HAVE FOR THEIR FOREFATHERS AND FOR THEIR HERITAGE.
33:4933 minutes, 49 secondsWHEN OTHER PEOPLE SAY, "COME ON. YOU'RE POOR," WE KNOW WE ARE RICH IN OUR OWN WAYS. WE ARE RICH SPIRITUALLY.
33:5533 minutes, 55 seconds[DRUMS AND SINGING]
33:5933 minutes, 59 secondsGates, voice-over: MAX BEAUVOIR IS A BIOCHEMIST TRAINED AT CITY COLLEGE IN NEW YORK CITY AND THE SORBONNE IN PARIS.
34:0734 minutes, 7 secondsFOR THE PAST 30 YEARS, HE'S BEEN THE HOUNGAN, THE HIGH PRIEST, OF ONE OF HAITI'S MOST IMPORTANT HOUNFOURS, OR VODOU TEMPLES.
34:1834 minutes, 18 secondsMAX BELIEVES THAT VODOU'S EMBRACE OF NATURE PLACES IT AT THE CORE OF HAITIAN IDENTITY.
34:2534 minutes, 25 secondsBeauvoir: I WOULD SAY IT'S THE AIM, THE AIM OF VODOU.
34:2934 minutes, 29 secondsWHEN VODOU WAS CONSTRUCTED ITSELF, THE POINT WAS TO INCLUDE INTO IT EACH GROUP.
34:3634 minutes, 36 secondsGates: EACH AFRICAN-- SO, IN FACT, SENEGAL WAS PART OF IT. MALI WAS PART OF IT. DAHOMEY WAS PART OF IT. THE UPPER NIGERIA WAS PART OF IT.
34:4434 minutes, 44 secondsSOUTHERN NIGERIA WITH THE IGBOS WAS A PART OF IT.
34:4734 minutes, 47 secondsONCE YOU HAVE THE NORTHERN CONGOS WITH CAMEROON AND GABON, THEY WERE ALSO PART OF IT. SO, IN FACT, I THINK THAT WAS THE BASIC STRENGTH OF VODOU.
34:5734 minutes, 57 secondsIT WAS INCLUSIVE, EMBRACING. INCLUSIVE.
35:0135 minutes, 1 second[HOG SQUEALING]
35:0535 minutes, 5 secondsGates, voice-over: LIKE OTHER OPPRESSED PEOPLE, THE SLAVES DREW SOLACE AND COMFORT FROM THEIR RELIGION.
35:1235 minutes, 12 secondsVODOU ALSO GAVE THEM STRENGTH, COURAGE, ORGANIZATION, AND LEADERSHIP,
35:2035 minutes, 20 secondsQUALITIES THAT HELPED THE HAITIAN PEOPLE REALIZE THEIR GREATEST ACHIEVEMENT-- THE DEFEAT OF THEIR COLONIAL MASTERS THE FRENCH.
35:3135 minutes, 31 secondsIN THE COUNTRYSIDE JUST OUTSIDE CAP-HAITIEN SITS BOIS CAYMAN, THE FOREST OF THE ALLIGATORS.
35:3935 minutes, 39 secondsTODAY IT'S JUST A MODEST VILLAGE.
35:4235 minutes, 42 secondsTHERE'S NOTHING THERE TO COMMEMORATE THE MOMENTOUS EVENTS THAT TOOK PLACE MORE THAN 200 YEARS AGO, NOT EVEN A PLAQUE.
35:5135 minutes, 51 secondsTHIS IS WHERE THE HAITIAN REVOLUTION WAS CONCEIVED, A REVOLUTION THAT WOULD RESULT IN THE CREATION OF THE FIRST FREE BLACK REPUBLIC ON EARTH...
36:0236 minutes, 2 secondsAND IT ALL BEGAN WITH A VODOU RELIGIOUS CEREMONY HELD ON THIS VERY SPOT.
36:1136 minutes, 11 secondsANTHROPOLOGIST RACHEL BEAUVOIR, WHO IS MAX BEAUVOIR'S DAUGHTER, HAS RESEARCHED THE EVENTS OF THAT NIGHT USING ORAL ACCOUNTS PASSED DOWN FOR GENERATIONS.
36:2236 minutes, 22 secondsGates: RACHEL, AUGUST 14, 1791. IT'S MIDNIGHT. TELL ME WHAT HAPPENED HERE UNDER THIS TREE.
36:3036 minutes, 30 secondsTHUNDER, LIGHTNING. THE WHOLE PLACE IS TREMBLING.
36:3536 minutes, 35 secondsTHE EARTH SEEMS TO SHAKE, AND THAT'S WHEN THEY GET TOGETHER IN THIS VODOU CEREMONY, AND EVERYONE TOGETHER
36:4236 minutes, 42 secondsSAYS, "IT'S OVER. SLAVERY IS OVER." THEY DID A SACRIFICE OF AN ANIMAL, WHICH WAS A BLACK PIG, AND THIS SACRIFICE,
36:5136 minutes, 51 secondsEVERYONE TOUCHED THE BLOOD, AND THIS WAS THE SACRED OATH THAT, ABOVE EVERYTHING, LIBERTY WAS MOST IMPORTANT.
36:5836 minutes, 58 seconds[DRUMS AND SINGING]
37:0637 minutes, 6 secondsGates, voice-over: THE HAITIAN SLAVES CONFRONTED ONE OF THE MOST POWERFUL NATIONS ON EARTH.
37:1337 minutes, 13 secondsFOR BLACK SLAVES TO HAVE THE WHEREWITHAL TO OVERTHROW THEIR WHITE COLONIAL MASTERS WAS UNTHINKABLE.
37:2137 minutes, 21 secondsTHE PRINCIPLES OF THE FRENCH AND AMERICAN REVOLUTIONS INSPIRED MANY OF THE LEADERS.
37:2637 minutes, 26 secondsMANY OF THE SLAVES DREW THEIR STRENGTH FROM THE PRIDE IN THEIR AFRICAN PAST EXPRESSED IN THE BELIEF IN THE POWER OF VODOU.
37:4437 minutes, 44 secondsGates: WHAT WAS THE ROLE OF VODOU IN THE REVOLUTION?
37:4637 minutes, 46 secondsRachel: VODOU REPRESENTED THE CEMENT THAT GOT ALL OF THOSE SLAVES COMING FROM SO MANY DIFFERENT AREAS,
37:5337 minutes, 53 secondsTHE CONTINENT OF AFRICA-- HAITI IS LIKE A MICROCOSM OF AFRICA... AND THE GLUE WAS VODOU.
37:5937 minutes, 59 secondsAND THE GLUE WAS VODOU, MAKING SENSE OF IT ALL AND MAKING EVERYONE MAKE SENSE OF EVERY OTHER ONE, AND THEN THEY HAD THE UNITY NECESSARY TO HAVE THE MOST POWERFUL SLAVE REVOLUTION IN THE WHOLE WORLD.
38:1438 minutes, 14 secondsGates, voice-over: THE BOIS CAYMAN UPRISING MARKED THE BEGINNING OF THE GREATEST SLAVE REVOLT IN THE HISTORY OF THE NEW WORLD.
38:2338 minutes, 23 secondsIT TOOK THE SLAVES JUST TWO YEARS TO WIN THEIR FREEDOM, FORCING THE FRENCH TO ABOLISH SLAVERY.
38:3238 minutes, 32 secondsHAITI WAS RUN BY THE GREAT GENERAL TOUSSAINT LOUVERTURE, STILL AS A FRENCH COLONY BUT FREE OF SLAVERY...
38:4238 minutes, 42 secondsBUT IN 1802, THE FRENCH, UNDER NAPOLEON BONAPARTE, REVERSED THE EMANCIPATION OF THE SLAVES.
38:5038 minutes, 50 secondsTOUSSAINT WAS TRICKED AND ARRESTED AND THEN SENT TO A FRENCH PRISON, WHERE HE DIED IN EXILE.
38:5938 minutes, 59 secondsTHE HAITIANS ROSE UP AGAINST THE FRENCH ONCE AGAIN TO STOP THE REIMPOSITION OF SLAVERY.
39:0639 minutes, 6 secondsAT VERTIERES, JUST OUTSIDE CAP-HAITIEN, THE HAITIAN FORCES, UNDER JEAN JACQUES DESSALINES, TOUSSAINT'S SUCCESSOR, ROUTED THE FRENCH ARMY FOR THE LAST TIME.
39:1939 minutes, 19 secondsTHIS BRILLIANT GENERAL, A FORMER SLAVE HIMSELF, WAS DETERMINED THAT SLAVERY WOULD NEVER RETURN TO HAITI.
39:2939 minutes, 29 secondsWHEN HE DECLARED INDEPENDENCE ON JANUARY 1, 1804, HIS STIRRING WORDS LEFT NOTHING TO CHANCE.
39:3739 minutes, 37 seconds"LET THEM TREMBLE WHEN THEY APPROACH OUR COASTS.
39:4039 minutes, 40 seconds"IF NOT FOR THE MEMORY OF THOSE CRUELTIES THEY PERPETRATED HERE, "THEN FROM THE TERRIBLE RESOLUTION THAT WE WILL HAVE MADE
39:4939 minutes, 49 seconds"TO PUT TO DEATH ANYONE BORN FRENCH WHOSE PROFANE FOOT SOILS THE LAND OF LIBERTY."
39:5739 minutes, 57 secondsJEAN-JACQUES DESSALINES, DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE OF HAITI, 1804.
40:0540 minutes, 5 secondsTHESE WORDS ARE STARTLING TO US TODAY, EVEN SOMEWHAT FRIGHTENING, BUT THEY'RE CERTAINLY UNDERSTANDABLE.
40:1040 minutes, 10 secondsDESSALINES FELT THAT THE FRENCH, GIVEN ANY OPPORTUNITY, WOULD REIMPOSE SLAVERY ON THIS ISLAND.
40:1740 minutes, 17 secondsAND YOU KNOW WHAT, DESSALINES WAS ABSOLUTELY RIGHT.
40:2040 minutes, 20 secondsAND HE THOUGHT, PERHAPS MISTAKENLY, THAT UNLESS HE WIPED THEM OUT, SLAVERY WOULD RETURN.
40:2640 minutes, 26 secondsSO SHORTLY AFTER READING THIS STATEMENT, DESSALINES ORDERED THE MASSACRE OF THE FRENCH PEOPLE ON THIS ISLAND,
40:3340 minutes, 33 secondsAN ACT THAT SHOCKED NOT ONLY THE NATIONS OF EUROPE AND THE UNITED STATES, OF COURSE, BUT EVEN MANY OF HIS PEERS.
40:4240 minutes, 42 secondsTWO YEARS LATER, DESSALINES HIMSELF WOULD BE ASSASSINATED BY THE VERY GENERALS WITH WHOM HE DEFEATED THE FRENCH.
40:5640 minutes, 56 secondsBUT FOR THE HAITIAN PEOPLE, THE FIGHT TO RETAIN THEIR INDEPENDENCE HAD ONLY JUST BEGUN.
41:0341 minutes, 3 secondsNO SOONER HAD THEY WON THEIR FREEDOM FROM FRANCE, THAN THEIR ENEMIES BEGAN A CAMPAIGN TO STRANGLE THE NEW REPUBLIC IN ITS CRIB.
41:2241 minutes, 22 secondsSANS-SOUCI, A REMARKABLE FAIRY-TALE PALACE IN THE COUNTRYSIDE JUST OUTSIDE CAP HAITIEN, WAS BUILT BY DESSALINES' SUCCESSOR, KING HENRI CHRISTOPHE.
41:3341 minutes, 33 secondsA BRILLIANT SOLDIER, CHRISTOPHE HAD FOUGHT IN THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION AND HAD BEEN DESSALINES' RIGHT-HAND MAN IN THE WAR AGAINST THE FRENCH.
41:4441 minutes, 44 secondsHAITI'S CONTINUED SURVIVAL NOW RESTED SQUARELY ON HIS SHOULDERS.
41:5241 minutes, 52 secondsFRANCE, BRITAIN, AND AMERICA, ALL REFUSED TO RECOGNIZE HAITI.
41:5841 minutes, 58 secondsTHEY COULD NEVER ALLOW IT TO BECOME AN EXAMPLE TO OTHER ENSLAVED PEOPLE IN THE REST OF THE AMERICAS.
42:0642 minutes, 6 secondsFEARFUL OF INVASION, CHRISTOPHE CONSTRUCTED A GREAT FORTRESS KNOWN AS THE CITADEL.
42:1442 minutes, 14 secondsBUILT ATOP A 3,000 FEET PEAK, IT TOOK 20,000 MEN TO CONSTRUCT.
42:2242 minutes, 22 secondsIT'S STILL THE LARGEST FORTRESS IN THE ENTIRE WESTERN HEMISPHERE.
42:3242 minutes, 32 secondsPATRICK DELATOUR IS AN ARCHITECT WHO IS IN CHARGE OF THE CITADEL'S RESTORATION. OH! HMM.
42:4042 minutes, 40 secondsPATRICK, WHAT WAS CHRISTOPHE AFRAID OF? THE RETURN OF THE FRENCH. THE RETURN OF THE FRENCH AND GOING BACK INTO SLAVERY.
42:5042 minutes, 50 secondsAND AS SOON AS FRANCE WOULD BE AT PEACE WITH ENGLAND, AND BE AT PEACE WITH THE REST OF THE EUROPEAN POWERS, FRANCE COULD THINK OF ONE THING: TO COME BACK.
43:0143 minutes, 1 secondBECAUSE EVERYBODY WANTED HAITI TO BE CRUSHED BECAUSE IT WAS BLACK MEN WHO HAD FREED THEMSELVES FROM THE SHACKLES OF SLAVERY.
43:0843 minutes, 8 secondsYES. THE PAIN OF SLAVERY IS SUCH THAT WHENEVER YOU'RE MAKING AN ANALYSIS OF HAITI OR THE HAITIAN, IT IS THERE THAT YOU HAVE TO GO BACK TO.
43:1843 minutes, 18 secondsMM-HMM.
43:2043 minutes, 20 secondsI BELIEVE THAT THE QUEST FOR EQUALITY AND THE QUEST FOR FREEDOM WAS SO GREAT THAT THOSE GUYS, IN FACT, WROTE IT DOWN
43:2943 minutes, 29 secondsAND SAID THAT THEY WOULD RATHER DIE THAN GO BACK TO SLAVERY.
43:3343 minutes, 33 secondsGates, voice-over: WITH THE FRENCH EXPELLED, THE HAITIAN PEOPLE REJECTED EVERYTHING THAT REMINDED THEM OF SLAVERY.
43:4043 minutes, 40 secondsGates: HAITI WAS THE MOST PROFITABLE COLONY IN THE HISTORY OF COLONIZATION.
43:4643 minutes, 46 secondsSO IF THEY COULD HAVE MAINTAINED THE PLANTATION SYSTEM, HAITI WOULD HAVE BEEN RICH. IT WOULD HAVE BEEN ONE OF THE WORLD'S RICHEST ECONOMIES.
43:5243 minutes, 52 secondsTHEY SYSTEMATICALLY DESTROYED ALL THE MEANS OF PRODUCTION. ANYTHING THAT HAD TO DO WITH SLAVERY WAS DESTROYED.
44:0244 minutes, 2 secondsAND WE DESTROYED THE WHOLE DRAINAGE SYSTEM, THE ROAD SYSTEM, THE INVESTMENT INTO THE MACHINERY FOR SUGAR AND THE GOOD WHEAT, AND ... COFFEE.
44:1544 minutes, 15 secondsSO BASICALLY, IT WAS SOLELY THE NOTION OF INDIVIDUAL SURVIVAL, FAMILY SURVIVAL.
44:3444 minutes, 34 secondsTHEN YOU HAVE THE PLATFORM. MY GOD, LOOK AT THIS. THAT'S IT. WHEW! FROM HERE, YOU HAVE HISTORY AT YOUR FEET.
44:4344 minutes, 43 secondsYEAH!
44:4444 minutes, 44 secondsYOU CAN SEE ON ONE SIDE THE BED LACUNE, THE ARRIVAL OF CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS. THAT'S WHERE COLUMBUS ARRIVED? COLUMBUS. TAKE A LOOK.
44:5244 minutes, 52 secondsON TOP OF THE MOUNTAIN RIGHT THERE THERE'S ANOTHER FORT. NEXT TO IT, THERE'S ANOTHER FORT. YEAH, I SEE. YES.
45:0045 minutesSO THAT ONE COULD SUSTAIN A GUERRILLA WAR AGAINST ANY INVADING FORCE. IT'S TAKING MY BREATH AWAY. YES.
45:0845 minutes, 8 secondsI HAD NO IDEA THAT IT WOULD BE THIS AWE-INSPIRING.
45:1245 minutes, 12 secondsGates, voice-over: NO FOREIGN TROOPS WOULD EVER TEST THE STRENGTH OF THE WALLS OF THE CITADEL, BUT THEY DIDN'T NEED TO.
45:1845 minutes, 18 secondsHAITI'S ENEMIES USED OTHER MEANS TO CRIPPLE THE WORLD'S FIRST BLACK REPUBLIC.
45:2645 minutes, 26 secondsACTUALLY, THE INVASION DID COME, BUT NOT IN THE FORM THAT CHRISTOPHE THOUGHT.
45:3045 minutes, 30 secondsIT CAME IN THE FORM OF TRADE EMBARGOS, OF BLOCKADES, AND THE SYSTEMATIC DENIGRATION OF THE HAITIAN PEOPLE, THE DENIAL OF THE RIGHT OF BLACK PEOPLE TO GOVERN THEMSELVES.
45:4245 minutes, 42 secondsAND NO ONE PURSUED THAT POLICY WITH MORE VIGOR AND PASSION THAN OUR OWN PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES THOMAS JEFFERSON.
45:5245 minutes, 52 secondsGates, voice-over: THOMAS JEFFERSON CALLED TOUSSAINT AND THE HAITIAN FREEDOM FIGHTERS "CANNIBALS OF THE TERRIBLE REPUBLIC." THE FRENCH, TOO, DID EVERYTHING THEY COULD TO CRIPPLE HAITI.
46:0346 minutes, 3 secondsOUTRAGEOUSLY, FRANCE DEMANDED REPARATIONS FOR ITS LOSSES AS THE PRICE FOR OFFICIAL RECOGNITION OF THE NEW COUNTRY, THREATENING A BLOCKADE IF THE HAITIANS REFUSED.
46:1546 minutes, 15 secondsHAITI HAD LITTLE CHOICE.
46:1746 minutes, 17 secondsINCREDIBLY, IT PAID FRANCE MORE THAN $1 BILLION BETWEEN 1825 AND 1947, EFFECTIVELY BANKRUPTING ITS TREASURY.
46:2946 minutes, 29 secondsONE FORM OF SLAVERY REPLACED ANOTHER.
46:3846 minutes, 38 secondsFOREIGN INTERVENTION IN HAITI'S AFFAIRS WOULD BECOME EVEN MORE BLATANT.
46:4546 minutes, 45 secondsON JULY 28, 1915, THE UNITED STATES MARINES LANDED IN PORT-AU-PRINCE, JUST AS THEY WOULD DO IN THE DOMINICAN REPUBLIC A YEAR LATER.
46:5646 minutes, 56 secondsTHEIR DECLARED AIM WAS TO PROTECT AMERICAN AND FOREIGN INTERESTS-- IN OTHER WORDS, TO ENSURE THAT HAITI PAID ITS DEBT TO AMERICA AND FRANCE.
47:0847 minutes, 8 secondsFOR 19 YEARS, THE UNITED STATES WIELDED AN ABSOLUTE VETO OVER ALL GOVERNMENT DECISIONS, WHILE THE PROVINCES CAME UNDER THE RULE OF MARINE COMMANDERS.
47:3147 minutes, 31 secondsAND GUESS WHO THE AMERICAN GOVERNMENT PICKED TO DO THE OCCUPYING? SOME OF THE MOST RACIST SOUTHERNERS IT COULD FIND IN THE ENTIRE MARINE CORPS.
47:4147 minutes, 41 secondsWHAT WAS THE RESULT OF OUR ILLEGAL OCCUPATION FOR 19 YEARS OF THIS COUNTRY?
47:4747 minutes, 47 secondsOUR PRESENCE CREATED POLITICAL, ECONOMIC, AND SOCIAL INSTABILITY THAT CONTIED TO PLAGUE HAITI FOR THE NEXT SEVERAL DECADES.
47:5747 minutes, 57 secondsIT WAS INEXCUSABLE. HAITIANS WERE NEVER REALLY GIVEN THE CHANCE TO DEVELOP AS AN INDEPENDENT NATION.
48:1548 minutes, 15 secondsBUT NOT ALL OF HAITI'S PROBLEMS CAN BE BLAMED ON FOREIGNERS. THE COUNTRY HAS ALSO SUFFERED FROM SEVERAL BRUTAL, CORRUPT, DESPODIC LEADERS.
48:2948 minutes, 29 secondsAND PERHAPS NONE EPITOMIZED THIS MORE THAN HAITIAN PRESIDENT FRANCOIS "PAPA DOC" DUVALIER.
48:3748 minutes, 37 secondsTO HAVE PEACE AND STABILITY, YOU SHOULD HAVE A STRONG MAN IN EVERY COUNTRY-- NOT A DICTATOR, BUT A STRONG MAN.
48:5148 minutes, 51 secondsDEMOCRACY IS A WORD-- IS ONLY A WORD, IS A [SPEAKING FRENCH], A CONCEPTION.
48:5948 minutes, 59 secondsWHAT YOU CALL DEMOCRACY IN YOUR OWN COUNTRY, ANOTHER COUNTRY CAN CALL THAT A DICTATORSHIP.
49:1049 minutes, 10 secondsGates, voice-over: PRESIDENT FROM 1957 UNTIL HIS DEATH IN 1971, DUVALIER WAS POSSIBLY HAITI'S MOST DESPODIC RULER.
49:2049 minutes, 20 secondsHE STOLE MILLIONS OF DOLLARS IN FOREIGN AID, WHILE HIS PRIVATE MILITIA, THE TONTON MACOUTES, OVERSAW A REIGN OF TERROR.
49:3049 minutes, 30 secondsTHE AMERICAN GOVERNMENT BACKED HIM, JUST AS IT HAD BACKED THE DOMINICAN DICTATOR GENERAL TRUJILLO, OSTENSIBLY, BECAUSE HE WAS A LOYAL ALLY AGAINST COMMUNISM.
49:4149 minutes, 41 secondsTHEY CONSIDER ME LIKE A BLACK SHEEP.
49:4449 minutes, 44 seconds[LAUGHTER]
49:5249 minutes, 52 secondsGates: BERNARD DIEDERICH WAS ASSOCIATED PRESS CORRESPONDENT IN HAITI FOR MUCH OF THE DUVALIER PERIOD, AND HE MADE HIS HOME HERE.
50:0450 minutes, 4 secondsBERNARD TOOK ME TO FORT DIMANCHE, DUVALIER'S INFAMOUSLY SADISTIC PRISON, FROM WHICH VIRTUALLY NO ONE EVER MANAGED TO ESCAPE.
50:1350 minutes, 13 secondsBERNARD, WHAT HAPPENED HERE? Bernard: WELL, IT WAS AN OLD ARMY HEADQUARTERS.
50:2050 minutes, 20 secondsAND IT WAS THE WORST PLACE TO BE UNDER DUVALIER. IT WAS HIS GULAG.
50:2550 minutes, 25 secondsHE JUST PUT HIS PEOPLE IN THERE, AND THEY DIED SLOWLY.
50:2850 minutes, 28 secondsTB WAS THE FIRST THING TO STRIKE THEM, AND THEN DYSENTERY. AND THEY GRADUALLY GOT WORSE AND WORSE AND DIED.
50:3550 minutes, 35 secondsAND SOME BASICALLY ROTTED TO DEATH HERE. WHAT WAS THE WORST THING ABOUT DUVALIER'S REIGN OF TERROR?
50:4450 minutes, 44 secondsWELL, HE ALLOWED THE COUNTRY'S ENTIRE TALENT TO LEAVE THE COUNTRY, AND THE COUNTRY HAS NEVER REALLY SURVIVED THIS,
50:5250 minutes, 52 secondsBECAUSE YOU--YOU LOST ALL THE BEST TEACHERS, ALL THE BEST WRITERS. HE HAD BROKEN THE SCHOOLS AND HE HAD KICKED THEM OUT.
51:0251 minutes, 2 seconds[CHILDREN SHOUTING]
51:1951 minutes, 19 secondsGates: TODAY IT'S HARD TO FIND MUCH HOPE IN THE TENT CITIES OF PORT-AU-PRINCE.
51:2351 minutes, 23 secondsHAITIANS ARE STILL WAITING FOR MOST OF THE $10 BILLION PLEDGED IN AID.
51:2851 minutes, 28 secondsBUT IN ONE SMALL WAY, THE EARTHQUAKE HAS OFFERED A FRESH BEGINNING.
51:3251 minutes, 32 secondsAFTER THE DISASTER STRUCK, IT WAS THE DOMINICANS WHO WERE THE FIRST ON THE SCENE, PROVIDING AID AND SUPPORT.
51:4451 minutes, 44 secondsTHE HAITIANS HAVE FACED GREATER ODDS IN THEIR HISTORY.
51:4851 minutes, 48 secondsTHE SAME RESILIENCE AND COURAGE WITH WHICH THEY DEFEATED THE FRENCH EMPIRE CAN BE SUMMONED TO REBUILD THEIR SOCIETY AND CONSTRUCT MORE PROSPEROUS LIVES.
52:0152 minutes, 1 secondAND PERHAPS NOW, AFTER ALL THESE YEARS, THE WORLD WILL WELCOME THIS GREAT BLACK REPUBLIC AS A FULL AND EQUAL PARTNER IN THE COMMUNITY OF NATIONS.
52:1152 minutes, 11 secondsIF NOT NOW, THEN WHEN?
52:1852 minutes, 18 secondsAnnouncer: HERE'S MORE FROM "BLACK IN LATIN AMERICA." Gates: ...IF YOU WERE SEARCHING TO CAPTURE THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE CULTURES ON HISPANIOLA?
52:2752 minutes, 27 secondsWELL, DEMOGRAPHICALLY SPEAKING, RACIALLY SPEAKING, A BLACK POPULATION AND A MULATTO POPULATION.
52:3252 minutes, 32 secondsCULTURALLY SPEAKING, A SPANISH-SPEAKING POPULATION, A CREOLE-SPEAKING POPULATION.
52:3952 minutes, 39 secondsIDEOLOGICALLY SPEAKING, A CATHOLIC POPULATION ON THIS SIDE, AND A VOODOO-PRACTICING POPULATION ON THE OTHER SIDE.

Sync to video time