서평을 다 썼기에 업로드 해봅니다.
Unbowed : A Memoir. by Wangari Maathai, New York: Alfred A. Knopf (314 pp.) $24.95 | 2006 ISBN 978-0307275202
Reviewed by Hyewon Hong, Ph.D. student, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Unbowed provides a vivid first-hand account of postcolonial Kenya, blending Wangari Maathai’s environmental advocacy with her broader struggle for human rights and democratic governance. In the post-independence era, Kenya aspired to progress and freedom but grappled with the lingering colonial legacies of the British Empire, including corruption, environmental degradation, and disregard for human rights. Maathai’s story reminded me of South Korean President Kim Dae-jung, as both endured political oppression by their respective governments and physical challenges resulting from detention and torture. However, Maathai’s story is particularly remarkable in how she became a unifying figure, addressing environmental, political, and social issues throughout Kenya’s post-independence history.
Written as an autobiography, this book appears designed to convey Maathai’s messages through the lens of her inspiring life, particularly following her receipt of the Nobel Peace Prize in 2004. Her story is especially relevant to our “20th Century African Intellectual History” course, as she contributes to postcolonial narratives not only in Kenya but across Africa and on the global stage. Maathai engaged directly with conversations around gender roles and expectations in Kenyan-African society—arguably in the form of a fight—by advocating for equal wages and benefits for female faculty members at the University of Nairobi in the 1960s and 1970s. Her ongoing efforts with the Green Belt Movement raised awareness about the importance of preserving forests and mountains, and encouraged action, no matter how small, from everyone. Therefore, it is fair to recognize that she has influenced not only African intellectual history but also the history of African activism, merging these two realms into a vibrant and practical force across the continent.
Maathai’s narrative also stands out as a powerful example of African women’s leadership, offering rare and authentic insights into the intersection of gender, politics, and environmentalism in Africa. One notable instance is when she reflects on the process of organizing the tree-planting movement. She considered several factors, such as the qualifications of the planters, whether specialized knowledge of flora was required, and whom to involve in the initiative. Despite being an elite woman with a higher education from the United States, Maathai chose to simplify the process by empowering rural women with basic tree-planting skills. This decision was remarkable, as rural women were often marginalized, considered illiterate, and largely disregarded in conventional societal roles. By trusting these women to lead local efforts, Maathai not only transformed environmental activism but also challenged gender norms and uplifted an overlooked segment of society.
In addition, Maathai’s holistic approach to activism is truly remarkable. While her initial motivation stemmed from witnessing environmental degradation, she saw her struggle for environmental protection as part of a broader movement for social justice, democracy, and human rights. Her personal experiences with government conflict and imprisonment deepened her empathy for marginalized groups, such as frustrated mothers fighting for their rights. Moreover, having lived through British colonialism in Kenya, she could relate to the struggles of Haitians facing environmental degradation and poverty amidst the challenges of nation-building and political instability. The book vividly illustrates her comprehensive approach, highlighting how interconnected environmental health, governance, and social equality are. This makes her work resonate not only with environmental activists but also with politicians and policymakers seeking holistic solutions to societal issues.
While this book is undoubtedly an inspiration for many readers, it also has some weaknesses. Throughout the memoir, Maathai, who was born and raised in rural Kenya, frequently contrasts the present state of Kenyan nature with its past, often reminiscing about the abundance, fertility, and verdant beauty she experienced in her childhood. She tends to romanticize the past—her upbringing and traditional wisdom—while portraying the developments and modernization efforts by the Kenyan government as predominantly negative. This dichotomy feels overly simplistic, as it overlooks the complexities and the potential grey areas that exist between tradition and progress. The challenges of modernization and environmental degradation are not always black and white, and a more nuanced exploration of these issues would have strengthened her argument.
Furthermore, while I fully support Maathai’s emphasis on the importance of education and appreciated her narrative about attending Catholic mission schools in Kenya and later pursuing higher education in the United States, her own trajectory as a highly educated elite raises important questions about the accessibility of such opportunities. Her educational journey was largely shaped by the Kennedy Airlift in the 1960s, a rare opportunity for many at the time. This issue of accessibility is further highlighted by her decision to send all three of her children to study in the United States, a choice that perpetuated her privileged status and underscores the disparity between her experiences and those of the average Kenyan. Maathai’s remarkable achievements and global recognition appear closely linked to her privileged educational background, fluency in English, and connections with developed nations like Norway and the United Kingdom. This raises the question of whether similar success would have been possible without these advantages and brings attention to the broader issue of accessibility for the average Kenyan.
While Maathai emphasizes her humble beginnings, coming from a rural family with her father working as a squatter on a colonial settler's farm, there is a noticeable lack of reflection on her position as a female African elite as the book progresses. Although she begins by centering rural women, who were integral to the early stages of the Green Belt Movement, their presence gradually fades as her narrative shifts toward her personal achievements and global recognition. Additionally, the memoir often underrepresents the collective efforts behind the success of the Green Belt Movement. While prominent figures such as Al Gore and Gordon Brown are mentioned, the book provides little insight into the key individuals who worked closely with her for years, such as staff members or the secretary general of the organization. This omission leaves readers with an incomplete understanding of the movement's collaborative nature and the people who played crucial roles in its achievements.
In conclusion, I highly recommend Unbowed to teenagers, activists, and educators who can draw inspiration from Maathai’s courageous initiatives and unwavering perseverance. Her memoir not only offers valuable lessons in leadership and activism but also provides a powerful testimony to Kenya’s transitional period from colonial rule to independence. As an African historian, I found the book particularly insightful, offering a unique perspective from a female activist who transcended national and continental boundaries, sharing her inspiring message of environmental conservation, social justice, and human rights on a global stage. Unbowed stands as an enduring testament to the power of one woman’s vision and the profound influence her activism has had on both local communities and global conversations about justice and sustainability.
Unbowed : A Memoir. by Wangari Maathai, New York: Alfred A. Knopf (314 pp.) $24.95 | 2006 ISBN 978-0307275202
Reviewed by Hyewon Hong, Ph.D. student, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Unbowed provides a vivid first-hand account of postcolonial Kenya, blending Wangari Maathai’s environmental advocacy with her broader struggle for human rights and democratic governance. In the post-independence era, Kenya aspired to progress and freedom but grappled with the lingering colonial legacies of the British Empire, including corruption, environmental degradation, and disregard for human rights. Maathai’s story reminded me of South Korean President Kim Dae-jung, as both endured political oppression by their respective governments and physical challenges resulting from detention and torture. However, Maathai’s story is particularly remarkable in how she became a unifying figure, addressing environmental, political, and social issues throughout Kenya’s post-independence history.
Written as an autobiography, this book appears designed to convey Maathai’s messages through the lens of her inspiring life, particularly following her receipt of the Nobel Peace Prize in 2004. Her story is especially relevant to our “20th Century African Intellectual History” course, as she contributes to postcolonial narratives not only in Kenya but across Africa and on the global stage. Maathai engaged directly with conversations around gender roles and expectations in Kenyan-African society—arguably in the form of a fight—by advocating for equal wages and benefits for female faculty members at the University of Nairobi in the 1960s and 1970s. Her ongoing efforts with the Green Belt Movement raised awareness about the importance of preserving forests and mountains, and encouraged action, no matter how small, from everyone. Therefore, it is fair to recognize that she has influenced not only African intellectual history but also the history of African activism, merging these two realms into a vibrant and practical force across the continent.
Maathai’s narrative also stands out as a powerful example of African women’s leadership, offering rare and authentic insights into the intersection of gender, politics, and environmentalism in Africa. One notable instance is when she reflects on the process of organizing the tree-planting movement. She considered several factors, such as the qualifications of the planters, whether specialized knowledge of flora was required, and whom to involve in the initiative. Despite being an elite woman with a higher education from the United States, Maathai chose to simplify the process by empowering rural women with basic tree-planting skills. This decision was remarkable, as rural women were often marginalized, considered illiterate, and largely disregarded in conventional societal roles. By trusting these women to lead local efforts, Maathai not only transformed environmental activism but also challenged gender norms and uplifted an overlooked segment of society.
In addition, Maathai’s holistic approach to activism is truly remarkable. While her initial motivation stemmed from witnessing environmental degradation, she saw her struggle for environmental protection as part of a broader movement for social justice, democracy, and human rights. Her personal experiences with government conflict and imprisonment deepened her empathy for marginalized groups, such as frustrated mothers fighting for their rights. Moreover, having lived through British colonialism in Kenya, she could relate to the struggles of Haitians facing environmental degradation and poverty amidst the challenges of nation-building and political instability. The book vividly illustrates her comprehensive approach, highlighting how interconnected environmental health, governance, and social equality are. This makes her work resonate not only with environmental activists but also with politicians and policymakers seeking holistic solutions to societal issues.
While this book is undoubtedly an inspiration for many readers, it also has some weaknesses. Throughout the memoir, Maathai, who was born and raised in rural Kenya, frequently contrasts the present state of Kenyan nature with its past, often reminiscing about the abundance, fertility, and verdant beauty she experienced in her childhood. She tends to romanticize the past—her upbringing and traditional wisdom—while portraying the developments and modernization efforts by the Kenyan government as predominantly negative. This dichotomy feels overly simplistic, as it overlooks the complexities and the potential grey areas that exist between tradition and progress. The challenges of modernization and environmental degradation are not always black and white, and a more nuanced exploration of these issues would have strengthened her argument.
Furthermore, while I fully support Maathai’s emphasis on the importance of education and appreciated her narrative about attending Catholic mission schools in Kenya and later pursuing higher education in the United States, her own trajectory as a highly educated elite raises important questions about the accessibility of such opportunities. Her educational journey was largely shaped by the Kennedy Airlift in the 1960s, a rare opportunity for many at the time. This issue of accessibility is further highlighted by her decision to send all three of her children to study in the United States, a choice that perpetuated her privileged status and underscores the disparity between her experiences and those of the average Kenyan. Maathai’s remarkable achievements and global recognition appear closely linked to her privileged educational background, fluency in English, and connections with developed nations like Norway and the United Kingdom. This raises the question of whether similar success would have been possible without these advantages and brings attention to the broader issue of accessibility for the average Kenyan.
While Maathai emphasizes her humble beginnings, coming from a rural family with her father working as a squatter on a colonial settler's farm, there is a noticeable lack of reflection on her position as a female African elite as the book progresses. Although she begins by centering rural women, who were integral to the early stages of the Green Belt Movement, their presence gradually fades as her narrative shifts toward her personal achievements and global recognition. Additionally, the memoir often underrepresents the collective efforts behind the success of the Green Belt Movement. While prominent figures such as Al Gore and Gordon Brown are mentioned, the book provides little insight into the key individuals who worked closely with her for years, such as staff members or the secretary general of the organization. This omission leaves readers with an incomplete understanding of the movement's collaborative nature and the people who played crucial roles in its achievements.
In conclusion, I highly recommend Unbowed to teenagers, activists, and educators who can draw inspiration from Maathai’s courageous initiatives and unwavering perseverance. Her memoir not only offers valuable lessons in leadership and activism but also provides a powerful testimony to Kenya’s transitional period from colonial rule to independence. As an African historian, I found the book particularly insightful, offering a unique perspective from a female activist who transcended national and continental boundaries, sharing her inspiring message of environmental conservation, social justice, and human rights on a global stage. Unbowed stands as an enduring testament to the power of one woman’s vision and the profound influence her activism has had on both local communities and global conversations about justice and sustainability.
See less
No comments:
Post a Comment