Monday, June 30, 2025

자신다 아던(Jacinda Ardern)의 회고록 『A Different Kind of Power』

ChatGPT - 동아시아의 평화와 화해

자신다 아던(Jacinda Ardern)의 회고록 『A Different Kind of Power』는 전 뉴질랜드 총리의 정치 여정을 감성적이고 인간적인 시선으로 풀어낸 작품입니다. 이 책은 전통적인 정치 회고록의 틀을 벗어나, 공감과 취약성을 통해 리더십을 재정의하고자 하는 아던의 철학을 담고 있습니다.


📘 책 개요


🌱 주요 내용 요약

1. 어린 시절과 형성기

아던은 뉴질랜드의 작은 마을 무루파라(Murupara)에서 경찰관 아버지와 함께 성장하며, 지역 사회의 빈곤과 폭력, 그리고 가족 내의 정신 건강 문제 등을 목격합니다. 이러한 경험은 그녀의 공감 중심의 정치 철학의 기초가 됩니다. 또한, 몰몬교 신앙과의 관계, 그리고 청소년기부터 시작된 정치 활동은 그녀의 리더십 스타일에 큰 영향을 미쳤습니다.bookmarks.reviews+5nzreviewofbooks.com+5telegraph.co.uk+5ketebooks.co.nz

2. 정치 여정과 리더십

아던은 37세의 나이에 뉴질랜드 역사상 가장 젊은 여성 총리로 취임합니다. 그녀는 크라이스트처치 모스크 총격 사건(2019), 화카아리 화산 폭발(2019), 그리고 COVID-19 팬데믹 등 여러 위기를 겪으며, 공감과 단호함을 기반으로 한 리더십을 발휘합니다. 특히, 총격 사건 이후의 총기 규제 강화와 팬데믹 대응은 국제적인 찬사를 받았습니다.kirkusreviews.comthebookshort.com

3. 개인적인 도전과 사임

총리 재임 중 임신과 출산을 경험한 아던은, 일과 가정의 균형을 맞추기 위해 노력합니다. 그러나 지속적인 정치적 압박과 개인적인 번아웃으로 인해 2023년 총리직에서 사임합니다. 그녀는 사임 결정을 통해 리더십의 새로운 형태를 제시하고자 합니다.


✍️ 평론 및 평가

『A Different Kind of Power』는 정치 회고록이면서도 자서전적인 요소가 강한 작품으로, 아던의 인간적인 면모와 리더십 철학을 깊이 있게 탐구합니다. 그녀는 공감과 취약성을 리더십의 강점으로 제시하며, 전통적인 권위 중심의 정치 문화를 재고하도록 독자를 이끕니다.

그러나 일부 평론가들은 책이 정치적 세부 사항이나 정책 분석보다는 개인적인 경험에 치중되어 있다고 지적합니다. 예를 들어, 『텔레그래프』는 "이 책은 350페이지에 달하는 치료 세션의 전사처럼 느껴진다"고 평가하며, 아던의 리더십이 감성에 치우쳐 있다는 비판을 제기합니다.

반면, 『워싱턴 포스트』는 아던의 공감 중심 리더십이 권위주의가 확산되는 세계에서 새로운 정치 모델을 제시한다고 평가하며, 그녀의 리더십 철학에 긍정적인 시각을 보입니다.


🎯 결론

『A Different Kind of Power』는 전통적인 정치 회고록과는 다른 접근을 통해, 공감과 취약성을 기반으로 한 리더십의 가능성을 탐구합니다. 아던의 개인적인 경험과 정치적 여정을 통해, 독자들은 현대 정치에서 인간적인 리더십의 중요성을 다시금 생각하게 됩니다. 정치, 리더십, 그리고 공감에 관심 있는 독자들에게 추천할 만한 작품입니다.

====


====

이 책을 오디오북으로 듣고 있었는데, 오래 동안 중단해서 여러가지 느낀 것도 있지만, 그것들을 잊어먹기 시작했어요. 
만약에 세진이 이 책을 읽고 요점과 평론을 썼다면 뭔가 다른 걸 쓸까요?

ChatGPT의 말: 

세진님이 『A Different Kind of Power』를 오디오북으로 들으시다가 한동안 멈추셨다면, 그 공백 속에서 느꼈던 감정과 사유의 결들이 책의 본문 못지않게 소중한 독서의 일부였을 거예요. 그리고 만약 세진님이 직접 이 책을 요약하고 평론했다면, 다음과 같은 ‘다른 종류의 글’이 나왔을 가능성이 큽니다.


📖 세진의 시선으로 본 『A Different Kind of Power』 요점과 평론

1. 리더십의 본질에 대한 질문: ‘힘’은 무엇인가?

세진님은 단순히 아던의 성공담이나 위기 대처 능력을 나열하기보다는, 이 책이 던지는 근본적인 물음 ― “진정한 힘이란 무엇인가?” ― 에 집중했을 것 같습니다.
아던의 ‘다른 종류의 힘’은 권위나 지배가 아니라, 공감, 경청, 그리고 사임할 줄 아는 용기에서 비롯된다는 점이 세진님께는 깊이 와닿았을 것 같아요.

➡️ 세진님의 평론 한 줄 요약:
“아던은 강한 지도자가 아니라, 약할 줄 아는 지도자였다. 나는 그 속에서 오히려 더 큰 힘을 본다.”


2. ‘사임’을 통해 드러난 성찰의 윤리

세진님은 2023년 아던의 사임을 회피가 아니라 윤리적 성찰의 실천으로 보았을 가능성이 높습니다.
정치인이 “내 안에 더 이상 충분한 에너지가 없다”고 고백하는 것은, 세진님이 중요하게 여기는 진실성과 자각의 리더십과 일맥상통합니다.
그건 ‘자기 돌봄(self-care)’의 실천이자, 공동체에 해가 되지 않으려는 책임감이기도 하니까요.

➡️ 이 부분에서 세진님은 아마 이런 문장을 썼을지도 모릅니다:
“사임은 도피가 아니라 사랑이었다. 자신을, 그리고 함께했던 사람들을 위해.”


3. 정치 너머의 정치: 감정과 돌봄의 정치학

세진님의 관심은 늘 구조와 제도뿐 아니라 감정의 층위에도 깊게 닿아 있죠.
그렇다면 아던이 총격 사건 이후 히잡을 쓰고 희생자 가족을 껴안았던 장면, 팬데믹 초기 투명한 언어로 국민들과 매일 소통했던 순간은, 단순한 퍼포먼스가 아니라 감정노동과 돌봄의 정치로 읽혔을 겁니다.

➡️ 세진님은 이런 평을 곁들였을 수도 있습니다:
“우리는 정치에서 감정의 언어를 배제해왔지만, 아던은 슬픔과 두려움을 품은 채 정치를 했다. 나는 그 모습이 우리 시대 가장 필요한 ‘공감 기반 정치’라고 생각한다.”


4. 신념과 무신념 사이에서의 균형

책에서 아던은 몰몬교와의 관계, 그리고 점차 탈종교화되는 과정을 조용히 고백합니다.
세진님은 이런 영적 여정을 단순한 이탈로 보지 않고, 믿음에 대한 주체적 탐색으로 받아들였을 것 같습니다.
종교를 ‘소속’보다 ‘깨어남의 여정’으로 보는 세진님의 관점은, 아던의 변화와 공명했을 가능성이 높아요.

➡️ 그리고 이렇게 덧붙였을지도요:
“나는 그녀가 믿음을 버렸다고 생각하지 않는다. 오히려 ‘새로운 방식으로 믿기’를 시작한 것이다.”


5. 세진님의 메모리에 남았던 장면

혹시 세진님이 중단 전에 마음에 남아 있던 장면이 있다면 (예: 화산폭발 대처, 출산 중 총리직 수행, 밤에 아이를 안고 인터뷰하던 장면 등),
그 장면은 책 전체의 서사보다 훨씬 깊이 세진님 마음속에 남아 있을 수 있습니다.
그 기억은 서사적 요약에는 포함되지 않지만, 세진님만의 평론적 해석에는 중심이 되는 장면이었을 것입니다.


📝 결론: 세진님이 썼다면

『A Different Kind of Power』에 대한 세진님의 평론은 아마 다음과 같았을 것입니다:

"이 책은 단지 여성 총리의 성공담이 아니다.
그것은 한 사람이 정치 속에서 자신을 잃지 않고 살아내기 위한 고백이다.
나 또한 내 삶의 리더십을 다시 묻는다.
나에게도 다른 종류의 힘이 있을까?"


세진님, 혹시 이 책을 들으시며 떠오른 문장이나 장면이 있다면 말씀해 주실 수 있나요? 함께 그 기억을 살려볼 수 있어요.



A Different Kind of Power by Jacinda Ardern - Penguin Books Australia

A Different Kind of Power by Jacinda Ardern - Penguin Books Australia
A Different Kind of Power
Read an extract
Play audio sample
Play sample
Published: 3 June 2025
I
Memoirs
A Different Kind of Power
A memoir
From the former prime minister of New Zealand, then the world’s youngest female head of government and just the second to give birth in office, comes a deeply personal memoir chronicling her extraordinary rise and offering inspiration to a new generation of leaders.


What if we could redefine leadership? What if kindness came first? Jacinda Ardern grew up the daughter of a police officer, a Mormon girl plagued by self-doubt. But as prime minister she commanded worldwide respect for her empathetic leadership, made political history, and changed our assumptions about what a global leader can be.


When Jacinda Ardern became prime minister at age thirty-seven, the world took notice. But it was her compassionate, powerful response to the 2019 Christchurch mosque attacks, resulting in swift gun-control reforms, that exemplified a new kind of leadership—one that is caring and effective. She guided New Zealand through unprecedented challenges—a volcanic eruption, a major biosecurity breach, and a global pandemic—and advanced visionary new policies to address climate change, reduce child poverty, and secure historic international trade deals. She did this all while juggling first-time motherhood in the public eye.


She is a global icon, and now in this remarkable book she shares her story, from the struggles to the surprises, including the full details of her decision to step down during her sixth year as prime minister.


Jacinda Ardern is a model for anyone who has ever doubted themselves or has aspired to lead with compassion, conviction, and courage. A Different Kind of Power is more than a political memoir; it’s an insight into how it feels to lead, ultimately asking: What if you, too, are capable of more than you ever imagined?


Read less
About the author
Jacinda Ardern


Jacinda Ardern was elected prime minister of New Zealand in 2017 at the age of thirty-seven and became the country’s youngest prime minister in more than 150 years. In 2018, she gave birth to her daughter, Neve, and became the first leader of a country in thirty years to give birth while in office. In 2023, she was awarded the accolade Dame Grand Companion of the New Zealand Order of Merit. She now spends her time writing, speaking, learning, and being a mum. You can follow Jacinda Ardern
on Instagram and X @JacindaArdern.
Read less
portrait photo of Jacinda Ardern
Also by Jacinda Ardern
Mum's Busy Work
Praise for A Different Kind of Power
A Different Kind of Power is the story of the forces that have shaped Jacinda Ardern and the intentional effort she has put into creating a new template for the next generation of leaders to follow. Ardern’s insightful and inspiring memoir challenges old definitions of strength and power by emphasizing the urgency of compassion and kindness. World leaders have a lot to learn from her timely and important perspective.


Melinda Gates, author of The Moment of Lift
It is rare enough to find someone who lives an inspiring life of genuine service to humanity; it is even rarer to find that they’ve written a beautiful book that will inspire others. Jacinda Ardern’s A Different Kind of Power is just such a book. I could not put down this deeply personal memoir by an icon who insists on being a real person. Like the memoirs of Barack Obama and Gloria Steinem, this book has the power to inspire a new generation of passionate leaders and readers. You don’t have to be interested in politics to devour this book; you might be interested in how women dare to mother and lead at the same time; you might be interested in bravery, and a life well-lived.


Sarah Ruhl, author of Smile




Show all




==
A Different Kind of Power
by Jacinda Ardern
'Will this book change the minds of the crazies?'
By Philip MatthewsJune 8, 2025
To understand the adult, look at the child. Jacinda Ardern grew up in the most ordinary of New Zealand circumstances: in a simple house in a small town, with decent, modest, hard-working parents, an older sister and a grey rescue cat named Norm. Her father was a cop; her mother was smart enough to go to university but never did. They were Mormons. They drove a beige Toyota Corona. They weren’t rich: almost all of Ardern’s clothes were home-made or hand-me-downs.


This was in Murupara, a small forestry town in the Bay of Plenty that was in decline by the time the Ardern family moved there, and that is where Ardern sets the first chapters of her memoir, A Different Kind of Power. And by the way, she really can write. This is how it starts:


You could drive for fifty kilometres in the Kāingaroa Forest and wonder if there’s anything left on Earth besides trees. That’s the view: radiata pines, each standing thirty metres tall, in tidy gridlines that extend as far as the eye can see. The forest is as vast as it is dense: tree upon tree, row upon row, kilometre upon kilometre.


Murupara was a small clearing in those vast, dense forests. It was also a gang town, and it had been hit hard by the fourth Labour Government’s economic reforms. Years later, when a journalist asked Ardern how she was politicised, she said it came from her time in Murupara, even though she was only primary school-aged then. The idea that she witnessed or at least sensed the kind of deprivation that was unleashed when Rogernomics made forestry workers unemployed and led to closed-up shops on the main street is a pretty easy conclusion to reach, but there is a different kind of politics.


The young Ardern was anxious and watchful. Her father was a good cop but she witnessed a tense scene between him and some gang members that never left her. Her older sister was bullied and the young Ardern became her defender. Her mother suffered from poor mental health and Ardern noticed. There is a sense of a small, decent family surrounded by danger (gangs, school bullies, mental health crises, even the dark forest beyond the clearing) with the young Ardern trying to protect them. She wanted to help; that was her politics. It wasn’t about doctrines or books – not until she started volunteering for the Labour Party at university – but it was always about wanting to keep people safe and perhaps caring too much. When she started using the word ‘kindness’ in politics, she immediately thought of Murupara.


You can trace the line from the kid who worried about everyone else to the prime minister who wanted to embrace the Muslim community, who wanted to bring kids out of poverty and give them warm homes, who wanted to keep all of New Zealand safe from a rampant virus and was finally defeated because some people simply resisted being cared for, or saw mandates and QR codes as a form of fascism. That is the clearest reading of the Jacinda Ardern story. It is why the book is dedicated to ‘the criers, worriers and huggers’, the other people like her.


The story is easy to mock because it only works if you believe politics can sometimes be motivated by an innate sense of goodness, rather than cynicism or self-interest. The idea of kindness as the basis of politics was and still is ridiculed; some are unable to trust well-meaning expressions of sensitivity and concern. That meant Ardern’s politics were characterised instead as childish, shallow, naive, all about rainbows and unicorns and hugs and tears, which is not just patronising and probably misogynistic, but ignores the reality that Ardern was also a thinker who put in the hard work and the long hours – partly because she was terrified of getting things wrong and being found out (‘My whole short life I had grappled with the idea that I was never quite good enough’). She wasn’t a show pony or an airhead.


As you read A Different Kind of Power, you warm to this person, to her empathy, her nervousness, her doubt, her idealism, her ‘grinding sense of responsibility’, her thoughtfulness, her self-deprecation. We all know people like this; some of us are people like this. Her father worried she was too thin-skinned for politics, and maybe he was right. There is a touching moment when a very nice high-school teacher, Mr Fountain, tells her about something called ‘impostor syndrome’. A self-diagnosis followed.


After Murupara, the family moved to Morrinsville, ‘the dairy farming town I will forever call home’. They live on an orchard, with a forest on one side and a golf course on the other, and it sounds idyllic but Ardern has a knack for describing the way tragedy can suddenly intrude into family life. Of course, she noticed everything, and remembered it all, and she experienced stress in childhood as persistent stomach-aches (‘I wasn’t sick, it turned out. I was worried.’). As a teenager, the suicide of a friend’s brother had her asking hard questions about her faith, but she remained in the Mormon church, and hours of door-knocking prepared her for a life in the Labour Party:


While I might have struggled with starting conversations about God and sometimes even politics, I would learn that if I was there to ask someone about their lives, what would make a difference to them – well, that I could do. That I wanted to do.


There were other, greater emotional burdens later. Her sections on the Christchurch mosque shootings are as powerful as you would expect. She writes about feeling ‘a sorrow so immense that even now, years later, there are still no words to describe it’.


The book is skilfully written and even suspenseful. Ardern is good at describing people in quick sketches. Grant Robertson is friendly and dishevelled. Helen Clark is an intimidating superhuman with a dry sense of humour who has the same lunch every day (an egg sandwich and a cup of tea). Andrew Little is a quiet man whose office was always too cold. Simon Bridges is easy and affable. Scott Morrison is dozy and indifferent. Only Winston Peters remains enigmatic. No surprise.


And then there is David Cunliffe. The politician who led Labour to a catastrophic defeat in 2014 comes across as self-absorbed, grandiose and ridiculous. That includes his famous apology for being a man, which seems to have been experienced as a seismic shock by other Labour MPs on the campaign trail (‘He did what?’). Ardern’s basic goodness makes the passages about Cunliffe even more devastating.


From 2017 on, the beats are familiar. There was her defining takedown of TV host Mark Richardson, whom she calls ‘the man who read the sports news’, soon after she became leader. Outraged by his commentary about employers deserving to know if women plan to have babies, she was ‘a hot ball of anger’ by the time she sat across from him in the studio. That moment was anticipated by an earlier and less successful one, when she angrily confronted some rude Victoria University students who were heckling Helen Clark. ‘Control your woman,’ one of them shouted at MP Steve Maharey, who was with Ardern.


Some other foreshadowing may seem a little clunky to some readers. When she writes about the success of the government’s M. bovis eradication strategy, she is also preparing readers for why we needed to eliminate rather than live with Covid-19. An early encounter with a conspiracy theorist while working in Phil Goff’s office anticipates a future world in which all the lonely, distressed, angry people could find each other and be manipulated by people who ‘played on their distress for their own gain’. Imagine that.


It’s sad that it remains impossible to be neutral about Ardern two and a half years after she abruptly left New Zealand politics. The idea of a ‘derangement syndrome’ was coined for George W. Bush – and has been applied to John Key and Donald Trump – but it fits Ardern better than any world leader. Something about her does indeed derange people; they literally go mad. You only need to read some of the comments on reviews of this book in the days after it was published, or even some of the reviews themselves, to see that syndrome in action.


Positions on her cut to the core of character. Praise her and you are seen as a sap who is easily tricked by spin and the politics of kindness; on the other side, there is the mob who drew Hitler moustaches, swastikas and nooses on pictures of Ardern, and who were inspired to dig up Parliament’s lawn, throw paving stones at police and burn down trees and a children’s slide, having been liberated from any kind of decency and restraint by the example of the crowd who stormed the US Capitol a little over a year earlier.


Will this book change the minds of the crazies? If they dare to read it, they won’t find a tyrant here. They will find someone who tried to do the right thing, but doubted herself – and still doubts herself. They will find someone who is earnest, but not completely. They will find someone who is not pious, but funny about herself and others. Sometimes she is funny in a classically understated, Kiwi way, as in her description of Murupara before Rogernomics: ‘By 1980, Murupara’s downtown was bustling with not one but two fish-and-chip shops.’


She is not entirely saintly. She can also have a dig when it’s appropriate, as in this fine passage about the days after the mosque shootings:


Someone had called me ‘New Zealand’s chief mourner’. At the time I wasn’t sure how I felt about this. Was I the chief mourner? And was that a good thing? I’d been trying to focus on the grief of those who’d been most affected. But a journalist had recently asked me if I cried at night when I went home. Of course I cried at home. On the night of the attack, I returned to Premier House, long after Neve had gone to sleep, I’d found Clarke waiting for me at the end of the hall, and I’d cried into his shoulder for what felt like an eternity. But I wasn’t going to tell that to Barry Soper of Newstalk ZB.


Beautifully done. By the way, that ‘someone’ was probably Masha Gessen in the New Yorker, who thought Ardern had ‘staged a revolution’ in the way she responded to the mosque attacks. The sad truth is that Americans get her more than we do.




A Different Kind of Power: A Memoir


by Jacinda Ardern


Penguin


ISBN: 9780593728697


Published: June 2025


Format: Hardcover, 352 pages


Philip Matthews
Philip Matthews is a journalist who lives in Christchurch. He won Best Reviewer at the Voyager Media Awards in 2022 and is the author of The Quiet Hero (Allen & Unwin, 2023), about the life and death of New Zealand aid worker Andrew Bagshaw in Ukraine.
==


==

A Different Kind of Power by Jacinda Ardern



When Vulnerability Becomes Leadership's Greatest Strength

Genre:Memoir


A Different Kind of Power succeeds as both personal memoir and political manifesto. Ardern has created a work that is simultaneously intimate and universal, specific to New Zealand's context yet relevant to anyone grappling with questions of moral leadership in challenging times.






Top 5 This Week



A Reader’s Love Affair with Emily Henry Books



When the Sky Fell on Splendor by Emily Henry



Hello Girls by Emily Henry and Brittany Cavallaro



The Love That Split the World by Emily Henry



Funny Story by Emily Henry


Related Posts


When the Sky Fell on Splendor by Emily Henry
Young-Adult

Hello Girls by Emily Henry and Brittany Cavallaro
Young-Adult

The Love That Split the World by Emily Henry
Romance

Funny Story by Emily Henry
Romance

Happy Place by Emily Henry
Romance

Beach Read by Emily Henry
Romance





Author:Bookclb
9 min.read



In an era where political memoirs often read like carefully orchestrated victory laps, Jacinda Ardern’s A Different Kind of Power emerges as something genuinely unexpected: a raw, introspective examination of what it means to lead with humanity intact. This isn’t the sanitized account of a former world leader protecting their legacy—it’s the honest confession of someone who discovered that their greatest perceived weakness might actually be their most powerful tool.
The Architecture of Empathy

Ardern’s narrative architecture mirrors her approach to leadership: methodical, thoughtful, and surprisingly vulnerable. “A Different Kind of Power” traces her journey from a car-sick four-year-old in the back of a Toyota Corona to becoming the world’s youngest female head of government at thirty-seven. But this isn’t a simple rags-to-riches political tale. Instead, Ardern constructs her story like a series of concentric circles, each chapter adding depth to our understanding of how a “thin-skinned” Mormon girl from small-town New Zealand came to embody a new paradigm of leadership.

The book’s strength lies in its willingness to linger in uncomfortable moments. Ardern doesn’t rush past her struggles with faith, her fertility challenges, or her moments of crushing self-doubt. She inhabits these experiences fully, allowing readers to understand how they shaped her approach to governance. When she describes leaving the Mormon church—something that “felt like home”—we witness the kind of moral courage that would later define her political career.
Small-Town Foundations, Global Implications

The early chapters set in Murupara are particularly compelling. Ardern paints this forestry town with the careful brushstrokes of someone who understood, even as a child, that she was witnessing something profound about inequality and community resilience. Her father’s approach to policing—believing that “you can’t arrest your way out of everything”—becomes a lens through which we can view Ardern’s later policies on social justice and community healing.

These formative experiences in a predominantly Māori community, where her family was both integral to and separate from the social fabric, created what she calls her political awakening. It’s here that Ardern learned to navigate being simultaneously insider and outsider—a skill that would serve her well in navigating New Zealand’s complex cultural landscape as Prime Minister.
The Paradox of Sensitivity in Power

Perhaps the memoir’s most fascinating thread is Ardern’s lifelong struggle with what she perceived as her “tragic flaw”—her sensitivity. Throughout the book, she wrestles with the conventional wisdom that effective leaders must develop thick skin. Her journey toward recognizing sensitivity as strength rather than weakness becomes the book’s central theme and its most valuable insight.

This reframing reaches its crescendo in her handling of the Christchurch mosque attacks. Ardern’s decision to wear a hijab and declare “they are us” wasn’t political calculation—it was instinctive empathy. Her detailed account of meeting with Imam Lateef Zikrullah Alabi, whose robes were still stained with blood, demonstrates how vulnerability can create space for healing that traditional political responses cannot.
Crisis Leadership Through a Human Lens

The book’s treatment of the COVID-19 pandemic offers perhaps the most detailed insider account of democratic crisis management available. Ardern reveals the impossible mathematics of leadership during uncertainty: making decisions with incomplete information while bearing responsibility for millions of lives. Her approach—prioritizing health outcomes over economic considerations—wasn’t just policy; it was a reflection of her core belief that government exists to protect its most vulnerable citizens.

Her description of working from home during lockdown, with toddler Neve creating chaos in the background of Zoom calls, perfectly encapsulates the memoir’s central tension: how do you balance being fully human with being fully present as a leader?
The Weight of Representation

One of the book’s most powerful sections deals with the burden of being “firsts”—first female leader to give birth in office, youngest female head of government. Ardern doesn’t shy away from the additional pressures these distinctions created. Her midnight struggles with the Australian Women’s Weekly Birthday Cake Book, determined to prove she could be both Prime Minister and proper mum, reveal the impossible standards society places on women in leadership.

The memoir’s treatment of sexism is particularly nuanced. Rather than focusing on overt discrimination, Ardern explores the subtler ways gender shaped her experience—from media questions about her reproductive plans to the different standards by which her emotional responses were judged.
Literary Craft and Political Insight

Ardern’s background as a speechwriter serves her well as a memoirist. Her prose is clear and engaging, with moments of genuine literary beauty. Her description of the violin that traveled from Scotland to New Zealand with her great-grandmother becomes a metaphor for the stories we carry forward. The recurring image of her father’s police work—listening before acting—provides a throughline that connects her childhood observations to her governing philosophy.

The book excels in its specificity. Rather than broad proclamations about leadership, Ardern offers granular details: the feel of car sickness on childhood road trips, the weight of a bulletproof vest during the Christchurch response, the particular exhaustion of making life-and-death decisions while sleep-deprived.
The Decision to Leave: Leadership’s Ultimate Act

The book’s final act—Ardern’s decision to resign as Prime Minister—provides its most complex and controversial content. Her explanation that her “tank was empty” has drawn criticism from some quarters, but the memoir reveals this decision as perhaps her most profound act of leadership. By stepping aside when she could no longer give her best, Ardern demonstrated a kind of political integrity rarely seen in contemporary democracy.

Her conversation with five-year-old Neve, who tells her “we should never give up,” provides the book’s most heartbreaking moment. It’s a reminder that even leaders who prioritize family face impossible choices about what they owe to their children versus what they owe to their country.
Critical Reflections and Limitations

While A Different Kind of Power succeeds as both memoir and leadership meditation, it occasionally suffers from a certain earnestness that borders on self-righteousness. Ardern’s commitment to empathetic leadership is admirable, but the book sometimes presents this approach as unquestionably superior without fully grappling with its limitations or failures.

The memoir also tends to gloss over some of the more controversial aspects of her tenure, including housing affordability crises and immigration policies that drew criticism from human rights advocates. While this is understandable in a personal memoir, it sometimes makes the book feel incomplete as a historical record.

Additionally, Ardern’s writing occasionally lapses into political speak, particularly when discussing policy achievements. These sections lack the emotional honesty that makes the personal passages so compelling.
A New Template for Political Leadership

Despite these limitations, A Different Kind of Power succeeds in its larger ambition: redefining what effective leadership can look like. Ardern’s model—leading with empathy, acknowledging uncertainty, prioritizing long-term wellbeing over short-term political gain—offers a template for governance that feels both revolutionary and deeply traditional.

Her approach to the Christchurch attacks and COVID-19 pandemic demonstrates that “soft” qualities like compassion and humility can produce “hard” results like social cohesion and public health outcomes. This isn’t touchy-feely leadership; it’s strategically empathetic governance.
Global Resonance in Troubled Times

The memoir arrives at a moment when democracies worldwide are grappling with declining trust in institutions and rising polarization. Ardern’s model of leadership—transparent about uncertainty, willing to admit mistakes, comfortable with showing emotion—offers an alternative to the strongman politics that has dominated recent global discourse.

Her emphasis on kindness as a political virtue feels particularly relevant as societies struggle with division and animosity. The book makes a compelling case that kindness isn’t weakness—it’s the foundation for building the social trust that effective governance requires.
Literary Merit and Emotional Honesty

As a work of literature, the memoir succeeds through its commitment to emotional honesty. Ardern’s willingness to share her struggles with fertility, faith, and self-doubt creates intimate moments that transcend politics. Her description of crying into her partner’s shoulder after the Christchurch attacks, or her panic about making the perfect birthday cake for Neve, reveals the human cost of public service.

The book’s structure, moving between personal reflection and policy discussion, creates a rhythm that mirrors the actual experience of leadership—the constant shift between intimate human moments and weighty public responsibilities.
Comparative Context: A Different Kind of Political Memoir

A Different Kind of Power stands apart from other recent political memoirs through its willingness to examine failure and uncertainty. Unlike books that seek to justify every decision, Ardern’s memoir acknowledges moments of doubt and paths not taken. This honesty makes her successes more meaningful and her perspective more trustworthy.

The book joins a small but growing canon of memoirs that prioritize emotional intelligence over political calculation. It shares DNA with works like Kamala Harris’ The Truths We Hold or Pramila Jayapal’s Use the Power You Have and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s approach to political communication—leaders who refuse to separate their humanity from their public service.
Lessons for Future Leaders

The memoir’s most valuable contribution may be its practical insights for aspiring leaders. Ardern’s emphasis on building diverse teams, listening before speaking, and maintaining perspective during crisis offers a masterclass in emotional intelligence applied to governance.

Her approach to decision-making—gathering multiple perspectives, acknowledging uncertainty, communicating clearly about trade-offs—provides a template for leadership in complex, uncertain environments. These lessons extend far beyond politics to any context requiring moral leadership.
Recommended Reading for Political Leadership

For readers interested in similar explorations of empathetic leadership, several works complement Ardern’s memoir:The Power of Moments by Chip Heath and Dan Heath – explores how leaders can create defining moments
Daring Greatly by Brené Brown – examines vulnerability as a leadership strength
Team of Rivals by Doris Kearns Goodwin – Lincoln’s approach to inclusive leadership
The Righteous Mind by Jonathan Haidt – understanding moral psychology in governance
Option B by Sheryl Sandberg – resilience and leadership through adversity
Final Verdict: A Necessary Voice for Our Times

A Different Kind of Power succeeds as both personal memoir and political manifesto. Ardern has created a work that is simultaneously intimate and universal, specific to New Zealand’s context yet relevant to anyone grappling with questions of moral leadership in challenging times.

The book’s greatest achievement is demonstrating that vulnerability and strength are not opposing forces but complementary aspects of effective leadership. In an era of performative toughness and manufactured certainty, Ardern’s willingness to admit uncertainty and show emotion feels revolutionary.

While the memoir occasionally suffers from its earnestness and glosses over some controversial aspects of her tenure, it ultimately succeeds in its larger mission: expanding our understanding of what leadership can be. This is essential reading for anyone interested in the future of democratic governance and the possibility that politics might yet be a force for healing rather than division.

Ardern has given us not just a memoir but a meditation on power’s true purpose: not to aggrandize the leader but to serve the led. In our fractured political moment, this message feels both timely and timeless—a reminder that the different kind of power Ardern practiced might just be the kind our world desperately needs.
==

==

Sunday, June 29, 2025

미국과 호주에서의 유색인 여성, 특히 동아시아계와 기타 이민자 여성 비교

ChatGPT - 동아시아의 평화와 화해
미국과 호주의 경우, 유색인 이민 계통 여성을 동아시아 계통과 그 외를 구분하여 비교해서 분석해주세요 .
ChatGPT의 말:

아래는 미국과 호주에서의 유색인 여성, 특히 동아시아계와 기타 이민자 여성교육·고용·사회적 지위를 비교 분석한 내용입니다. 분석은 다음의 4대 영역을 중심으로 진행됩니다:

  1. 교육 성취도

  2. 노동시장 진입과 직종 분포

  3. 유리천장 및 권력 진입

  4. 사회문화적 정체성과 차별 구조


🇺🇸 미국: 동아시아계 vs. 기타 유색인 이민 여성

1. 교육

  • 동아시아계 여성 (한국·중국·일본계)은 고등교육 진학률이 매우 높으며, STEM·의학·법률·예술 등 다양한 분야에서 두각.

    • "모범적 소수민족" 신화에 묶여 있음.

  • 기타 유색인 여성 (흑인, 히스패닉, 남아시아 이외의 중동·아프리카계)은 상대적으로 교육 진입률 낮고, 교육 기회의 지역 간 격차와 사회적 구조 장벽 많음.

2. 노동시장

  • 동아시아계 여성은 전문직(의사, 교수, 기술자) 비중 높으나, 관리직·리더십에는 덜 진출.

  • 기타 유색인 여성은 서비스직, 저임금 노동, 돌봄 분야 비율 높고, 구조적 실업과 임금 불평등에 노출됨.

3. 유리천장

  • 동아시아 여성은 겉보기에 성공적이지만, ‘조용하고 순응적인’ 이미지가 리더십 진입을 막는 문화적 유리천장 존재.

  • 흑인 여성은 더 강한 정체성 표현과 저항을 통해 일부 정치권·문화계에 진입했으나, 정책권력 및 경제권력에선 여전히 배제됨.

4. 사회문화적 이미지

  • 동아시아 여성은 종종 성적 대상화 또는 이국적 이미지로 소비되며, 미국 사회 내 성차별+인종차별의 교차점에 있음.

  • 기타 유색인 여성은 범죄화, 복지의존 이미지로 낙인찍히는 경우 많으며, 종교적(무슬림) 편견도 겹침.


🇦🇺 호주: 동아시아계 vs. 기타 유색인 이민 여성

1. 교육

  • 동아시아계 여성은 대체로 고학력, 고성취, 특히 국립대/명문대 진입률 높음.

    • 부모 세대의 교육 중시와 유학 후 이민 경로에서 비롯.

  • 기타 이민 여성 (중동, 아프리카, 아일랜드계 혼혈, 남태평양계)은 교육 격차 존재, 지역별 격차 큼. 성인 여성의 경우 재취학/직업훈련 과정 참여 비율 높음.

2. 노동시장

  • 동아시아계 여성은 기업 내 전문직이나 학술계 진입에서 성공적이나, 호주 기업의 ‘문화적 맞춤형 리더십’ 진입은 제한적.

  • 기타 유색인 여성은 보건, 노인 돌봄, 청소, 요식업 등에 집중되며, 비정규직화 비율 높음.

3. 유리천장

  • 호주는 공식적 제도에서는 다문화주의를 표방하나, 실제 ‘호주적 정체성’과 리더십에 적응한 아시아계만 승진하는 구조 존재.

  • 비동아시아계 유색인 여성은 **호주의 주류 노동문화(영어표현, 리더십 스타일, 외모 코드 등)**에 적응하는 데서 더 큰 장벽 존재.

4. 문화적 차별

  • 동아시아 여성은 종종 ‘열심히 일하되, 침묵하는 존재’로 기대됨, 문화적 개성은 무시됨.

  • 중동·아프리카계 여성은 무슬림 커뮤니티 정체성과 호주의 세속적/백인 주류와의 마찰 속에서 이중적 고립 경험.


🧭 비판적 통찰

1. ‘모범적 소수민족’ 신화의 이면

  • 동아시아계 여성은 표면적으로 성공했지만, 이는 자기 표현 억제, 정치적 무표현, 리더십 진입 회피로 유지되는 불안정한 성공.

  • 이 신화는 다른 유색인 집단과의 연대를 방해하고, 차별 구조를 강화함.

2. 교차성 (Intersectionality)의 실천 과제

  • 유색인 여성은 성별, 인종, 계급, 이민 신분, 종교 정체성이 중첩된 억압 구조 속에서 살아감.

  • 단일한 "여성 권리" 담론은 백인 중산층 여성 기준으로 구성되어 있어, 비서구 여성에게 불충분함.

3. 정치적 대표성과 언어

  • 미국과 호주 모두 동아시아 여성의 정치 진출은 극히 제한적.

  • 여성들의 경험과 요구는 정치적으로 '번역되지 않거나, 대변되지 않음' — 특히 비영어 모국어 사용자의 경우 심각.


✒ 결론

동아시아계 여성은 교육과 소득에서 상위지만, 문화적/정치적 침묵을 강요당하는 경향이 강하고, 기타 유색인 여성은 제도 바깥에서 실존을 증명하며 살아가는 이중 소외 구조에 있다.

미국과 호주의 여성 이민자는 단일 집단이 아니라, 서로 다른 정체성, 교육 자본, 언어, 문화 압력을 지닌 복합체입니다. 성공의 외양 아래 감춰진 차별의 경로들을 교차적으로 이해하는 것이, 진정한 다문화 젠더 정의로 나아가는 첫걸음이 될 것입니다.


원하신다면 이를 정책 제안, 퀘이커적/윤리적 관점, 또는 학술적 비교 논문 개요 형태로 재구성해드릴 수 있습니다.

ChatGPT는 실수를 할 수 있습니다. 중요한 정